Sarah’s Handmade Ice Cream Wildwood

The ice cream is pretty good, they have lots of flavors and varieties. The service is definitely speedier than most other ice cream shops. They also have many cool books there if you want to just chill and read.

While I've only been 2 or 3 times, I'm in love with Sarah's. Unfortunately (or fortunately for my weight and my wallet) I can't go easily or often, but I find myself thinking about if and when I might be near one next, all of the flavors I love, and what new ones I can sample. They have the creamiest, most flavorful, fresh, delicious ice cream. The menu is enormous which is really fun (some may say overwhelming, I say the more choices the better!). I was able to sample several flavors my first time and ended up choosing peanut butter fudge and banana pudding. Peppermint stick was another favorite which I got in a future visit, as well as I believe grapefruit (maybe pink lemonade?) sorbet. It'll be hard to stray from peanut butter fudge and peppermint in the future, but I do want to try lots more flavors. Yes, it's pricey, but so are other nearby highly-rated places like Mimi's and Baked Bear, and this is where I'd choose to go of the 3. The staff is also very friendly, helpful, and patient. Highly recommend!!!

This is a local favorite, so be ready to wait when you get your ice cream. They have hand-dipped flavors galore that are made in-house on a rotating basis with seasonal specials. So, if you're vegetarian, you will have a blast and go back again and again! If you're vegan, well, you have options, but, well, they're options. I only give 3 stars because the vegan options are sorbets, essentially. Even the ones like double chocolate and mint Oreo have a base that has the same palate sensation has sorbet. There's nothing wrong with sorbet, but if you're a vegan looking for ice cream that's creamy, this is not the place for you. Sure, there's something for you that you can eat while your friends and family have their run of the place on whatever their heart desires, while you'll politely just be grateful there is something, right? There are other places with vegan creamy ice cream, so I'd go there over here any day of the week.

Why close at 9 pm on a Saturday night? 4 families wanted to go and n and were very disappointed.

Amazing homemade ice cream! Love the variety of creative flavors, it's hard to choose.... I want them all!! A favorite of the community.

Delicious ice cream, interesting and imaginative flavors, fun for both children and kids. Our family’s favorite local outing.

This ice cream is soooooo good!! I got the flight so I was able to try 8 flavors at one time!! What a great idea Sarah😂😂😂

Very tasty I had the Oreo cookie and cream

What a delightful experience! So many flavors to choose from. We took the flight, all of them were very tasty. Best were almond coconut and Sandy Shore Chesapeake. 100% recommend! Will be going back soon.

Splendid. The flavors are delicious and very innovative. I don’t normally leave reviews, but I gotta say, this is some really great ice cream. I’ve been doing my ice cream tour, and made this stop here. 5/5 would recommend. I got this mango sticky rice and Chesapeake bay flavor which were really good. I was even able to get samples. Nice price point for the quality as well. If you are in town, stop by. Thanks.

THE GOAT ICE CREAM AROUND MARYLAND !!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fast and friendly service even with a long line of summer customers!

Ice cream is delicious, but customer service is terrible. Rude and snappy immature workers.

Delicious ice cream at this neighborhood joint!! Not cheaply priced, but excellent quality.

Delicious ice cream and great service. Plus pup cups!