I’m very disheartened with the customer service here. The cashiers are extremely brash and seem annoyed when customers ask questions. The overall lack of community engagement is disappointing, as other businesses in Columbian Square care about contributing to the neighborhood in a positive way.
ShempThe Dog
I wish I could give 0 stars… worst business I have ever been to, there was mold on the cake slice I purchased and they charged me full price, $7 for a moldy slice of cake… YUM! DO NOT GO HERE unless you want to have food poisoning. I had gotten a slice of pizza here last week and it had very clearly not been fresh, The cheese had a greenish color to it and there was a funky smell. Also it was stone cold and looked like yesterdays leftovers. I wouldn’t even give it to my dog, asked for my money back and they said we can’t do that. Cashiers were decent, that’s the only “good” thing about it. Decided to just take the $4 loss and throw the slice of pizza out. Decided to give it another try today thought maybe the pastries would be better. nope. Almost half of the pastries looked old and there was definitely clearly mold on at least 10 items. Honestly I can’t believe this place is allowed to be open if this is how they operate. This location brings shame to the other locations. There should be a Hazard sign on the door with “Enter at your own risk” This is more like a haunted house than a bakery with all the horrendous handling of food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Samantha C.
Used to love this bakery a few years back. Moved out of state and was super looking forward to eating a banana cream pie but was also super disappointed in the size and price of the pie. Not only was it way overpriced but the crust of the pie was rubbery. Seems like the quality of this place has gone way down
Marilyn Aziz
The staff they don’t even greet you as you come in super quiet. I want to leave as soon as possible and on top of that I Was super excited to try this place for the first time I felt like I was getting ripped off I only bought four slices of the cake and paid $27 plus I think it’s way too much to charge a small slice of cake for 7$ plus dollars each never going back never even got my receipt
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bill Frank
Montillio's is my go-to bakery for every holiday, and even when you just have to have something from there. Every item made is unbelievably delicious, and the Hawaiian Eye is a must try; it's the best!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake, Hawaiian, Birthday Cakes, Cookies Pastry, Italian Rum Cake
Alex C
The pastries are definitly not fresh. The lady at the counter is greedy, offish, and sneaky.
Satyanarayana Vanguru
We tried birthday cakes (range 30$ - 60$) from multiple places in southshore over last few years. But never disappointed as much as with Monitlio's.Birthday cake we ordered isn't terrible, but thats the only best part. I would rate the 15$-20$ cake from warehouse stores to be better than the on we got for 40$ here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cakes
Abby Engstrom
I smile as soon as I see the sign! Everything is so beautifully decorated with rich fillings and perfect down to the pecans on the bottom & flipped on their turnovers!! Lobster Claw= so good!!
Liz DeVincenzo
This used to be my go to for custom ordered cakes or a quick cake pickup.The last 3 times I’ve been haven’t been great. They couldn’t do the type of cake I wanted to order, a cartoon style birthday cake just a plain style. They didn’t have anything in the case for birthday cakes other than a vanilla with vanilla frosting.And the last time I went they had another poor selection, either something for a child, or something with TONS of fruit on it.It would be great if they had more of a variety for people doing a quick run in.
Lisa Superior
This place has the best Breakfast pizza.I like the bacon egg and cheese with maple syrup, and it's not just for breakfastA definite must try if you never have had breakfast pizza, I don't even know of any other pizza place that does this pizza choice.
I’m very disheartened with the customer service here. The cashiers are extremely brash and seem annoyed when customers ask questions. The overall lack of community engagement is disappointing, as other businesses in Columbian Square care about contributing to the neighborhood in a positive way.
I wish I could give 0 stars… worst business I have ever been to, there was mold on the cake slice I purchased and they charged me full price, $7 for a moldy slice of cake… YUM! DO NOT GO HERE unless you want to have food poisoning. I had gotten a slice of pizza here last week and it had very clearly not been fresh, The cheese had a greenish color to it and there was a funky smell. Also it was stone cold and looked like yesterdays leftovers. I wouldn’t even give it to my dog, asked for my money back and they said we can’t do that. Cashiers were decent, that’s the only “good” thing about it. Decided to just take the $4 loss and throw the slice of pizza out. Decided to give it another try today thought maybe the pastries would be better. nope. Almost half of the pastries looked old and there was definitely clearly mold on at least 10 items. Honestly I can’t believe this place is allowed to be open if this is how they operate. This location brings shame to the other locations. There should be a Hazard sign on the door with “Enter at your own risk” This is more like a haunted house than a bakery with all the horrendous handling of food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Used to love this bakery a few years back. Moved out of state and was super looking forward to eating a banana cream pie but was also super disappointed in the size and price of the pie. Not only was it way overpriced but the crust of the pie was rubbery. Seems like the quality of this place has gone way down
The staff they don’t even greet you as you come in super quiet. I want to leave as soon as possible and on top of that I Was super excited to try this place for the first time I felt like I was getting ripped off I only bought four slices of the cake and paid $27 plus I think it’s way too much to charge a small slice of cake for 7$ plus dollars each never going back never even got my receipt
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Montillio's is my go-to bakery for every holiday, and even when you just have to have something from there. Every item made is unbelievably delicious, and the Hawaiian Eye is a must try; it's the best!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake, Hawaiian, Birthday Cakes, Cookies Pastry, Italian Rum Cake
The pastries are definitly not fresh. The lady at the counter is greedy, offish, and sneaky.
We tried birthday cakes (range 30$ - 60$) from multiple places in southshore over last few years. But never disappointed as much as with Monitlio's.Birthday cake we ordered isn't terrible, but thats the only best part. I would rate the 15$-20$ cake from warehouse stores to be better than the on we got for 40$ here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cakes
I smile as soon as I see the sign! Everything is so beautifully decorated with rich fillings and perfect down to the pecans on the bottom & flipped on their turnovers!! Lobster Claw= so good!!
This used to be my go to for custom ordered cakes or a quick cake pickup.The last 3 times I’ve been haven’t been great. They couldn’t do the type of cake I wanted to order, a cartoon style birthday cake just a plain style. They didn’t have anything in the case for birthday cakes other than a vanilla with vanilla frosting.And the last time I went they had another poor selection, either something for a child, or something with TONS of fruit on it.It would be great if they had more of a variety for people doing a quick run in.
This place has the best Breakfast pizza.I like the bacon egg and cheese with maple syrup, and it's not just for breakfastA definite must try if you never have had breakfast pizza, I don't even know of any other pizza place that does this pizza choice.
Restaurantji Recommends
I called to ask about ordering a cake for a birthday and the woman on the phone was so rude
Montilios is a solid 4 star or 5 star good, the Weymouth one is not.
I hadn’t stopped by for a few months. I should’ve kept going…bought a stale pastry. I won’t be back
Great food, clean, qnd great service. Will come back soon.
What a bakery should be. A lovely little place to stop in to get a tasty treat! Love their desserts.