I've favorably reviewed this place before, but my last 2 visits were not good at all. The past 2 Saturday nights I ordered the same thing, 1 large cheese and 1 small cheese pizza for pickup. On both occasions I had to wait 5-10 minutes for my order and on both days when I got the pizza home it was lukewarm at best, seemed and tasted like the pizza had been made several hours earlier and had been sitting under a heat lamp. Very disappointing since a large cheese is more than $18 there. I do not plan to return there and will be looking for a new pizza shop near our Dennis home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Fran Marci-Glenn
Under new ownership, no more beer and wine license.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Sam Bekov
Update your number
Jenn S.
We came here for lunch on a rainy Sunday and it was so good. They were super busy, so we did have to wait a while for our food but it was worth the wait! While we waited for our food, people came in and out and the phone was off the hook. They are super busy! Definitely call ahead but great selection and can't wait to try their pizzas and pastas. I got the buffalo chicken sub and my fiancé got the steak and cheese calzone. Both were super tasty and worth the price.
mir09 com
Nice pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heidi H.
We love pizza night as a family. We ordered pizza by Evans and got chicken broccoli ziti Alfredo and we also ordered a bacon, ham and pineapple pizza for the kids. I have to say the food was not delicious at all. Over priced undercooked. As for chicken broccoli ziti Alfredo had no Alfredo, they put full strips of bacon on the pizza which I have never seen that before. It was hardly any pineapple, and it was undercooked.
Brian 360
It's a must go-to place. Everytime I'm in the area it's an automatic lunch stop. They are quick, affordable and have a great selection of wonderful food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Pjzza
Jason Catarino
Been there a few times when it town and the pizza is delicious! Some of the best in the area. Great little spot to dine-in as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Constant
Pizza is outstanding. I was visiting family from NJ, and Yarmouth Pizza was a pleasant surprise. I highly recommend it!
Extremely disappointed with Yarmouth Pizza by Evan. While holding a fundraising golf tournament nearby, we found out the restaurant was closed until they were scheduled to feed our tournament participants. So, because we had to feed the people who were working the tournament, we called Yarmouth Pizza by Evan. We placed an order for about a dozen people totaling over $200.00. Some of the orders were for Buffalo Chicken Wraps and Chicken Tenders, so we requested extra buffalo sauce, as well as ranch and honey mustard. I went and picked the food up and gave them my credit card. I signed the receipt and left a pretty decent tip (15%) for carryout... after all it was a sizable order and they had it ready in 25 minutes. Needless to say, when the receipt was being reviewed later, it was discovered that not only did they charge $21.00 for the sauces ($.90 a piece for Ken's ranch cups and $1.25 for Ken's honey mustard cups), but an $8.00 fee for using a card to pay. None of this was explained when we were placing the order or when I picked up the food and gave the woman my card nor was it stated on their website when we were looking at the menu options. We called to speak with someone about the charges, we were told the manager wasn't in and would be in at 4:15 and that they would call. No call. A follow up call and the manager was still not in and still no one could help us. As of today, over 24 hours later, there's still no resolution to this matter and, as far as I know, the manager hasn't called back. I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT.
Service: 1
Michael Kelly
Great spice on the Mexican pizza. Their gluten-free pizza was good, too.
jody sylvia
I have always loved Pizza by Evans in Yarmouthport but this time I was disappointed. The Greek salad was good but no olives. The pizza was suppose to be pepperoni and onion and there was plenty of pepperoni but hardly an onion to be found.Asked for it to be cooked well done but it wasn't. Unfortunately I forgot they charge extra for using a credit card or I would have brought cash. All in all it was just ok. Mostly because what I ordered was pretty basic and hard to get wrong.Sorry but don't think I will go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mimi M.
Mediocre Pizza. I am from NYC, so for me this pizza is extremely bland. The ingredients are fresh but lack the flavor and texture of real pizza. Also, it's not inexpensive. For that price, I think the service should be better. Plastic everywhere, silverware, salad served in plastic containers, paper plates. It's just not an all around great experience for the price. Not worth it.
Rob Leonard
I got two slices from this place they were the smallest slices I've ever had in I don't even think it would have filled up fivels belly.
Great subs. My toasted Italian was awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've favorably reviewed this place before, but my last 2 visits were not good at all. The past 2 Saturday nights I ordered the same thing, 1 large cheese and 1 small cheese pizza for pickup. On both occasions I had to wait 5-10 minutes for my order and on both days when I got the pizza home it was lukewarm at best, seemed and tasted like the pizza had been made several hours earlier and had been sitting under a heat lamp. Very disappointing since a large cheese is more than $18 there. I do not plan to return there and will be looking for a new pizza shop near our Dennis home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Under new ownership, no more beer and wine license.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Update your number
We came here for lunch on a rainy Sunday and it was so good. They were super busy, so we did have to wait a while for our food but it was worth the wait! While we waited for our food, people came in and out and the phone was off the hook. They are super busy! Definitely call ahead but great selection and can't wait to try their pizzas and pastas. I got the buffalo chicken sub and my fiancé got the steak and cheese calzone. Both were super tasty and worth the price.
Nice pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love pizza night as a family. We ordered pizza by Evans and got chicken broccoli ziti Alfredo and we also ordered a bacon, ham and pineapple pizza for the kids. I have to say the food was not delicious at all. Over priced undercooked. As for chicken broccoli ziti Alfredo had no Alfredo, they put full strips of bacon on the pizza which I have never seen that before. It was hardly any pineapple, and it was undercooked.
It's a must go-to place. Everytime I'm in the area it's an automatic lunch stop. They are quick, affordable and have a great selection of wonderful food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gluten Free Pjzza
Been there a few times when it town and the pizza is delicious! Some of the best in the area. Great little spot to dine-in as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is outstanding. I was visiting family from NJ, and Yarmouth Pizza was a pleasant surprise. I highly recommend it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Extremely disappointed with Yarmouth Pizza by Evan. While holding a fundraising golf tournament nearby, we found out the restaurant was closed until they were scheduled to feed our tournament participants. So, because we had to feed the people who were working the tournament, we called Yarmouth Pizza by Evan. We placed an order for about a dozen people totaling over $200.00. Some of the orders were for Buffalo Chicken Wraps and Chicken Tenders, so we requested extra buffalo sauce, as well as ranch and honey mustard. I went and picked the food up and gave them my credit card. I signed the receipt and left a pretty decent tip (15%) for carryout... after all it was a sizable order and they had it ready in 25 minutes. Needless to say, when the receipt was being reviewed later, it was discovered that not only did they charge $21.00 for the sauces ($.90 a piece for Ken's ranch cups and $1.25 for Ken's honey mustard cups), but an $8.00 fee for using a card to pay. None of this was explained when we were placing the order or when I picked up the food and gave the woman my card nor was it stated on their website when we were looking at the menu options. We called to speak with someone about the charges, we were told the manager wasn't in and would be in at 4:15 and that they would call. No call. A follow up call and the manager was still not in and still no one could help us. As of today, over 24 hours later, there's still no resolution to this matter and, as far as I know, the manager hasn't called back. I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT.
Service: 1
Great spice on the Mexican pizza. Their gluten-free pizza was good, too.
I have always loved Pizza by Evans in Yarmouthport but this time I was disappointed. The Greek salad was good but no olives. The pizza was suppose to be pepperoni and onion and there was plenty of pepperoni but hardly an onion to be found.Asked for it to be cooked well done but it wasn't. Unfortunately I forgot they charge extra for using a credit card or I would have brought cash. All in all it was just ok. Mostly because what I ordered was pretty basic and hard to get wrong.Sorry but don't think I will go back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Mediocre Pizza. I am from NYC, so for me this pizza is extremely bland. The ingredients are fresh but lack the flavor and texture of real pizza. Also, it's not inexpensive. For that price, I think the service should be better. Plastic everywhere, silverware, salad served in plastic containers, paper plates. It's just not an all around great experience for the price. Not worth it.
I got two slices from this place they were the smallest slices I've ever had in I don't even think it would have filled up fivels belly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 2