Tomanetti's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

308 S 2nd St, Oakland
(301) 334-4844

Recent Reviews

Alex R.

Our family loves this restaurant and has been several times. The service is fast. The food always tastes so good and fresh. It feels very cozy inside and you can tell it's a family-run business. Everyone that works there is very friendly and pleasant. Great seating options. Reminds us Venice, one of our favorite places ever. And now my 10 year olds review: For my review every thing was good like the food was amazing The service was amazing just every thing was amazing so I give it

Kim Haney

Stopped here on the way to visit family. Large portions. Friendly service. Good food. We left happy and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Licharowicz

We love this little town Pizzeria! Great food, clean, nice atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Dough Cheese Pizza

Kevin Hook

This is a great little hideaway with amazing food. My family has had pretty much everything on the menu and we have enjoyed it all. You cannot go wrong if you are looking for Italian food by coming here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew O.

Zero stars. Rude service. Very rude. Food tastes like it's from a jar or frozen. Atmosphere would be fine if the staff weren't so inconvenienced by your presence.

Tiffany D.

I really enjoyed the pizza from here. Calling in an order was easy and pick up was seamless. They are quite expensive however. GLOWS: -The pizzas were very good. Nice amount of crust and the toppings were good (veggie, cheese, pepperoni ) -The wings were good (bbq, mild, buffalo)--- make sure to ask for ranch if you prefer it over blue cheese -I ate a good amount and didn't have the heavy greasy feeling that usually comes with pizza GROWS: -I wish there was a delivery option -The chicken pizza wasn't my favorite

Wayne Bowser

Pizza has potential but I believe they use frozen crust.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Matt Frank

Excellent service. Great food

Vincent R.

I'll start with the positives.. 1) we were able to place an order by just showing up as they had their phone off the hook due to how busy they were. 2) the place is quaint, the staff seemed very friendly As for the food, it's not the style of pizza that we are accustomed to, the thin crust is an obvious frozen pizza and the thick crust was just not enjoyable. We ordered 4 pies and a calzone but threw most of it out....even the kids wouldn't eat it. There really aren't a lot options around here though so perhaps try the place for yourself as we are from NY and to be considered pizza snobs.

Lisa O

**The worst and most uncomfortable experience I’ve ever had in a restaurant**We ordered an appetizer (that never came or was even acknowledge) but prior to ordering we asked the server if some items could be eliminated from a pasta dish due to a food allergy she said she would ask the kitchen but probably knew the answer, I said that is fine if not just wanted to check… she returned and said that they would not do a special order, my husband said we understand it might be put together already… at this point the server rapidly pivoted and ran away from our table only to send out what I presume to be the manager or owner, we were confused as to why she came to our table but she reiterated no special orders we again said fine we understand… the server returns and we tried to explain it was not a problem whatsoever and she abruptly interrupts and says do you know what you want I have other tables (although everyone else had their food and it was not busy) so startled by this behavior we just picked the first thing on the menu which was fettuccine alfredo with chicken…when the dish came it was obvious it was alfredo sauce from a jar that had been thinned with oil, the chicken was of a composite texture (think high school lunch) with purposeful grill marks- the meal was beyond awful for a place that presents themselves as a restaurant, let alone an Italian restaurant ??

Courtney C.

This was better than even the first trip. Everything was perfect. The fried green tomatoes with my own bowl and spoon for red tomato sauce to go on top? Say less. The veal is a special and as you can tell is my favorite. And this was HUGE!? Like 3 ginormous pieces. I prefer the sauce here. Idk just do. Server either owned the place or the owners should be grateful she's on staff 1 of the 2. Only downsides could be maybe parking, maybe seating. Place up the road couldn't accommodate so we went here instead and was in and out with dessert in an hour.

Marie Crum

Cute restaurant it is very small inside.. good Italian food with large

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Natalie Wooldridge

Such great food and amazing service. The calzone was to die for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie Wooldridge

Great Italian food in Oakland MD. Local IPAs and ciders on tap. Huge portions, the calzone was gigantic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

scott schmidt

Chicken Alfredo was awful! I took one bite and knew chicken was frozen then microwaved sauce was jarred (Ragu) though they claim sauce is made in house I don't believe them and it cost 18.99. I was told it wasn't their fault I didn't like it so I was expected to pay in full. I did end up getting 40% off that dish. No plate was given to the 5 yo for her pizza even after after we were told she was going to get a plate. She never showed up with one. Stuff shells were expensive for 3 shells 16.00 I did not taste it but did taste the sauce it was not great. Staff was initially friendly but did not listen as we asked for spaghetti and meatballs for the 4 yo and didn't get meatballs. We didn't ask again for them and he enjoyed his buttered spaghetti noodles

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More

Tomanetti's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

308 S 2nd St, Oakland, MD 21550
(301) 334-4844