Hornstra Dairy Farm

60 Bedford St, Whitman
(339) 675-4022

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ellise Melanson

Went to go at 830 9/3 as hours online sat 9 pm but they were closed. Now I have a crying 4 year old

Christina Efremidis

Service was great. The girl at the counter was very sweet. Oreo ice cream was yummy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Konstantinos Tziallas

We were in the area and had a craving for some Ice Cream Sundaes. They had a great variety of flavors. We ordered 2 Hot Fudge Sundaes ?and a Hot Caramel Sundae ? they were so Delicious ?. The Service was Excellent ?.
Highly Recommend Hornstra Dairy Farm! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Breisy Zelaya

Not a ice cream person, but brought my girls here and we all love it ❤️? I even came back for more ice cream this week ?
The only suggestion is to put some chairs cause nowhere to sit .

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mrs. Belden Makes You Cry

BYOSeating.
For ice cream.
It's a messy endeavor.
A picnic table or two was really needed.
Other than that, standard ice cream joint. Can't go wrong with that.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 4

Zach Sousa

Hornstra Farm was very good. I gave 4 stars only because we were a little underwhelmed by the waffle cone quality and the variety of flavors. The ice cream is very good. Not the best in the area but very good and would return here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

William Kennedy

First and foremost it’s not the employees fault that the place is just awful. Let’s start with white walls with no seeming seeing what it replaced had a whimsical inside and served high-quality ice cream. This place has a white pretentious and boring inside that suggested sterile and does not welcome people with really low quality ice cream. It may be fresh, but when you have to add simple syrup to a milkshake to make it taste like some thing there’s really something wrong with the ice cream. The pistachio ice cream doesn’t even taste like pistachio. It taste like milk with pistachios floating around the inside of it, compare that to the high-quality peaceful Meadows. That was there before hand. It’s a slap in the face at a price point that is laughably overpriced. You can get a higher quality ice cream Out of the freezer at your local grocery store.. Such a same :(

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Shana Garden

Ella F was amazing! We had a large office order and she handled it with ease and was super friendly! Highly recommend this icecream!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hamza Abuhajeb

Ice cream!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darlene A. Parks “Starchipper” DAP

Great friendly service and great Ice cream ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M's Adventures

I love having access to fresh, local milk. The ice cream is such a treat, and they have fun flavors that are different from the standard supermarket selection. Their pantry items are generally overpriced, but that's not what you go here for anyway.

Holly Richard

We just went to get I cream and we were in line waiting and got to the window to a rude employee and asked if we were there before 8:00 . We got out of our car at 8:04 and another customer said we are closed . We were the last two people in line and didn’t help us and your employees where rude saying “ um where you here before 8:00 we are closed” and shut the window . Unfortunately we won’t be back, you may want to get new employees that are professional and want to serve your customers . You’d think you would want to make business and not send your last two customers away .

Tiago Ikert

Delicious mocha frappe

Terri Bourassa

Great ice cream! Good service.I thank John Hornstra and his family for buying and taking over the Whitman land!

Isabella Toal

I left after they told me you're only allowed to have two toppings on a sundae, and that whipped cream and a cherry count as two. you can't even pay extra for more, you're just not allowed to have more than two! how is that even a sundae? with the prices you're charging, the sundae should actually BE a sundae!

Loading...