Stopped in for a later Sunday dinner and had great and friendly service by Jill. Good beer selection, the gobbler sandwich did not disappoint, and the pub side had great ambiance. Will go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michael george
Food is good nice place to meet up with old friends
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sandy Cleveland
Our bartender and server C J was great! We live in Raymond and were looking for a different place to go. Well worth the drive. Not busy at 2:00 on a Tuesday, but very welcoming. Chicken wrap was awesome!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Michael Johnson
Food was great!! The waitress/bartender was awesome as well as a cutie pie!!! (Elizabeth) Highly recommend it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Nancy Strini
Really excellent food, great cocktails and wonderful service by Jesse!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darryl Sampson
Great food and service every time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Louiselle
My party of 9 had dinner last night here. The atmosphere and food were excellent. It helped to have made a reservation because I saw people having to wait. My only complaint, which really irks me, is the tricky extra fees restaurants slap onto the bill. When taking our orders the server says, “Would you like a baked potato, mashed potato, fries, sweet potato fries or onion rings?” As if they are all included equally as part of the meal options. We are a family who loves sweet potato fries and ended up with nearly everyone being charged $3 extra on each meal because of it. That was a bit cunning and left a bad taste in my mouth on the way out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Christy Brown
Elizabeth is amazing! Always friendly and lighting fast. Love this place.
This was the worst service experience that I have ever had in a restaurant. My server, ELIZABETH B, actually raised her voice and yelled at me that the reason I did not receive what I ordered was my fault!!! When I first addressed ELIZABETH B about my order I told her I knew it wasn’t her fault, but…. And, she proceeded to yell at me! I never have received such disrespect in a restaurant!. Where is the customer service? I told ELIZABETH B that she was loosing her tip. This is something I have never done. Thank goodness this is not my first visit to Maine, she should be embarrassed.
Service: 1
Katherine A Champagne
This survey needs to stop asking , Personally i DO NOT enjoy the atmospheric conditions and conflicts inside olde mill tavern
Not a bad place great people great food the cook ben will make it happen for you no complaints good old American tavern great bartenders great drinks
Corey “cdog2366” H
A friend of mine and I went to the Olde Mill Tavern on Harrison on 5/19/25 for an early dinner. I have to share it was AMAZING! I had the NY Strip Steak dinner. It might be the best piece of steak I’ve had in my life, and it was cooked to perfection! Hot, tender and juicy, WOW! My friend had the Baked Haddock dinner and it was excellent as well. The waitress was fantastic service was quick and food was hot. Really great experience and great food. As far as price, honestly the dinners were pretty expensive $29 and $27 but, I minded that less after tasting the steak! I would definitely recommend going there.
Douglas Kilgore
Great place for any meal or just to have a drink. Nice atmosphere with interesting items thruout to check out. Easy access.
Amber Riendeau
We went around 1ish and it wasn’t busy but it wasn’t completely empty. The food was fresh and tasty. It’s for sure a hidden gem! The places like it would a great local hotspot!
Stopped in for a later Sunday dinner and had great and friendly service by Jill. Good beer selection, the gobbler sandwich did not disappoint, and the pub side had great ambiance. Will go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is good nice place to meet up with old friends
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our bartender and server C J was great! We live in Raymond and were looking for a different place to go.
Well worth the drive. Not busy at 2:00 on a Tuesday, but very welcoming. Chicken wrap was awesome!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Food was great!! The waitress/bartender was awesome as well as a cutie pie!!! (Elizabeth) Highly recommend it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Really excellent food, great cocktails and wonderful service by Jesse!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and service every time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My party of 9 had dinner last night here. The atmosphere and food were excellent. It helped to have made a reservation because I saw people having to wait. My only complaint, which really irks me, is the tricky extra fees restaurants slap onto the bill. When taking our orders the server says, “Would you like a baked potato, mashed potato, fries, sweet potato fries or onion rings?” As if they are all included equally as part of the meal options. We are a family who loves sweet potato fries and ended up with nearly everyone being charged $3 extra on each meal because of it. That was a bit cunning and left a bad taste in my mouth on the way out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Elizabeth is amazing! Always friendly and lighting fast. Love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nachos El Grande, Steak Tips, Garden Salad, Chowder, Chili, Quesadilla
This was the worst service experience that I have ever had in a restaurant. My server, ELIZABETH B, actually raised her voice and yelled at me that the reason I did not receive what I ordered was my fault!!! When I first addressed ELIZABETH B about my order I told her I knew it wasn’t her fault, but…. And,
she proceeded to yell at me! I never have received such disrespect in a restaurant!. Where is the customer service? I told ELIZABETH B that she was loosing her tip. This is something I have never done.
Thank goodness this is not my first visit to Maine, she should be embarrassed.
Service: 1
This survey needs to stop asking ,
Personally i DO NOT enjoy the atmospheric conditions and conflicts inside olde mill tavern
Restaurantji Recommends
Not a bad place great people great food the cook ben will make it happen for you no complaints good old American tavern great bartenders great drinks
A friend of mine and I went to the Olde Mill Tavern on Harrison on 5/19/25 for an early dinner. I have to share it was AMAZING! I had the NY Strip Steak dinner. It might be the best piece of steak I’ve had in my life, and it was cooked to perfection! Hot, tender and juicy, WOW! My friend had the Baked Haddock dinner and it was excellent as well. The waitress was fantastic service was quick and food was hot. Really great experience and great food. As far as price, honestly the dinners were pretty expensive $29 and $27 but, I minded that less after tasting the steak! I would definitely recommend going there.
Great place for any meal or just to have a drink. Nice atmosphere with interesting items thruout to check out. Easy access.
We went around 1ish and it wasn’t busy but it wasn’t completely empty. The food was fresh and tasty. It’s for sure a hidden gem! The places like it would a great local hotspot!
Live music Friday night.
And prime rib.
Loading...