Paradise NY Style Pizza & Italian Restaurant

“We stumbled upon this little hidden gem, and it exceeded our expectations yesterday. The best pizza we ever had in Hagerstown, Md. and surrounding area. The pizza made here is real amazing and we would recommend trying these guys out. They have great topping selections and great prices on a single slice or whole NY style pizza. We like the thin crispy crust pizza, and this exceeded our expectations. Even the sweet tea was the best I have ever ordered in a restaurant. They offer an awesome range of fresh pizzas and Italian dishes. We liked dining here and definitely will be back many more times. Staff members were very friendly, prices are quite reasonable and was amazed at the cleanliness of this small establishment. Thank you to the kind waitress, and the gentlemen who were making the pizzas.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best Pizza in town! Best pizza anywhere around town! Nothing in the entire epwv area hits the authentic NY pizza craving except this place! Staff are super kind.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

best pizza in the state!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have ordered delivery multiple times and everything is great every time. Fast and hot! 5 stars all around!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paradise pizza hands down is one of the best pizza place I have tried throughout the Hagerstown, Maugansville AND Funkstown area. The sauce is ON POINT, the toppings are a very generous amount, and the crust is finely executed. QUALITY IS TOP TIER. Fresh ingredients. The subs here are also amazing!!! If you are a pizza enthusiast THIS is the place to order from. As a customer for over just a year I will NEVER search for another pizza place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I had a delivery of lasagna and a medium cheese the crust was thin and crisp it was delicious the lasagna was also very good but a little too much gravy for me I really enjoyed the food and I would recommend it to everyone enjoy the driver was very pleasant

Food: 5

Service: 5

After working at a pizza place for years, I'm pretty picky when it comes to pizza. It's rare for a restaurant to get all 3 parts right. These guys get it.

The cheese was good with satisfactory proportions. The sauce had a nice flavor that complimented the cheese without stealing any of the stars thunder. And lastly the crust, which is usually supbar, bland or supplemented (w/ garlic or cheese filling usually), was actually pretty good!

Overall, they did a stand up job and I'd absolutely buy from them again ❤️

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered a pizza and it was A-MAZING !!! Great-tasting, crispy crust !!! And the service was top notch !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was trash and way over priced. Slice was bland , meatball hero was almost 13$ , fountain drink was more than 4$

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Delicious New York style pizza. Crust was nice and crispy and airy enough to not weigh you down after eating. Staff there was very friendly and checked up on me to make sure I was doing good. Would definitely recommend!

Pizza was great! Not the best I’ve ever had but a huge step above the normal chain restaurants. Wings were cooked perfect and sauced just as good. Delivery driver was friendly.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Best pizza I've had in the area so far. I have only done delivery and not been inside the building. I don't know if the owners are Italian or not, but the pizza tasted pretty legit. The crust had a nice crunch when folded. Little to no grease on the bottom of the pizza or inside the box. Great flavor and me being semi lactose intolerant, this pizza has not affected me at all. Prices are reasonable as well. Will order again!

Found hair in my pizza after it was delivered. Gross 🤮

Hi everyone, if it's right I say it's right if it's not I have the right to say it's not.

This was my experience. Saw a sign that said grand opening.

Stoped in and this is what I received...

The wings were dry and burnt, the onion rings were delicious, the broccoli Alfredo was nothing but a mess of pasta no taste.

I was the only one in the line yet they sent a order that was the same as mine out for delivery and served several other customers as I continued waiting.

The man pulled a order that had been sitting on top of the stove placed the fresh bag of hot onion rings on top and served me last.

In response to the owner's reply, if a person's order is ready and paid for you give to them not place on a stove to get cold.

If the person order more and pay for that and have to wait it is ok. No excuse. My order was paid in full should have been given to me when it is ready not put back on stove.

Respectfully,

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Pizza Paradise has the best subs in town! The food quality is always top-notch, and the service is incredibly fast. Everything on the menu is delicious—from the pizza to the pasta. Highly recommend this spot if you’re craving real New York-style Italian food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5