Love this place. Fantastic food and unique diner style decor. Fair prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
KathyC138
Charming place with wonderful breakfast!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terri Jo Tatusko
The reviews tell the truth, this place is cute and the food so yummy. I had the crab Benedict and it was a ton of food. Quick service, lots of fun decor to look at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
K U
Food was fantastic. Had the strawberry fig pancakes. The strawberry sauce was addictive. We took some home. Also had the homemade cornbeef hash. It was crispy with a great blend of potatoes meat and seasoning. Generous portions. Ice tea was spot on. Service was friendly and timely.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Wadsworth
We had Two If By Sea cater both our rehearsal dinner (a crab boil!) and our wedding day, and we are absolutely blown away by how delicious everything was. Henry made the planning process easy and straightforward, and the team truly delivered beyond our expectations. The raw bar was incredible—I don’t even usually eat oysters, and I had three because they were that good! The wedding cakes (Smith island cakes - we served multiple flavors) were out of this world delicious! A special shout-out to our bartender, Debbie, who was fantastic at both our welcome party and the wedding. We would absolutely hire Two If By Sea again for future events and highly recommend them to anyone planning a special occasion. Many of our wedding guests staying on Tilghman Island for the wedding weekend mentioned to us they went to Two If By Sea for breakfast or lunch and let us know how amazing their meals were.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Hart
Awesome. Kelly is FANTASTIC
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Cave
Amazingly delicious breakfast fare, phenomenal service and an atmosphere that you won’t find anywhere else! ❤️❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Ultimate Breakfast Sandwich, Tilghman Eggs Benedict, Chicken Biscuit and Gravy
Amelia Espina
Fast, friendly, and delicious. Taking timeless classics and cooking them to perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natasha Nash Dixon
I was on Tilghman Island early this morning and stopped at Two if by Sea for breakfast. I had seen pictures of the pancakes on FB and had to try them.
First, the restaurant has that nice down home feel from the minute you arrive. And the staff are all very sweet and they look happy to be there. Debbie was my waitress and her nephew also helped. There was another nice young man there also, working the tables and bar area. I had the best conversation with Debbie and she was excellent. I want to come back just to talk to her!
My food was Soooo good. I just ordered too much. I ordered 2 pancakes with side orders of one scrambled egg and sausage. I really just needed the pancakes with no sides. They are a meal by themselves. And when I ordered them she asked if I wanted fresh blueberries or strawberry rhubarb and I chose blueberry. Everything was perfect. And I have breakfast for tomorrow. I didn't take a picture but I wish I had.
Restaurant and kitchen is clean. The chef/cook looked happy to be there and seemed to have everything well in hand.
Highly recommend this restaurant and I will be back!
Kevin
Inspired breakfast and brunch menu. Chef/owner Henry Miller is a savant who could be running much larger and fancier kitchens. Why he chose this rustic outpost is a mystery, but thankfully he did. Easily the best breakfast on the shore. Add in some local flair (“Tilghman Tots”) and a crab option on nearly every entree (not the pancakes), and you know without doubt you are in an Eastern Shore original.
This is one of my favorite restaurants and the staff is next level awesome!!! Food does not disappoint! Yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dana Hoffer
A good option
Mike Mitchell (fmagic)
We had a great meal. We had made a reservation, and although we were seated on time, it took them 30 minutes before we even had someone come to take our drink order. That was very awkward...
Karl Berger
Wonderful breakfast dishes with plentiful crab. Crab Benedict is superb!
Jim beaupre
First time here. Breakfast was excellent and Debbie made us feel right at home. Motif is right out of 1950's and very nostalgic
Love this place. Fantastic food and unique diner style decor. Fair prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Charming place with wonderful breakfast!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The reviews tell the truth, this place is cute and the food so yummy. I had the crab Benedict and it was a ton of food. Quick service, lots of fun decor to look at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was fantastic. Had the strawberry fig pancakes. The strawberry sauce was addictive. We took some home. Also had the homemade cornbeef hash. It was crispy with a great blend of potatoes meat and seasoning. Generous portions. Ice tea was spot on. Service was friendly and timely.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had Two If By Sea cater both our rehearsal dinner (a crab boil!) and our wedding day, and we are absolutely blown away by how delicious everything was. Henry made the planning process easy and straightforward, and the team truly delivered beyond our expectations. The raw bar was incredible—I don’t even usually eat oysters, and I had three because they were that good! The wedding cakes (Smith island cakes - we served multiple flavors) were out of this world delicious! A special shout-out to our bartender, Debbie, who was fantastic at both our welcome party and the wedding. We would absolutely hire Two If By Sea again for future events and highly recommend them to anyone planning a special occasion. Many of our wedding guests staying on Tilghman Island for the wedding weekend mentioned to us they went to Two If By Sea for breakfast or lunch and let us know how amazing their meals were.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome. Kelly is FANTASTIC
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazingly delicious breakfast fare, phenomenal service and an atmosphere that you won’t find anywhere else!
❤️❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Ultimate Breakfast Sandwich, Tilghman Eggs Benedict, Chicken Biscuit and Gravy
Fast, friendly, and delicious. Taking timeless classics and cooking them to perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was on Tilghman Island early this morning and stopped at Two if by Sea for breakfast. I had seen pictures of the pancakes on FB and had to try them. First, the restaurant has that nice down home feel from the minute you arrive. And the staff are all very sweet and they look happy to be there. Debbie was my waitress and her nephew also helped. There was another nice young man there also, working the tables and bar area. I had the best conversation with Debbie and she was excellent. I want to come back just to talk to her! My food was Soooo good. I just ordered too much. I ordered 2 pancakes with side orders of one scrambled egg and sausage. I really just needed the pancakes with no sides. They are a meal by themselves. And when I ordered them she asked if I wanted fresh blueberries or strawberry rhubarb and I chose blueberry. Everything was perfect. And I have breakfast for tomorrow. I didn't take a picture but I wish I had. Restaurant and kitchen is clean. The chef/cook looked happy to be there and seemed to have everything well in hand. Highly recommend this restaurant and I will be back!
Inspired breakfast and brunch menu. Chef/owner Henry Miller is a savant who could be running much larger and fancier kitchens. Why he chose this rustic outpost is a mystery, but thankfully he did. Easily the best breakfast on the shore. Add in some local flair (“Tilghman Tots”) and a crab option on nearly every entree (not the pancakes), and you know without doubt you are in an Eastern Shore original.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is one of my favorite restaurants and the staff is next level awesome!!! Food does not disappoint! Yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A good option
We had a great meal. We had made a reservation, and although we were seated on time, it took them 30 minutes before we even had someone come to take our drink order. That was very awkward...
Wonderful breakfast dishes with plentiful crab. Crab Benedict is superb!
First time here. Breakfast was excellent and Debbie made us feel right at home. Motif is right out of 1950's and very nostalgic
Loading...