Restaurants near Tilghman

“I was on Tilghman Island early this morning and stopped at Two if by Sea for breakfast. I had seen pictures of the pancakes on FB and had to try them. First, the restaurant has that nice down home feel from the minute you arrive. And the staff are all very sweet and they look happy to be there. Debbie was my waitress and her nephew also helped. There was another nice young man there also, working the tables and bar area. I had the best conversation with Debbie and she was excellent. I want to come back just to talk to her! My food was Soooo good. I just ordered too much. I ordered 2 pancakes with side orders of one scrambled egg and sausage. I really just needed the pancakes with no sides. They are a meal by themselves. And when I ordered them she asked if I wanted fresh blueberries or strawberry rhubarb and I chose blueberry. Everything was perfect. And I have breakfast for tomorrow. I didn't take a picture but I wish I had. Restaurant and kitchen is clean. The chef/cook looked happy to be there and seemed to have everything well in hand. Highly recommend this restaurant and I will be back!”

“If you’re hanging out in Saint Michael’s or any of the beautiful adjacent towns on vacation, then you definitely have to make your way to tickler‘s crab shack and restaurant. Trust me, the locals definitely know about this restaurant.
Located behind Wyler Hotel, with a commanding view of Harris Creek, Tickler’s is an exceptional establishment for family get together or a romantic dinner.
The crabs 🦀 are medium to large and are heavy. Have fun digging in!
The staff at tickler’s are awesome. They definitely got the extra mile to make sure that you have an outstanding experience.”

“What a hidden gem ! Very cool & welcoming atmosphere! Our meals were flavorful & phenomenal! The beef rib special = chef’s kiss ! We will be back!”

“Absolutely phenomenal space with an amazingly knowledgeable staff that’ll ensure that you have a great experience!”

“Bistro St. Michaels is just amazing. From the moment you walk in to the moment you leave, everything is great. The staff is awesome and the food is beyond amazing. My husband and I come every year for our anniversary, and it somehow gets better each time. We always sit at the chef’s table, and it honestly feels like home. The kitchen staff is super kind and even remembers us every year. We highly recommend you experience this wonderful establishment. Thank you guys for always being so kind to us! You know who you are 😉”

“SO YUMMY and fresh”

“We dined at STARS to celebrate my wife's birthday. We sere seated at a wonderful table facing the water. We both chose seafood, my wife the crab cakes, and I the Black Bass and we shared a dumpling appetizer and a dessert. In my opinion the appetizer and the Bass could have been seasoned more, though the fish itself was cooked properly. My wife enjoyed the crab cakes. The service was very good as was the selection of wines.”

“Absolutely love Blue Heron Coffee — it’s hands down my favorite for fresh roasted coffee. Their iced lattes are fantastic every single time, smooth, refreshing, and perfectly made. Such a great spot you can always count on!”

“Our favorite place in St. Michael’s!! So glad they opened another location close to our home. But, this is our favorite vibe and feel. Highly recommend. If you don’t get the green bean and prosciutto salad you haven’t lived!!”

“The folks at Rise Up were helpful and friendly, and even gave us a small side cup of honey no charge. The only problem was that they take cash tips only and there is no option to tip if you use a card, so if you don’t have cash, you can’t tip. My husband had a very good double shot of espresso and my matcha latte with oat milk was excellent.”

“👏 After a long days work craving some of Elijah's award winning crab and corn chowder, we popped in for take out smash burgers and chowder, best take out meal everrrr made our day! slamm dunk per usual! THE BEST”

“Beautiful Sun Day spent at Foxy's! Thank You, to our server, Travis, who made sure all of our food and drink needs were met, and with a smile! We appreciate the professional, friendly service! We'll be back. 😊”

“We had a wonderful dinner a few weeks ago at Theo’s that was superb. The front desk was welcoming and courteous. Our server, Caroline, was efficient and accommodating. We ordered the châteaubrio for two, and the steak was cooked perfectly. The atmosphere is relaxing and cozy. We are heading back again soon for another wonderful dining experience.”

“We love everything about San Miguels. A family owned and operated business providing great food and service. The hostess is courteous and accommodating. The owner, Jennifer, is always present and welcoming. The service is awesome. The whole team works cohesively and professionally. The food is freshly prepared and presented with a festive flare. The salsa, guacamole and house made sauces are delicious. The beef and chicken is cooked to perfection with a wonderful blend of spices. The margaritas are delightful and the tequila selection is amazing. It’s a great place to enjoy great food! We also love Jennifer’s additional restaurant, The Galley. We highly recommend both locations for an excellent dining experience!”

“The price is right and the seafood is delicious from the Korean mussels, shrimp🦐🍤, 🦀crabs🦀everything is great. I love the different flavors and am going to miss them when they close. 😩”

“Best Chinese food in sunshine hands down”

“Our home grown server at dinner the night before said C Street had the best breakfast in St. Michaels. Glad we took her advice. I started with a fried oyster appetizer and had one of the best spinach omelettes I've had in years. Fresh ingredients, well prepared. Excellent and prompt service. Very casual and friendly atmosphere.”

“Everything! Everything! Everything! Gina, thanks for getting Redbreast. True to my promise, I’ve had a glass every time I’ve visited. Now, if you can find Redbreast Lustau, I’ll have two every time I come in. Thanks again and good luck with your new place in Tilgham. “Santa””

“As one of the first employees of the Blue Crab under Brian and Hellen, I can say that the vibes are immaculate and you can feel their flair throughout the entire building. The coffee choice is the best on the Eastern Shore (over Rise Up) and they don’t try to be fancy with their menu. It’s fairly straightforward and everything is delicious (I’ve tasted it all). I may have moved away and be saddened by the couple stepping away but I know the folks at the bagery are just as passionate. I will continue to stop by whenever I can and support not only an amazing business but also the people in this community. I recommend you try it out whenever you’re in St. Michaels. It’s the perfect place to escape and relax for even just a moment. Thank you Brian and Hellen. I’m so grateful for your love and kindness to the St. Michaels community.”

“Since checking this place out, I have become a regular customer, and now come in 1-2x a week for a grocery restock. I have had no time to cook since the new year and had been eating out almost every meal.... but there are so few places around with healthy options. I am so picky about what fruits and veggies, organic items, etc. that I eat, and thankfully sprouts has provided great options for that! The baristas/cashiers are always so helpful and kind to us. Some of my favorites are-- ALL of the soups (seriously that chicken and rice is perfection, especially if you are under the weather), turkey chili, thai wrap, veggie wrap, egg roll in a bowl, drunken noodles, bbq chicken and succotash, the vitality ginger drink (that spice burns but feels good!), the challah and sourdough bread, eskimo bites for a treat, and the strawberry blondie brownies! I am trying new things as the menu changes, but these have been on my constant restock when available of what I have had so far!! I recently learned they can heat the items for you, so you can eat a hot meal there (I have not done this yet myself, as this is like grocery shopping for me so i take it home... but i have seen lots of people in there enjoying their meals!) I have seen some complain about the prices, but if you know the quality of what you are getting (local, organic), then you would realize these are very fair prices! If I have ever wanted to request something or had a slight issue, Sprouts has always been more than happy to accommodate. Thank you Sprouts for providing great service and food options to the community! You will see me again soon! Gluten free, Dairy free, or Flexitarian, check them out!”

“Sadly even though I generally love Subway my last order was hugely disappointing and we will never order thru the App again. Was NOT toasted, paid for smashed avacados & extra cheese on 2 footings and did NOT get extras or toasted on either 😭. On a positive note, go in and have built in front of you and they are great.”

“Placed an order and received the very next day! Amazing customer service and everything was absolutely delicious! I’m in WV and tried one of your bars while visiting DE. So happy to have stumbled across your page! Will definitely be ordering again. Thank you! ❤️”

“Food is always delicious.”

“Local oysters were so good!”

“We had a wonderful experience at St. Michaels Winery for our friend's birthday! The wine was wonderful, though it is mainly a sweet selection. It is not a large place, but is perfectly cozy. Jim went above and beyond to create a memorable experience for our group.”

“Best crabs & crab cakes! Cooked to PERFECTION and the flavor was AMAZING! Great staff & casual, comfy environment as well!”

“This lounge is beautiful! Great atmosphere and small plate food. The tempura is excellent. Highly recommend”

“We ate at Limoncello for the first time for our anniversary this weekend and it was fantastic! The decor was lovely and the food was amazing—like being in Italy for real. We can’t wait to go back and would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone!”