Smith Island Baking Company
$ • Bakery, Patisserie/Cake ShopAbout Smith Island Baking Company
Customers' Favorites
Smith Island Bakery Chocolate Cake
Red Velvet Cake
lg Cakes
Smith Island Baking Company Reviews
113 ratings
Share your opinion about Smith Island Baking Company
Picked up two very delicious Smith Island Cakes. Strawberry 🍓 🍰 and Carrot 🥕 😋
I grew up in Maryland and moved to Florida years ago. I just had my sister send me an Old Bay Buttercream cake for my birthday and... Amazing!!! Arrived packaged well, fresh, and my taste buds will never be the same. Who would have thought, but I'm one grateful brother. Well done S.I.B.C.
I’ve always liked a smith island cake but never went crazy over them, then I tried the coconut one last holiday season and it was fantastic. I had to pick up dessert for a housewarming and saw they had a lemon cake available on Goldbelly, so I figured why not.
This cake was a huge hit. Everybody loved it and kept asking where it came from. It’s lemony and tart but not overly sweet. It is exactly what you want in a lemon cake. I’ll be ordering it again.
This cake was a huge hit. Everybody loved it and kept asking where it came from. It’s lemony and tart but not overly sweet. It is exactly what you want in a lemon cake. I’ll be ordering it again.
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 4PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Smith Island Baking Company is known for its delicious cakes, which many customers describe as the "best ever eaten" and a "huge hit" at celebrations. The cakes are moist, easy to thaw, and look great when served. The company offers excellent customer service, with the owner quickly resolving any issues. Customers often request these cakes for family holidays, and some have received them as surprises on special occasions like Mother's Day, even when shipping challenges arose. The company consistently ensures the cakes arrive on time and in perfect condition. Recent reviews highlight the friendliness of the staff, with one customer mentioning how the team went out of their way to help with a delivery glitch, providing tracking info and friendly support. Many customers praise the cakes' handmade quality, especially the vanilla birthday cake with its perfect buttercream layers, and the red velvet cake delivered during tough times. Overall, Smith Island Baking Company remains a trusted choice for special occasions and memorable treats.