Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth
(774) 994-8295

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The Fluffy Seagull did not disappoint. It was excellent with great peanut butter flavor. We also loved the cranberry muffin and the chocolate chip cookie was fresh, gooey, and delicious! The staff was super friendly and attentive despite being extremely busy with a line out the door. Everything we got was SO worth the wait.

They also have cute and comfy indoor as well as outdoor seating. A must-stop!
I got the famous Fluffy Seagull drink and a chocolate chip cookie. They were both tasty. The Fluffy Seagull on ice is sweet and refreshing. To be honest, I barely tasted the peanut butter. I ordered a small which was probably equivalent to a grande or venti Starbucks drink. The cookie was soft and gooey with flaky salt on top. The staff was friendly. The only thing I didn’t like was how claustrophobic it was inside.
This place is a hidden gem! It does have a line out the door but don’t worry, it moves right along.
Once inside they have a lot of small items for sale, shirts, coffee, toys and trinkets. They have breakfast sandwiches, salads, lunch sandwiches, drinks, ice cream sandwiches and more!
Then you get to the coffee and pastries and they are second to no one.
Make sure you add this hidden gem to your must stop list!
Moderately priced but worth...

More Reviews

Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry

173 Main St, Yarmouth, MA 02675
(774) 994-8295