Pilgrim's Inn

We have had mixed experiences at the Whale's Rib tavern, some very good but last night was disappointing. My wife had a cod dish and I had Wagyu steak. The cod was lukewarm and the accompanying potatoes were undercooked. My steak, which I ordered medium, was barely rare. On the plus side the sauces were quite good, and the server quite personable. Perhaps it had something to do with being at the end of the season, but these mistakes are characteristic of a kitchen that does not...read full review

A marvelous inn with a great dining room downstairs. The food is elegantly prepared, very delicious and served graciously. We love Whale Rib's Tavern part of (and separate from) the Pilgrim Inn

We dined on a Thursday evening and the food (delicious) and service (friendly and courteous) were wonderful. We had the mussels and fennel/apple salad as starters. My husband had the seafood stew, slightly spicy, which he enjoyed. I had the lobster “pot pie”. Both the maple walnut ice cream sundae with caramelized popcorn and the spiced apple cake with pumpkin walnut ice cream were perfect endings to our great meal! We look forward to returning on our next trip to Deer Isle...read full review