The New Yarmouth Cafe did an amazing job catering this year's New Year's Eve event! They served over 250 burgers, 300 hotdogs, 40 pounds of wings, and 10 pizzas in less than two hours. Everything was served hot (and with a smile) and the guests were very happy with the quality of the food that was provided. Larry delivered on time and consistently worked to make sure the meals were perfect. We could not have made a better choice!
Richard B.
I will continue this later but for now. I just want to give it all the stars available. This is a real sleeper in a very pleasant surprise after 3 years in the area we have found our favorite little spot. We are fully aware that only one meal cannot make a qualified review so we will defer until a later date after a few more visits. For now let me just say that the burger I had was the best I've had in the area. We are both anxious to see what the next few visits tell us.
Tammy Cossairt
I worked with Larry (owner) to cater our Pirates Weekend event at Haven Harbour South last weekend. Extremely pleased with the taste, quality, quantity and service. The lasagna, fried chicken and pulled pork were excellent! I would absolutely work with them again. We actually had quite a bit of leftover food. In the future Larry can connect us with a local charity so others can enjoy our leftovers. Thank you. HSA-1. Tim and Tammy Cossairt
Nicole F.
We started off with some nachos. Very good. We both got the buffalo chicken salad. This was very good. Too much and we couldn't finish it. Service was excellent and all the staff were super nice.
Richard N.
Ordered take out .Pizza& French fries.Fries very good had a salt& pepper seasoning on them very good, pizza was a really good 16" hot.Very friendly.
Laura Hall
Food is good, ate in once and carried out twice.
Jason Smucker
place needs cleaned and food over salted
Ron Preiss
Nice people, good food, fair prices. What's not to love?
Jennifer Clark
The pizza we got wasn't cooked all the way and didn't taste very good.
Ted Bachman
Good home-style cooked food, they're warm and friendly, they are accommodating to your wishes and desires and oh did I mention it's veteran-owned.
This place was just okay. It started out great with the fried pickles - I would definitely get them again because they were great - thin strips of pickle fried perfectly with a nice dip. But sadly, the dough on the inside of my stromboli wasn't cooked through - I should have sent it back, but I didn't. Instead I took it home and tried to cook it some more but that didn't really work out either. My husband wasn't expecting fried fish on his tacos - usually when he gets fish tacos, the fish is grilled or steamed or something. Anyway, I will probably give them another try sometime.
Melody Valentine Prairie
Clean place, friendly organized staff, and the crust.... oh that pizza crust! Just wow! Great experience all the way around!
Susannah D.
We had clam strips, chicken cheesesteak, and a cheeseburger. Everything was tasty! Food was ready when promised.
Kathi D.
Great place to grab a bite or get take out. Highly rec their Italian Stromboli. The crust is perfect, and the meats and sauce are excellent! They also do a very nice, house-made, pulled pork.
Peggy States
Excellent meal!! Our first visit and we will be back. From the time we walked in until the time we walked out, everyone was inviting and made us feel very welcomed. Husband had combo platter, steak, oysters and shrimp - delicious!! I had the scallops and they were delish!! The cream of crab was very tasty. Thank you, Peggy States Edwards, Hook Line ~N~ Sinker
The New Yarmouth Cafe did an amazing job catering this year's New Year's Eve event! They served over 250 burgers, 300 hotdogs, 40 pounds of wings, and 10 pizzas in less than two hours. Everything was served hot (and with a smile) and the guests were very happy with the quality of the food that was provided. Larry delivered on time and consistently worked to make sure the meals were perfect. We could not have made a better choice!
I will continue this later but for now. I just want to give it all the stars available. This is a real sleeper in a very pleasant surprise after 3 years in the area we have found our favorite little spot. We are fully aware that only one meal cannot make a qualified review so we will defer until a later date after a few more visits. For now let me just say that the burger I had was the best I've had in the area. We are both anxious to see what the next few visits tell us.
I worked with Larry (owner) to cater our Pirates Weekend event at Haven Harbour South last weekend. Extremely pleased with the taste, quality, quantity and service. The lasagna, fried chicken and pulled pork were excellent! I would absolutely work with them again. We actually had quite a bit of leftover food. In the future Larry can connect us with a local charity so others can enjoy our leftovers. Thank you. HSA-1. Tim and Tammy Cossairt
We started off with some nachos. Very good. We both got the buffalo chicken salad. This was very good. Too much and we couldn't finish it. Service was excellent and all the staff were super nice.
Ordered take out .Pizza& French fries.Fries very good had a salt& pepper seasoning on them very good, pizza was a really good 16" hot.Very friendly.
Food is good, ate in once and carried out twice.
place needs cleaned and food over salted
Nice people, good food, fair prices. What's not to love?
The pizza we got wasn't cooked all the way and didn't taste very good.
Good home-style cooked food, they're warm and friendly, they are accommodating to your wishes and desires and oh did I mention it's veteran-owned.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place was just okay. It started out great with the fried pickles - I would definitely get them again because they were great - thin strips of pickle fried perfectly with a nice dip. But sadly, the dough on the inside of my stromboli wasn't cooked through - I should have sent it back, but I didn't. Instead I took it home and tried to cook it some more but that didn't really work out either. My husband wasn't expecting fried fish on his tacos - usually when he gets fish tacos, the fish is grilled or steamed or something. Anyway, I will probably give them another try sometime.
Clean place, friendly organized staff, and the crust.... oh that pizza crust! Just wow! Great experience all the way around!
We had clam strips, chicken cheesesteak, and a cheeseburger. Everything was tasty! Food was ready when promised.
Great place to grab a bite or get take out. Highly rec their Italian Stromboli. The crust is perfect, and the meats and sauce are excellent! They also do a very nice, house-made, pulled pork.
Excellent meal!! Our first visit and we will be back. From the time we walked in until the time we walked out, everyone was inviting and made us feel very welcomed. Husband had combo platter, steak, oysters and shrimp - delicious!! I had the scallops and they were delish!! The cream of crab was very tasty. Thank you, Peggy States Edwards, Hook Line ~N~ Sinker