Small portions of clearly not fresh food that only filled half a bun of both the fish and chicken sando, neither of which came out as ordered. Expensive for less than dollar menu quality…
Andrew G.
Overpriced food but At least the food was good. Could use a better selection but I'm sure limited to what they get on the island. Service was friendly, and kind.
joanne macisaac
So disappointed - ordered two lobster rolls - the lobster was dry, overcooked and had a spice that was not disclosed - bun was stale and too big for the amount of lobster -
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
David Moradi
Worst restaurant experience in Portland. Way overpriced and not tasty.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Christophe Naud-Dulude
Waited for 30 minutes to be told they were not taking orders because they were swamped. There was at most 3 tables waiting. Waste of time.
Quin D.
Got the Cajun chicken sandwich. It was a HUGE chicken breast (over an inch tall) that was cut in half horizontally. I couldn't fit the sandwich in my mouth. The chicken was obviously boiled and the only seasoning was they put on raw cayenne pepper after it was done boiling. I couldn't even finish the sandwich because of how tasteless and dry it was. It was served on stale bread, with pre packaged chipotle mayo, and with unwashed dirty lettuce and tomato. It was also like $17 or $18 and came with no sides except half a bag of lays potato chips...
Froggy1313
Best hot lobster roll of the trip! Warm, sweet, lots of meat. My daughter had the Cajun chicken and really liked it.
Svava Cushing
First time there. Fish sandwich was almost inedible. Fish was old and obviously previously frozen.Had a very bad taste to it. The bun was equally bad. Onion rings were
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Michael Mcdonald
Great food, perfect ambience.Vegetarian options: Available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff B
We went out for reggae Sunday. The food was incredible. The views on the island spectacular. The music from Stream Reggae was wonderful. Highly recommend.
Costumer service was bad. My nana and I went and when we asked for a Togo box in the process of ordering. they didn’t put them in one. After asking again we were given an attitude. They cooked our side and main dishes separately so we waited for our sides while our mains got cold. When we got back home we find out our order wasn’t correct. Also after being asked “what’s the issue?” we explained and received burnt Brussels sprouts in return.
barbacoami
great service and very pet friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily V.
My mom and I stopped here for lunch before we got on the ferry. We both got lobster rolls. I thought they were kind of skimpy and the bread wasn't that great either. The fries were okay. Overall for the price I think you can get much better lobster rolls elsewhere in the area.
Susan L.
this is the first lobster shack u see once you get off the ferry at peaks island (right by the golf cart rental) so we saw a lot of ppl stopping by here grabbing a bite while killing time waiting for their rentals. the lobster roll was fine, nothing bad about them but nothing amazing either. we tried the original maine style (cold and fresh) and the captains style (warm with butter). i think i enjoyed the captains style more just because the ingredients seemed to blend well but they were both just regular lobster rolls to me. i'd rather spend the money at other spots just bc each roll is $30
Attaquin Weeden
Me and my fiancé shared the breakfast tacos and we highly recommend them!They taste amazing and healthy nice and fresh with a great crunch on the corn tortilla!
Small portions of clearly not fresh food that only filled half a bun of both the fish and chicken sando, neither of which came out as ordered. Expensive for less than dollar menu quality…
Overpriced food but At least the food was good. Could use a better selection but I'm sure limited to what they get on the island. Service was friendly, and kind.
So disappointed - ordered two lobster rolls - the lobster was dry, overcooked and had a spice that was not disclosed - bun was stale and too big for the amount of lobster -
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Worst restaurant experience in Portland. Way overpriced and not tasty.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Waited for 30 minutes to be told they were not taking orders because they were swamped. There was at most 3 tables waiting. Waste of time.
Got the Cajun chicken sandwich. It was a HUGE chicken breast (over an inch tall) that was cut in half horizontally. I couldn't fit the sandwich in my mouth. The chicken was obviously boiled and the only seasoning was they put on raw cayenne pepper after it was done boiling. I couldn't even finish the sandwich because of how tasteless and dry it was. It was served on stale bread, with pre packaged chipotle mayo, and with unwashed dirty lettuce and tomato. It was also like $17 or $18 and came with no sides except half a bag of lays potato chips...
Best hot lobster roll of the trip! Warm, sweet, lots of meat. My daughter had the Cajun chicken and really liked it.
First time there. Fish sandwich was almost inedible. Fish was old and obviously previously frozen.Had a very bad taste to it. The bun was equally bad. Onion rings were
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great food, perfect ambience.Vegetarian options: Available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went out for reggae Sunday. The food was incredible. The views on the island spectacular. The music from Stream Reggae was wonderful. Highly recommend.
Restaurantji Recommends
Costumer service was bad. My nana and I went and when we asked for a Togo box in the process of ordering. they didn’t put them in one. After asking again we were given an attitude. They cooked our side and main dishes separately so we waited for our sides while our mains got cold. When we got back home we find out our order wasn’t correct. Also after being asked “what’s the issue?” we explained and received burnt Brussels sprouts in return.
great service and very pet friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My mom and I stopped here for lunch before we got on the ferry. We both got lobster rolls. I thought they were kind of skimpy and the bread wasn't that great either. The fries were okay. Overall for the price I think you can get much better lobster rolls elsewhere in the area.
this is the first lobster shack u see once you get off the ferry at peaks island (right by the golf cart rental) so we saw a lot of ppl stopping by here grabbing a bite while killing time waiting for their rentals. the lobster roll was fine, nothing bad about them but nothing amazing either. we tried the original maine style (cold and fresh) and the captains style (warm with butter). i think i enjoyed the captains style more just because the ingredients seemed to blend well but they were both just regular lobster rolls to me. i'd rather spend the money at other spots just bc each roll is $30
Me and my fiancé shared the breakfast tacos and we highly recommend them!They taste amazing and healthy nice and fresh with a great crunch on the corn tortilla!