6 Best American Restaurants near Presque Isle

“I took my Mom to Teresa’s today (May 14, 2025) and I had the lobster roll and my Mom had the tenderloin clams..I also ordered homemade onion rings. Our food was delicious, plentiful and served with a smile by our very attentive server! We were so pleased and surprised at the quality of the food and the quantity! Everything was PERFECT! I’ll be back..it had been 3 years since I’d been there….I have to wonder if it’s under new ownership?“

“the place is awesome I haven't been home since 1989“

“Cant say I've had better seafood fried or broiled! The seafood platter was 2x what i could eat and normally I can put one down myself. Even the sides were great! The mashed potatoes and gravey we got for my little one sparked the rest of us to order a side of them too! Deserts we have had were all amazing as well. We have been back 4 times in 3 weeks to get our fill before we head back down to Florida. Oh and I cant forget the waiter who was fantastic! He basically remembered our orders from a week back and was always attentive and helpful but never hovering over us. He just came at the right time everytime for us! This will be our go too place when we stay at our place in Monticello for sure! The lemon and blueberry cake with cheesecake icing we ordered was the size of a cake and DELICIOUS!“

“We had a fantastic experience dining out! The food was delicious, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming, and the service truly made the night. A special shoutout to our waitress, Mia—she was absolutely awesome! Friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, she went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed. It’s clear she cares about her guests and takes pride in her work. We’ll definitely be back—and we’ll be asking for Mia again!“

“We enjoyed a delicious breakfast/brunch this morning and had excellent service. My husband had an omelette with toast and grilled home fries with onions. I had a breakfast quesadilla with a side of bacon. Everything was cooked to perfection and served hot. We both agreed that it was the best breakfast we’ve had anywhere.“

“I had my first experience with NMBC a couple of weeks ago. It was incredible. I had cheddar bites for an appetizer. They were honestly a little on the greasy side but tasted great. I never order haddock in a restaurant because it's usually tasteless, but the Haddock Weaver came highly recommended so I tried it. It was the best haddock I've ever eaten. It was truly delicious, as were the loaded cheese fries and even the veggie was wonderful. Service was good, atmosphere was nice. I was very impressed and will most definitely be back.“