In Brighton, this is one of my favorite places to go! The Stillwater Grill salad is one of my go-tos, but honestly, anything on the menu is great! The wine and cocktail menu has something for everyone and the servers and bartenders do a great job of taking care of you without hovering too much. In the summer, the outdoor patio is a great place to dine. Always a good time and great food.
Michael Killian
With a wonderful atmosphere and friendly staff Stillwater grill is one you don't want to miss! We will be back again.
Best Crab Cakes ever. Best Cashew Salmon ever. My Moscow mule was delicious. We love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque
Dock Master
Ribs were less than average. Salmon was a wet sloppy disappointment. Many other fine choices in area. Will not return.
Matt Swink
Shrimp was burnt, and the steak was medium well. I ordered medium rare.
Grace Willer
I had grilled salmon and salad. which was delicious, and my husband had the French dip and fries, and he loved it.They bring warm bread to the table that is out of this world. We tried the clam chowder . The flavor was good, but it was more of a light broth rather than a thick and creamy consistency.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Stillwater Salad
Shelagh B.
Our family has been to Stillwater Grill multiple times since we moved to Brighton two years ago. We can always count on a nice table, great service and very good food. My husband always gets a steak and I'm partial to the French Onion Soup (amazing!) and the French Dip (yum!). We've brought our adult kids with us many times and sometimes the grandchildren and we are always pleased with the food and service. I truly wouldn't change a thing.
Michael Grover
Chicken piccata was decent, but not enough sauce overall.
My sweet husband took me on a date tonight to Stillwater for a much needed night out. It was wonderful! No loud music or TV, no dog begging but pretending not to, no dishes to wash.And our waitress, Jennifer, was awesome. We explained that we have been working at a deep spring cleaning for like 10 days straight gearing up for new carpet, and we needed to just relax. She listened! She timed our courses perfectly allowing us to have a leisurely meal, not rushed or working to get new butts in our seats. She allowed us to breathe. The next time we go there. We will be requesting her. Thank You Jennifer!!!The food was good. One thing though. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip appetizer which I have always loved. Unfortunately, it was disappointing. They have changed the recipe. It is now more like a queso dip. The original is 100% better. I wish they would go back to the original. And just a side note. They need to sharpen their steak knives.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathan E.
I can honestly say that was the worst prime rib I have ever had in my entire life. The rest of my party loved their food. They all ordered fish. I guess the moral of my review is to order the fish and avoid the steak.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jorge9156
Disappointed! We hadn’t been to Stillwater in some years so we were anxious to be back to have a good meal. We ordered the soup special Salmon Chowder, steak tips with grilled salmon, ScallopsThe chowder when brought the table looked unappealing; grey in color making it not appetizing. The first taste was very fishy and too much tarragon. Unfortunately we sent it back.The steak tips and grilled salmon were disappointing. The salmon looked slightly grey. Not the typical pinkish color. Looked more like chicken breast. The steak tips were lathered in too must sauce. Normally the tips are seared and expected a good sauce. The sauce was more like a BBQ sauce. Too sweet. If it was supposed to be Cajun we couldn’t tell.All in all we were disappointed and not likely to return. Generally we are not this picky, but given the price point of the menu items, we would expect better quality
Eric Slee
Very nice ,would
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sarrah C.
Service was good but not overly impressed by the experience for the price. Good ambience. Party of 4. One mixed drink was so strong, it was nearly clear. The waitress promptly adressed it. Appetizers were quite good. Two at our table ordered the same filet dish,both cooked to mid-rare; one was accurate, the other nearly well done. Again the waitress was quick to address but it was disappointing. Portion size for the entree sides is oddly small for the price of the dishes.
In Brighton, this is one of my favorite places to go! The Stillwater Grill salad is one of my go-tos, but honestly, anything on the menu is great! The wine and cocktail menu has something for everyone and the servers and bartenders do a great job of taking care of you without hovering too much. In the summer, the outdoor patio is a great place to dine. Always a good time and great food.
With a wonderful atmosphere and friendly staff Stillwater grill is one you don't want to miss! We will be back again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cajun Tenderloin Tips, Lobster Bisque
Best Crab Cakes ever. Best Cashew Salmon ever. My Moscow mule was delicious. We love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque
Ribs were less than average. Salmon was a wet sloppy disappointment. Many other fine choices in area. Will not return.
Shrimp was burnt, and the steak was medium well. I ordered medium rare.
I had grilled salmon and salad. which was delicious, and my husband had the French dip and fries, and he loved it.They bring warm bread to the table that is out of this world. We tried the clam chowder . The flavor was good, but it was more of a light broth rather than a thick and creamy consistency.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Side Stillwater Salad
Our family has been to Stillwater Grill multiple times since we moved to Brighton two years ago. We can always count on a nice table, great service and very good food. My husband always gets a steak and I'm partial to the French Onion Soup (amazing!) and the French Dip (yum!). We've brought our adult kids with us many times and sometimes the grandchildren and we are always pleased with the food and service. I truly wouldn't change a thing.
Chicken piccata was decent, but not enough sauce overall.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
The food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cajun Tenderloin Tips
Nice evening out, great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
My sweet husband took me on a date tonight to Stillwater for a much needed night out. It was wonderful! No loud music or TV, no dog begging but pretending not to, no dishes to wash.And our waitress, Jennifer, was awesome. We explained that we have been working at a deep spring cleaning for like 10 days straight gearing up for new carpet, and we needed to just relax. She listened! She timed our courses perfectly allowing us to have a leisurely meal, not rushed or working to get new butts in our seats. She allowed us to breathe. The next time we go there. We will be requesting her. Thank You Jennifer!!!The food was good. One thing though. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip appetizer which I have always loved. Unfortunately, it was disappointing. They have changed the recipe. It is now more like a queso dip. The original is 100% better. I wish they would go back to the original. And just a side note. They need to sharpen their steak knives.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can honestly say that was the worst prime rib I have ever had in my entire life. The rest of my party loved their food. They all ordered fish. I guess the moral of my review is to order the fish and avoid the steak.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Disappointed! We hadn’t been to Stillwater in some years so we were anxious to be back to have a good meal. We ordered the soup special Salmon Chowder, steak tips with grilled salmon, ScallopsThe chowder when brought the table looked unappealing; grey in color making it not appetizing. The first taste was very fishy and too much tarragon. Unfortunately we sent it back.The steak tips and grilled salmon were disappointing. The salmon looked slightly grey. Not the typical pinkish color. Looked more like chicken breast. The steak tips were lathered in too must sauce. Normally the tips are seared and expected a good sauce. The sauce was more like a BBQ sauce. Too sweet. If it was supposed to be Cajun we couldn’t tell.All in all we were disappointed and not likely to return. Generally we are not this picky, but given the price point of the menu items, we would expect better quality
Very nice ,would
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Service was good but not overly impressed by the experience for the price. Good ambience. Party of 4. One mixed drink was so strong, it was nearly clear. The waitress promptly adressed it. Appetizers were quite good. Two at our table ordered the same filet dish,both cooked to mid-rare; one was accurate, the other nearly well done. Again the waitress was quick to address but it was disappointing. Portion size for the entree sides is oddly small for the price of the dishes.