The Toasted Goat
CLOSED$ •
About The Toasted Goat
The Toasted Goat Reviews
161 ratings
The food is pretty good but I ordered Buffalo wings and there was barely any Buffalo sauce on them. Only 2 wings had sauce on them. I requested some more Buffalo sauce and received very little. Still not enough for all 11 wings. I do like the place, the food was good but the person in the kitchen needs to learn how to sauce the wings. I'd give it a 4 out of a 5.
I had the whiskey rebellion burger and a route 40 raspberry wheat beer. everything was great. our server was awesome, the atmosphere is nice and location was interesting.
We come here often, we're big fans of the chef Matthew Martin! The food is always exceptional and creative, the martinis and beer selection outstanding. Great staff! Brittany was our server tonight, and she's the best! I rarely request a certain server on our foodie adventures, but I might have to start. 🥰
The Toasted Goat provides a charming and memorable dining experience in a beautiful, spooky old building. The restaurant offers outstanding vegetarian options like spinach artichoke dip and Quinoa salad. Their signature "Drunk Bird" sandwich, featuring beer-battered fried chicken breast with candied bacon and spicy honey dressing, is a must-try. The menu also includes a house-made black bean burger topped with goat cheese and roasted peppers, which has received high praise from customers. The extensive cocktail and bar menu features classic drinks like rye Manhattan, as well as excellent beers from their sister brewery, Route 40. The friendly staff and cool ambiance make it a fabulous place to enjoy a meal, making it a definite "must stop" location for travelers who want good food, great drinks, and a fun atmosphere. Visitors often comment on the fair prices, great service, and the chance to explore more of the building's history on future visits.