This is next to a great grocery market in the area (small "town") - bought a few years back (it's the old Fella's in West Tisbury) ; nestled in between the only grocery open year round close to up-island and next to the post office, also the only one in area that services this small town of mostly farm land. It was discovery of a coworker who was ranting about their bfast sandwiches- YEA - they are pretty spectacularly tasty!! I have had 4 items from this menu and today... I tried the pizza- I ATE THE CRUST - soft enough with a slight crunch - perfect dough, sauce was seasoned and is homemade- excellent. Best lil' spot to catch a quick bite. They are a slice app customer!!! Excellent!
Tom Christopher
Brazilian lunch spot.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Alexander Dimovich
I Would not recommend. Tried out the Italian and a burger. Italian was lack luster and drenched in dressing. Burger was a small over cooked and flavorless premade patty and for $11 you would expect a side of fries. Staff was also unfriendly. Will not be coming back.
DOUGLAS MACHADO
A perfect place with great service, fast delivery of orders and fair prices.
Doyle Bunch
very good breakfast sandwiches, lunch sandwiches. great pastries and we really enjoy Friday pizza night
cabtabsab
I visited each morning during my weeks vacation in the island at the recommendation of the landlord we rented from. The staff was super friendly and kind, my daughter lived giving them a high five each morning. The coffee and pastries were good. Location was convenient to where we were renting. Would definitely visit again.
Justin Stevens
Never open. Turned away at counter.
Josh Tucker
I always like going here, the staff is friendly and the food is good
Marina Kofman
CLAMBAKE GALORE!!! Fella's catered my brother's destination wedding welcome dinner. We were looking for something casual, inviting, local & of course tasty. Boy did Fella deliver! 2 months later, the guests are still talking about the most delicious lobster they've ever had. The whole family was EXTREMELY accommodating to this very last minute wedding, during Covid and us having to change adjust time/location of the event a few times. The whole team was organized & pleasant. And let's not forget the homemade brownies as a perfect finisher to this scrumptious meal. It was the most perfect evening. Thank you Fella's!
Andrew Luce
Very small portions. My Italian sub had a single piece of ham, salami and cheese. My wife’s turkey sandwich had two slices of turkey. It would be too much to pay $7 a sandwich but instead they cost $10.50 and $11.50. Don’t bother getting a sandwich here.
Me and my family love this pizza place. The sausage and mushroom is extremely tasty and I love their crust.
Super Muñeco Zuñiga
Very good food!
Tehya Backus-Clement
Me and my family love this pizza place. The sausage and mushroom is extremely tasty and I love their crust.
Duncan R
Every Saturday we take out dogs to Fella's and order two breakfast sandwiches that we share with the dogs. One is a burrito with bacon egg and cheese and one is a croissant with sausage egg and chees. Not only do we love them but so do the dogs who get small bites of ours. We've also had their baked goods, lunch sandwiches, pizza and muffins. As locals we tell you you can't go wrong her for take out.
This is next to a great grocery market in the area (small "town") - bought a few years back (it's the old Fella's in West Tisbury) ; nestled in between the only grocery open year round close to up-island and next to the post office, also the only one in area that services this small town of mostly farm land. It was discovery of a coworker who was ranting about their bfast sandwiches- YEA - they are pretty spectacularly tasty!! I have had 4 items from this menu and today... I tried the pizza- I ATE THE CRUST - soft enough with a slight crunch - perfect dough, sauce was seasoned and is homemade- excellent. Best lil' spot to catch a quick bite. They are a slice app customer!!! Excellent!
Brazilian lunch spot.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
I Would not recommend. Tried out the Italian and a burger. Italian was lack luster and drenched in dressing. Burger was a small over cooked and flavorless premade patty and for $11 you would expect a side of fries. Staff was also unfriendly. Will not be coming back.
A perfect place with great service, fast delivery of orders and fair prices.
very good breakfast sandwiches, lunch sandwiches. great pastries and we really enjoy Friday pizza night
I visited each morning during my weeks vacation in the island at the recommendation of the landlord we rented from. The staff was super friendly and kind, my daughter lived giving them a high five each morning. The coffee and pastries were good. Location was convenient to where we were renting. Would definitely visit again.
Never open. Turned away at counter.
I always like going here, the staff is friendly and the food is good
CLAMBAKE GALORE!!! Fella's catered my brother's destination wedding welcome dinner. We were looking for something casual, inviting, local & of course tasty. Boy did Fella deliver! 2 months later, the guests are still talking about the most delicious lobster they've ever had. The whole family was EXTREMELY accommodating to this very last minute wedding, during Covid and us having to change adjust time/location of the event a few times. The whole team was organized & pleasant. And let's not forget the homemade brownies as a perfect finisher to this scrumptious meal. It was the most perfect evening. Thank you Fella's!
Very small portions. My Italian sub had a single piece of ham, salami and cheese. My wife’s turkey sandwich had two slices of turkey. It would be too much to pay $7 a sandwich but instead they cost $10.50 and $11.50. Don’t bother getting a sandwich here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good food!
Me and my family love this pizza place. The sausage and mushroom is extremely tasty and I love their crust.
Very good food!
Me and my family love this pizza place. The sausage and mushroom is extremely tasty and I love their crust.
Every Saturday we take out dogs to Fella's and order two breakfast sandwiches that we share with the dogs. One is a burrito with bacon egg and cheese and one is a croissant with sausage egg and chees. Not only do we love them but so do the dogs who get small bites of ours. We've also had their baked goods, lunch sandwiches, pizza and muffins. As locals we tell you you can't go wrong her for take out.