Tonight we had the shrimp ( 5 large) stuffed with backfin crabmeat special for 22$. With it came their homemade Mac and Cheese and Asparagus. It was all so delicious. They have the best vegetables. They are always cooked to perfection. Try it while it’s on special. We love New York Pizzeria. Everyone is so nice and the food is always really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Salad, Italian Cold Cut, Cream of Crab Soup, Steak, Cream of Crab, 18' XLarge Margherita, Greek Salad, Lasagna, New York Style Supreme Pizza
Herbert “Boss” Butler
This place is really nice. The pizza was awesome. The waiters and staff . My wife and I will be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Deel
Ordered a chicken cheesesteak and got a chicken seasoning like teriyaki
MoCo Bass
Pitiful excuse of a restraunt today we usually love this place
Older guy working the tables where the bar is good.
The other lady with glasses is a pitiful excuse of a server. She’s been talking to two tables non stop absolutely not checking on anyone besides them two. I’m so livid. Amazing me someone could sit around and talk to customers like that without anyone saying anything. I will never return to this establishment
No side salad No ranch
Come on man we used to come here all the time
Reegan Tracy
They recently updated and woah it’s amazing! You need to try their weekend specials they always have the best! And try their deserts! Super friendly and welcoming environment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tim Bobyak
It was ok food and service were fine not quite as good as the original place in mt airy
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Caitie Einsfeld
Our family usually orders out for Friday night pizza night from here and we love it. During the summertime we’ve started doing lunches here on Monday since their cheese pizza deal is great- especially with our 3 children.
I took the kids in for a late lunch today by myself because my husband was working…our kids are 7, 2, and 3 months. Any mom knows that there’s a certain time limit in restaurants before your kids go crazy. We walked in, and got sat right away. Our waitress was amazing. She went above and beyond for us. She offered to double cut the pizza- “it will cool faster for your littles,” she changed the one tv behind the bar to a kid friendly show- told my 7 year old what the options were and let her pick. She kept checking on us, making sure the kids had what they needed, talked with the kids as well. When it was time to leave she took the leftover pizza and boxed it up for us, she offered to even walk the pizza out to my car with us because she saw my hands were full. I told her I think we had it and let my 7year old hold it. She said “well at least let me hold the door for you as you walk out.” I thanked her for everything and my 7 year old said “oh mommy we forgot the mints…” as we were leaving…I said it’s fine! I have mints/gum in the car- it’s raining so let’s just get in the car. We were loading everyone in their car seats and our server ran out, in the rain with a little brown bag with their mints in it. She said “here mom, you can use these for later…”
We’ve always loved the food here, and never had an issue with the service, but our server, Dora, went absolutely above and beyond for us. She said “I have twin 8 year olds…I know how this time can be.”
Our lunch was delicious, and the service was wonderful. As we were leaving, my 7 year old said “Mom, that lady…she was really nice…like REALLY nice to us.”
Thank you for being wonderful! You made our day!
Travis McBride
They have expanded the seating area. The people are very friendly, and the food is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Maria Elena Hooton
Never disappoints. Full italian menu. Wonderful customer service!
Recommended dishes: Fries with Gravy, Italian Cold Cut, Meatball Sub, Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
Daxo Men
1 min and you have to wait 45 min to pick up online order
Christine Lewis Wright
My father recently passed away and it was difficult to find a place in Eldersburg that could handle lunch for more than 50 people for the Celebration of Life. Fabio and Dora were absolutely wonderful in accommodating our party of over 70. They closed the restaurant for us on a Thursday from 12-3. They met with us to discuss the many menu options. We selected 3 appetizers, salads, and 4 entrees. They allowed us access to their tv's to run our slide show. They even let us bring our own desserts. Kudos to the servers and kitchen staff. Everything was wonderful! My father would have approved!
Kiara Romero
Excellent, food like at home
Parking: Parking in front of the restaurant, enough spaces to park
Kid-friendliness: Children's chairs, coloring pages, children's menu
Tonight we had the shrimp ( 5 large) stuffed with backfin crabmeat special for 22$. With it came their homemade Mac and Cheese and Asparagus. It was all so delicious. They have the best vegetables. They are always cooked to perfection. Try it while it’s on special. We love New York Pizzeria. Everyone is so nice and the food is always really good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Salad, Italian Cold Cut, Cream of Crab Soup, Steak, Cream of Crab, 18' XLarge Margherita, Greek Salad, Lasagna, New York Style Supreme Pizza
This place is really nice. The pizza was awesome. The waiters and staff . My wife and I will be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a chicken cheesesteak and got a chicken seasoning like teriyaki
Pitiful excuse of a restraunt today we usually love this place
Older guy working the tables where the bar is good.
The other lady with glasses is a pitiful excuse of a server. She’s been talking to two tables non stop absolutely not checking on anyone besides them two. I’m so livid. Amazing me someone could sit around and talk to customers like that without anyone saying anything. I will never return to this establishment
No side salad
No ranch
Come on man we used to come here all the time
They recently updated and woah it’s amazing! You need to try their weekend specials they always have the best! And try their deserts! Super friendly and welcoming environment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was ok food and service were fine not quite as good as the original place in mt airy
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Our family usually orders out for Friday night pizza night from here and we love it. During the summertime we’ve started doing lunches here on Monday since their cheese pizza deal is great- especially with our 3 children. I took the kids in for a late lunch today by myself because my husband was working…our kids are 7, 2, and 3 months. Any mom knows that there’s a certain time limit in restaurants before your kids go crazy. We walked in, and got sat right away. Our waitress was amazing. She went above and beyond for us. She offered to double cut the pizza- “it will cool faster for your littles,” she changed the one tv behind the bar to a kid friendly show- told my 7 year old what the options were and let her pick. She kept checking on us, making sure the kids had what they needed, talked with the kids as well. When it was time to leave she took the leftover pizza and boxed it up for us, she offered to even walk the pizza out to my car with us because she saw my hands were full. I told her I think we had it and let my 7year old hold it. She said “well at least let me hold the door for you as you walk out.” I thanked her for everything and my 7 year old said “oh mommy we forgot the mints…” as we were leaving…I said it’s fine! I have mints/gum in the car- it’s raining so let’s just get in the car. We were loading everyone in their car seats and our server ran out, in the rain with a little brown bag with their mints in it. She said “here mom, you can use these for later…” We’ve always loved the food here, and never had an issue with the service, but our server, Dora, went absolutely above and beyond for us. She said “I have twin 8 year olds…I know how this time can be.” Our lunch was delicious, and the service was wonderful. As we were leaving, my 7 year old said “Mom, that lady…she was really nice…like REALLY nice to us.” Thank you for being wonderful! You made our day!
They have expanded the seating area. The people are very friendly, and the food is great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Never disappoints. Full italian menu. Wonderful customer service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and service is always fantastic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Terrible, service and they scam if you do not tip
Food and service very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries with Gravy, Italian Cold Cut, Meatball Sub, Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce
1 min and you have to wait 45 min to pick up online order
My father recently passed away and it was difficult to find a place in Eldersburg that could handle lunch for more than 50 people for the Celebration of Life. Fabio and Dora were absolutely wonderful in accommodating our party of over 70. They closed the restaurant for us on a Thursday from 12-3. They met with us to discuss the many menu options. We selected 3 appetizers, salads, and 4 entrees. They allowed us access to their tv's to run our slide show. They even let us bring our own desserts. Kudos to the servers and kitchen staff. Everything was wonderful! My father would have approved!
Excellent, food like at home
Parking: Parking in front of the restaurant, enough spaces to park
Kid-friendliness: Children's chairs, coloring pages, children's menu
Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance ramp
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...