Amazing spot! The food was outstanding, the ambiance was fun, and the cocktails were exquisite and strong! We tried the Sally's Shrimp (literally wanted to drink the buttery sauce with a straw) and the crab cakes - truly outstanding and the house made tartar sauce was out of this world. We also each tried 2 unique cocktails, and all 4 were excellent. Marcy was amazing and we appreciated her drink recommendations. Only negative was that it was a liiiiittle too dark in there for me, but I'm old and can't see, so that's on me. My husband said more than once “what a great find!” Would definitely recommend this for your next trip to Fells Point!
Stephanie
They have really good crafted burgers (had their smash burger & steakhouse burger). Enjoyed a caramel old fashion & also a Grand Marnier creme brulee for dessert. Next time we'll try one of their entrees. Very nice ambience & friendly people who work there making you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door.
Lillian
Delicious and the drinks were strong. Oysters are a bit over priced but everything else was more than reasonable.
Jeanna
Our bartender Todd was lights out! He was so knowledgeable about the history of the restaurant and made our night! So much fun!
Ron
Flavorful French Onion Soup, tender Chilean Sea Bass...all great for a nicely served Valentine's dinner.
michelle
Crab cakes, Duck and steak were amazing! Cocktails were great and service was top notch!!! We will be back!
Ricky Grant
One-Eyed Mike's is a unique experience. They have a bar, a dining area and an outdoor patio which we took advantage of because of the good weather. The staff was very helpful in the selections and were quick to ensure the food, appetizers, and drinks were readily available and delivered. If you're a fan of the liqueur Grand Marnier this is the place to be the quintessential club for members is amazing with over 3,000 unique bottles for members. I will be back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sea Scallops with Lobster Risotto, Maryland Crab Soup
Tiffany
As usual we thoroughly enjoyed our visit to One-Eyed Mike's! Our bartender was super, food amazing, and drinks were delicious! It's not to Baltimore unless we get to visit One-Eyed Mike's!
Tim Kinnard
Best dinner in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Crab Cakes
Ricardo Ramos
Staff was super friendly even though they got slammed for a bit. Very low lighting which was cool, but can be tough to see a menu or your food. The crab cakes were very good. Cool little place.
Came in at the recommendation of a bartender at another bar. Loved this place - the crab cakes and gazpacho were both divine, and the service was warm, welcoming, and attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric Brooks
Great ambiance, great service, great food. The owner even stopped by to make sure we were enjoying everything
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary
We had an early reservation and the place was empty. A dear friend recommended so we went with it. We had the chicken liver pate, which was served with a side of bread and butter pickles. That was very good creamy and buttery. I ordered the crab soup and it was just too salty and I couldn't finish it. My husband ordered the Smashburger, which was OK and my daughter ordered the crab cake entrée that had a side of asparagus and something else which was probably the best thing we had there. The server was friendly, but not the quickest. As we were leaving at 740 the place was filling up and the ambience was way cooler. 
K S (Enilder)
Had a few drinks here. 10/10. I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacki Butterfield
Erin is absolutely a top tier, one of the best bartenders you can have service a late night wedding party of 30 on a Sunday night. That girl had our entire party poured and tabs going in with excellent execution in the time it would have taken two. Super friendly, knowledgeable, skilled, proficient, everyone was impressed with her and for those who had never been in, are looking forward to joining "the club" in this unique atmosphere.
Amazing spot! The food was outstanding, the ambiance was fun, and the cocktails were exquisite and strong! We tried the Sally's Shrimp (literally wanted to drink the buttery sauce with a straw) and the crab cakes - truly outstanding and the house made tartar sauce was out of this world. We also each tried 2 unique cocktails, and all 4 were excellent. Marcy was amazing and we appreciated her drink recommendations. Only negative was that it was a liiiiittle too dark in there for me, but I'm old and can't see, so that's on me. My husband said more than once “what a great find!” Would definitely recommend this for your next trip to Fells Point!
They have really good crafted burgers (had their smash burger & steakhouse burger). Enjoyed a caramel old fashion & also a Grand Marnier creme brulee for dessert. Next time we'll try one of their entrees. Very nice ambience & friendly people who work there making you feel welcome as soon as you walk in the door.
Delicious and the drinks were strong. Oysters are a bit over priced but everything else was more than reasonable.
Our bartender Todd was lights out! He was so knowledgeable about the history of the restaurant and made our night! So much fun!
Flavorful French Onion Soup, tender Chilean Sea Bass...all great for a nicely served Valentine's dinner.
Crab cakes, Duck and steak were amazing! Cocktails were great and service was top notch!!! We will be back!
One-Eyed Mike's is a unique experience. They have a bar, a dining area and an outdoor patio which we took advantage of because of the good weather. The staff was very helpful in the selections and were quick to ensure the food, appetizers, and drinks were readily available and delivered. If you're a fan of the liqueur Grand Marnier this is the place to be the quintessential club for members is amazing with over 3,000 unique bottles for members. I will be back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sea Scallops with Lobster Risotto, Maryland Crab Soup
As usual we thoroughly enjoyed our visit to One-Eyed Mike's! Our bartender was super, food amazing, and drinks were delicious! It's not to Baltimore unless we get to visit One-Eyed Mike's!
Best dinner in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seafood, Crab Cakes
Staff was super friendly even though they got slammed for a bit. Very low lighting which was cool, but can be tough to see a menu or your food. The crab cakes were very good. Cool little place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Came in at the recommendation of a bartender at another bar. Loved this place - the crab cakes and gazpacho were both divine, and the service was warm, welcoming, and attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great ambiance, great service, great food. The owner even stopped by to make sure we were enjoying everything
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had an early reservation and the place was empty. A dear friend recommended so we went with it. We had the chicken liver pate, which was served with a side of bread and butter pickles. That was very good creamy and buttery. I ordered the crab soup and it was just too salty and I couldn't finish it. My husband ordered the Smashburger, which was OK and my daughter ordered the crab cake entrée that had a side of asparagus and something else which was probably the best thing we had there. The server was friendly, but not the quickest. As we were leaving at 740 the place was filling up and the ambience was way cooler. 
Had a few drinks here. 10/10. I will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin is absolutely a top tier, one of the best bartenders you can have service a late night wedding party of 30 on a Sunday night. That girl had our entire party poured and tabs going in with excellent execution in the time it would have taken two. Super friendly, knowledgeable, skilled, proficient, everyone was impressed with her and for those who had never been in, are looking forward to joining "the club" in this unique atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...