Really cool bakery with creative baked good options. For Thanksgiving went there for a 6-pack of holiday themed cupcakes for $25. Very cute and tasty. The themes a re in the frosting. Service was great. Lots of very cool options. They are right next door to a bakery, so you can get baked and then have some baked goods 😁👍‼️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Meaghan Renkey
Starry Nights was the perfect pick for our wedding cake and cupcakes! We were looking for a vendor who would provide 120-150 cupcakes in a variety of flavors as well as a small cake for cutting all of which, we wanted GLUTEN FREE. Starry Nights was able to accommodate the request at a great price and went above and beyond in helping us decide on all our flavor combinations. We ended up with a naked strawberry yellow cake with rum mousse filling along with 4 types of cupcakes (strawberry yellowcake, Carmel frosted chocolate, pumpkin chia spice, and raspberry frosted and filled chocolate). I tried all and they were all fantastic. Starry Night was professional, quick to respond, and a pleasure to work with. They were even kind enough to offer additional cupcakes for guests with additional dietary restrictions. Couldn't recommend them higher!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Assorted Cupcakes
Kimberly Thomas
We chose Starry Night Bakery because we decided to do an assortment of treats and a small tier wedding cake at our wedding. I worked with the owner, Shannon, who was so incredibly helpful throughout the entire process. She had the best recommendations on the most popular assortment of mini desserts. We had so many compliments from guests that they loved all the desserts! Their staff set everything up the day of and made our day so perfect! Highly recommend them!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Schatz
I ordered a keto chocolate chip cookie cheesecake online to celebrate my fiancé and I’s anniversary. It was done on time and everyone behind the counter was helpful and friendly. Pick up was smooth, I was in and out. I even got some of the cotton candy funfetti cupcakes for my son (which he loved). The cheesecake was incredible! I’m on keto and my fiancé is not, but we both absolutely loved it. Totally made our anniversary, thank you! 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Keto Cookie Butter Cheesecake
Christa Mobley
We had a bunch of their cupcakes at our wedding and they were just so So delicious and everyone loved them! We did a combination of big filled cupcakes and smaller, bite-size cupcakes, and that was fun and everybody got to try different flavor combinations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catherine Noll
Service 5. Friendliness 5. Food fantastic. I review very seldom. They deserved my review.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
tami weber
Delicious, service was excellent and nice atmosphere ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gretchen
I used Starry Night Bakery for my wedding—they made a cake and cupcakes for me and I was beyond pleased with the results. I showed them pictures of what I wanted and they turned everything into real life. I also had them deliver the cake to the barn where my reception was, and I wasn’t sure if they would know where to put it so I had a friend waiting there to direct and/or set things up as needed. She told me afterwards that they took the time to arrange the cake and cupcakes themselves. My husband and I didn’t get to really eat the cake on our wedding day of course, but thankfully we got some pieces afterwards and it was DELICIOUS. The cake is so light and flavorful. I had carrot cake for my top layer and amaretto for the bottom layer, and while both were delightful, the amaretto was to die for.
Good looking cake but…. The price is for quality but that is not what you will get. The frosting is clearly crisco or lard and sugar. That’s it, no flavor. We got two: Chocolate and key lime. The key lime is clearly flavored with green jello. I don’t know anyone that likes green jello. Chocolate cake was pretty and cake inside was good but the frosting was absolutely disgusting. Cherry inside was just pink flavorless crisco. This is so low quality I will never go back. You do actually have to make a cake that tastes good and isn’t just something pretty to look at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Nevaeh Diane
I bought gluten free cupcakes from here - with buttercream and ganache. Wow! They were to die for!!!! So delicious! Would totally recommend!
My daughter surprised me with a birthday cake from Starry Nights Bakery. This is not her first purchase. We are both semi regular customers of several years standing. We have never been disappointed…until now.
Customer service was awesome, per my daughter. The ordering process was effortless, as was the pick up.
The cake was beautifully decorated. However, the detail of leveling the cake prior to stacking and icing it would have been appreciated. The domes of the cakes appear to have not been removed at all. A small but important detail I’m surprised a bakery of this caliber omitted.
This omission left a poor ratio of cake to icing and made the cake unattractive once cut. There were globs of icing used to fill in the gaps created by the cake dome of the inverted cake resting on the dome of the bottom half.
Really cool bakery with creative baked good options. For Thanksgiving went there for a 6-pack of holiday themed cupcakes for $25. Very cute and tasty. The themes a re in the frosting. Service was great. Lots of very cool options. They are right next door to a bakery, so you can get baked and then have some baked goods 😁👍‼️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Starry Nights was the perfect pick for our wedding cake and cupcakes! We were looking for a vendor who would provide 120-150 cupcakes in a variety of flavors as well as a small cake for cutting all of which, we wanted GLUTEN FREE. Starry Nights was able to accommodate the request at a great price and went above and beyond in helping us decide on all our flavor combinations. We ended up with a naked strawberry yellow cake with rum mousse filling along with 4 types of cupcakes (strawberry yellowcake, Carmel frosted chocolate, pumpkin chia spice, and raspberry frosted and filled chocolate). I tried all and they were all fantastic. Starry Night was professional, quick to respond, and a pleasure to work with. They were even kind enough to offer additional cupcakes for guests with additional dietary restrictions. Couldn't recommend them higher!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Assorted Cupcakes
We chose Starry Night Bakery because we decided to do an assortment of treats and a small tier wedding cake at our wedding. I worked with the owner, Shannon, who was so incredibly helpful throughout the entire process. She had the best recommendations on the most popular assortment of mini desserts. We had so many compliments from guests that they loved all the desserts! Their staff set everything up the day of and made our day so perfect! Highly recommend them!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a keto chocolate chip cookie cheesecake online to celebrate my fiancé and I’s anniversary. It was done on time and everyone behind the counter was helpful and friendly. Pick up was smooth, I was in and out. I even got some of the cotton candy funfetti cupcakes for my son (which he loved). The cheesecake was incredible! I’m on keto and my fiancé is not, but we both absolutely loved it. Totally made our anniversary, thank you! 😊
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Keto Cookie Butter Cheesecake
We had a bunch of their cupcakes at our wedding and they were just so So delicious and everyone loved them! We did a combination of big filled cupcakes and smaller, bite-size cupcakes, and that was fun and everybody got to try different flavor combinations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service 5. Friendliness 5. Food fantastic. I review very seldom. They deserved my review.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious, service was excellent and nice atmosphere ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used Starry Night Bakery for my wedding—they made a cake and cupcakes for me and I was beyond pleased with the results. I showed them pictures of what I wanted and they turned everything into real life. I also had them deliver the cake to the barn where my reception was, and I wasn’t sure if they would know where to put it so I had a friend waiting there to direct and/or set things up as needed. She told me afterwards that they took the time to arrange the cake and cupcakes themselves. My husband and I didn’t get to really eat the cake on our wedding day of course, but thankfully we got some pieces afterwards and it was DELICIOUS. The cake is so light and flavorful. I had carrot cake for my top layer and amaretto for the bottom layer, and while both were delightful, the amaretto was to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Assorted Cupcakes
Good looking cake but…. The price is for quality but that is not what you will get. The frosting is clearly crisco or lard and sugar. That’s it, no flavor. We got two: Chocolate and key lime. The key lime is clearly flavored with green jello. I don’t know anyone that likes green jello. Chocolate cake was pretty and cake inside was good but the frosting was absolutely disgusting. Cherry inside was just pink flavorless crisco. This is so low quality I will never go back. You do actually have to make a cake that tastes good and isn’t just something pretty to look at.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
I bought gluten free cupcakes from here - with buttercream and ganache. Wow! They were to die for!!!! So delicious! Would totally recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
My daughter surprised me with a birthday cake from Starry Nights Bakery. This is not her first purchase. We are both semi regular customers of several years standing. We have never been disappointed…until now.
Customer service was awesome, per my daughter. The ordering process was effortless, as was the pick up.
The cake was beautifully decorated. However, the detail of leveling the cake prior to stacking and icing it would have been appreciated. The domes of the cakes appear to have not been removed at all. A small but important detail I’m surprised a bakery of this caliber omitted.
This omission left a poor ratio of cake to icing and made the cake unattractive once cut. There were globs of icing used to fill in the gaps created by the cake dome of the inverted cake resting on the dome of the bottom half.
Disappointed but not deterred from future visits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coffee & Cupcake, Assorted Cupcakes
Amazing cupcakes plus vegan options like dairy free and gluten free, very good customer service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I bought gluten free cupcakes from here - with buttercream and ganache. Wow! They were to die for!!!! So delicious! Would totally recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is always fantastic.
Been around forever for a reason.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cupcakes for my son’s birthday party were perfect!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...