Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth
(774) 994-8295

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mohammed Shonar

Closes at 5 PM, not 9 PM on Saturdays. The door was locked in front of our face. Please list proper hours on Google Maps

Jake Rolfes

Gave my friend with a peanut allergy penuts

Bonnie Flahive

Great coffee drinks and breakfast foods. Long lines on weekends

Heather A.

The Fluffy Seagull did not disappoint. It was excellent with great peanut butter flavor. We also loved the cranberry muffin and the chocolate chip cookie was fresh, gooey, and delicious! The staff was super friendly and attentive despite being extremely busy with a line out the door. Everything we got was SO worth the wait.

They also have cute and comfy indoor as well as outdoor seating. A must-stop!

Abigail Moriarty King

I got the famous Fluffy Seagull drink and a chocolate chip cookie. They were both tasty. The Fluffy Seagull on ice is sweet and refreshing. To be honest, I barely tasted the peanut butter. I ordered a small which was probably equivalent to a grande or venti Starbucks drink. The cookie was soft and gooey with flaky salt on top. The staff was friendly. The only thing I didn’t like was how claustrophobic it was inside.

Kevin DiMarzio

This place is a hidden gem! It does have a line out the door but don’t worry, it moves right along.
Once inside they have a lot of small items for sale, shirts, coffee, toys and trinkets. They have breakfast sandwiches, salads, lunch sandwiches, drinks, ice cream sandwiches and more!
Then you get to the coffee and pastries and they are second to no one.
Make sure you add this hidden gem to your must stop list!
Moderately priced but worth every single penny!

Abby Hellauer Geiger

i did indeed fall for the well branded merch trap. that aside, the vibes are as good as they look on tiktok. and the coffee is stellar, really strong brew

Miranda Stewart

What a lovely experience! From the staff to the coffee and pastries, this place does it right! The iconic fluffy seagull was worth the hype! Our favorite item was by far the chocolate chunk cookie croissant… best croissant I think I’ve ever had. If you like cookie dough, you will definitely like this item! Poptart was so good but only available Thursday-Sunday 🥰

Natalie Kirkland

Pretty pedestrian which was disappointing. The story is a cute one and the jams are tasty but, not novel. The sandwiches are essentially a pound of whatever meat on bread with a single lettuce leaf and the specialty items are shipped in from far afield... China! I hope this shop does well and improves on its al a carte offerings since that's the most attractive thing about it in this food desert of 6a.

Sara Basic

One staff person who waits on us is just miserable and can't break a smile or a pleasant greeting when we go there. We feel like we aren't valued patrons and that our money is better spent elsewhere. Also, the seating is very limited. The times that we've gone there, one person with their laptop will take an entire table by themselves for hours while quite a few patrons either leave or wait for something to open up. This makes for a cramped and chaotic scene. It was very cold outside the last day we went and the sad staff person bluntly told us to sit outside. It would be easy enough to post a sign that tables are meant for groups of two or four, not one person to use for hours while other paying customers are told to eat out in the cold weather.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Reedfamily Reed

The three sandwiches that we ordered were excellent!! The staff was unfriendly and rude. The customer before me was having some difficulty with her credit card and the staff person was dismissive- It was not busy at the time - When asked if I wanted my breakfast sandwich heated up I said yes- then my daughter asked if her ham sandwich could be heated up and was told in a abrupt tone we only heat up breakfast sandwiches- How would we know that? I would recommend the sandwiches here but the staff clearly don’t want to there!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Sean Greenhow

Coffee and delicious jam and jelly.

Parking: Parking behind the building, plus parking on route 6A

Kid-friendliness: Plenty of options, including candy and ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicholas DiNinno

Great little shop. Sandwiches and pastries were very good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Stephanie Boosahda

Fantastic sandwiches and definitely worth thecalories sweets. Comfortable Capey atmosphere indoors and out.

Parking: Parking is in the back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Breakfast with Croissant, Pecan Roll, Blueberry Muffin

David Booker

The coffee and food was pretty good, but the service here is absolutely horrendous. I am not sure who the lady is who works here but on my vacation to Cape Cod I went here three times and every time she was incredibly rude. I am here on vacation and spending my money. I am not sure why people act like this, but clearly she doesn’t like her job and it’s very upsetting as a customer. Simply due to her, I would not recommend visiting this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Loading...

Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth, MA 02675
(774) 994-8295