Eataliano Market & Deli

I saw this place online from a food blogger I follow. I thought id give it a try.

1 hour and 20 minutes it took to get me my food. I understand its Friday night and ordered online. The online system said 35 minutes which i was okay with but an hour and a half to get two items. Pizza was good but the cheesesteak wasnt that special. there are better places.

Cleanliness lacks at this place. While I was standing there waiting, I was looking at some of the products they sell. The tops of most of the products I looked at are covered with dust.

You can imagine how bored I was waiting after an hour that I was cleaning off the top of boxes.

Not worth the hype. Won't be coming back. The bloggers who highlight this place obviously got better food and service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

I just waited an Hour and 45 minutes for a cheesesteak and fries. Absolutely insane.

Used to enjoy some of the things from this place. The last few times I have been the food takes forever and the sandwiches/subs have been lacking big time. Very dry, brown lettuce, just thrown together with no care. Seems like everyone in this place is always in the weeds. Real raggedy operation going on right now. Waited almost an hour for a cold sandwich and a piece of cake.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great cheesesteaks.. Will return when in the area.

Edited from 2 to 4 stars after a few good experiences.

Our take out was 40 minutes late. Many people received their food, even sat down and dined while my husband waited for our food and was mostly ignored by the staff. It was my birthday dinner, and because it was so late, we weren't able to have cake with my young boys before they needed to go to bed. My husband was never given an explanation or apology as to why the food was so late. It was pretty cold by the time we finally ate, leading us to believe it was forgotten about in the back. Very disappointed in this birthday dinner.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Food is FANTASTIC! We saw this online and drove a bit to give it a try and it did NOT disappoint!
Its a small shop, so plan accordingly. Not a lot of room for dining. We were able to grab a table, then head up and order. Its not traditional table service.
Portions are large, there a ton of variety and a small shop on the inside to pick up a bunch of snacks and ingredients for later. Recommend this as a MUST stop if your in the area!
The Crab roll was filling and overflowing with crab. The shrimp and crab Alfredo was so flavorful and the burrata salad was fresh and delicious. We wished we coukd try the whole menu.
We left with bags of desserts for later!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

I watched a Instagram that raved about the crab roll. I usually avoid Instagram reels about restaurants since most of them are fake and the influencer is paid.
This was most likely the case, the roll was not listed on the menu so I asked about it.
$33.00 for the roll was definitely not worth it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Ordered chef's choice pizza and real cheesesteak. Flavor was good, however, I wished they go easier on the salt. The food was very salty for my palette

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

First time visit. I called my order in to avoid a wait when I arrived. I had the cheese steak, non seeded toasted roll, fried onions, American cheese. 19.08 hit my wallet hard for me. The sub was fantastic! The meat was tender and tasty, no chewy fat, no grisle like some places I have reviewed. The sub was packed full of meat. The bread was fresh made perfect. Very impressed. 8 tables with Italian store front items nestled in the heart of the neighborhood. The food I saw other people eating looked great. Can't wait til I come again. Parking is limited 15 or so spaces.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love this place it is worth the drive to Columbia, Maryland to get the best steak and cheese in Maryland. They fill it up with meat cheese and a sesame seed. Bread is amazing not to mention how great the Pizza is. Enjoy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The big guy with the hat (cashier
) is very rude, avoid at all costs. He shouldn't be working in customer service with his attitude.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Neighbor highly recommended this place and it did not disappoint! Ordered the New Yorker pizza and Greek salad and it was outstanding !

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best cheesesteak in Maryland !!!! Well seasoned, cheese melted in meat, bread fresh, good quality steak, and you don’t need to order extra steak because it come packed! Order online to avoid the long wait times !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered Real Chesse steak on urber eats The Steak was really salty the bread was rubbery I feel I should be able to get replacement sub

Food: 1

Their food is great but the service is absolutely awful. They have gotten way too popular for their own good and can’t keep up with demand. Good luck trying to get food on a Friday or Saturday night. It’s absolute disaster.

The employees are working their hardest but the management is setting them up for failure. This place needs new management and processes to keep up with their demand. My pickup time when I ordered online said 45 minutes, which is fine, but then when I got there I had to wait another 45 minutes for my order.

They also need to loose their dine in tables and stick to only to go orders. There were easily 40-50 customers and uber eats drivers just standing around in their tiny area waiting for orders on a Friday night. It’s a zoo.

It’s a shame but I will not come back here again until they make some serious changes to how they operate.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1