Most expensive mediocre pizza I’ve ever had. Food was OK but definitely no where near worth the price. Next time I’d rather get a frozen pizza to cook myself. $50+ for a medium pizza and salad. Don’t give prices on the phone or on their menu online. Gave an attitude when I asked for a receipt.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lukas Mcconnell
Cold inside
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
Lisa Hillis
The pizza was very good, and the customer service was fine as well. The atmosphere is lacking, but we were getting take-out pizza anyway, so that was no problem. The only reason I'm giving the 3 stars is the price. Again, the pizza was very good. This isn't Little Caesar's; the ingredients are top notch. I saw some complaints about runny sauce and poor quality, but that was not my experience. The pizza was GOOD. But it cost me $106 for 3 pizzas with 2-3 toppings each. There is no menu available with prices, nor did we get an amount when we called in our order. We were definitely stunned when we got the amount, but we paid and went on our way. We did question it inside the business a bit, but we were never provided any detailed bill or explanation, and it was late, so we paid and left. Like I said though...the pizza was delicious, so all is well, but people should know about the prices...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
john zilio
Quite expensive...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
Christopher Saroli
Most expensive pizza I ever had in my life, didn't exactly get a welcome reception when I walked into the restaurant. Pushed the cash register at me when I asked the price. Not worth it. Go to Little Caesars.
Tim Adams
They were out of zucchini sticks but suggested the mushrooms which were amazingly!! A phenomenal appetizer, really glad we got it. The pizza was very good obviously made with quality cheese and ingredients. The boneless wings were very tasty, we appreciated the sauce being on the side.
If you are in the mood for real pizza, go to this genuine restaurant with real pizza ovens. The woman who took the order and gave it to me was very nice.
In response to earlier posters, the prices are what you should expect for good pizza and appetizers.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon Mullins
$79.95 for two medium pizzas and a pasta i haven’t been robbed before but i just did, no prices listed any where so I figured normal prices maybe a little higher, but I see why no prices are listed never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Angie Belleville
The pizza is worth the price. Gluten-free is better than most.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Pineau
I ordered a medium bacon peperoni with a side of ranch.. I was expecting it to be $25 maybe... it was $32... Come on it costs less than $10 to make a pizza in today's economy. Some places manage to make pizza for less than $5 per pizza.. way to expensive. Wasn't bad pizza tho
Food: 3
Jamie Hormel
Literally the most overpriced place in Caseville, asked for cheese on the breadsticks, nope!! No ranch and $45 for a small pizza and bread do not recommend
I hadn’t been to Caseville in about 8 years and I remembered loving this pizza. When I search to find the phone number and saw the low stars and bad reviews I was kinda bummed but I decided to order anyway! So glad I did. Yes the pizza was pricey but you do get what you pay for and this isn’t Little Caesar’s. Also saw reviews that pizza was watery. I got the special with everything and it was perfect! I did order ahead of time so there was basically no wait. On a Friday night also. There was a huge line for carry out which means they must be doing something right! My picky autistic daughter and I LOVED our food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
Megan Barney
This place was amazing. The food is expensive but you get what you pay for. Owner even gave us a whole background for how the restaurant came to be and why it’s priced that way. Ran only by mother and son and the pizza, pickle spears, and mushrooms were amazing. Definitely recommend getting if you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Bread Sticks
Henry Salowitz
1 star. Enough said.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jen Salowitz
While leaving Caseville after camping, we wanted to grab a pizza and breadsticks for dinner. Foolishly, I didn't read the reviews first. Also foolishly, I didn't read the menu/price list first. I placed a carry out order for a large pepperoni pizza and breadsticks. My order was $42 and was absolutely awful. When I questioned the price, I received a snarky attitude. The pizza was an undercooked, super greasy, sloppy mess. One third of the pizza wasn't cut while the other 2/3rds were super uneven, some large, some super tiny. The breadsticks were very clearly at least one day old, reheated. Please don't waste your money. We wanted to support local but I would never return here. I'm really hoping we don't get food poisoning; I regret the purchase immensely.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jb
EXPENSIVE!!!!Ordered a medium pizza three toppings and bread sticks (4 breadsticks) total price $42.66. Thought wow this must be a great pizza? NOT! Caseville has great food and good clean restaurants. Just not this one!No prices listed on line. Hummmm
Most expensive mediocre pizza I’ve ever had. Food was OK but definitely no where near worth the price. Next time I’d rather get a frozen pizza to cook myself. $50+ for a medium pizza and salad. Don’t give prices on the phone or on their menu online. Gave an attitude when I asked for a receipt.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cold inside
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
The pizza was very good, and the customer service was fine as well. The atmosphere is lacking, but we were getting take-out pizza anyway, so that was no problem. The only reason I'm giving the 3 stars is the price. Again, the pizza was very good. This isn't Little Caesar's; the ingredients are top notch. I saw some complaints about runny sauce and poor quality, but that was not my experience. The pizza was GOOD. But it cost me $106 for 3 pizzas with 2-3 toppings each. There is no menu available with prices, nor did we get an amount when we called in our order. We were definitely stunned when we got the amount, but we paid and went on our way. We did question it inside the business a bit, but we were never provided any detailed bill or explanation, and it was late, so we paid and left. Like I said though...the pizza was delicious, so all is well, but people should know about the prices...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
Quite expensive...
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
Most expensive pizza I ever had in my life, didn't exactly get a welcome reception when I walked into the restaurant. Pushed the cash register at me when I asked the price. Not worth it. Go to Little Caesars.
They were out of zucchini sticks but suggested the mushrooms which were amazingly!! A phenomenal appetizer, really glad we got it. The pizza was very good obviously made with quality cheese and ingredients. The boneless wings were very tasty, we appreciated the sauce being on the side.
If you are in the mood for real pizza, go to this genuine restaurant with real pizza ovens. The woman who took the order and gave it to me was very nice.
In response to earlier posters, the prices are what you should expect for good pizza and appetizers.
Food: 5
Service: 5
$79.95 for two medium pizzas and a pasta i haven’t been robbed before but i just did, no prices listed any where so I figured normal prices maybe a little higher, but I see why no prices are listed never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is worth the price. Gluten-free is better than most.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a medium bacon peperoni with a side of ranch.. I was expecting it to be $25 maybe... it was $32... Come on it costs less than $10 to make a pizza in today's economy. Some places manage to make pizza for less than $5 per pizza.. way to expensive.
Wasn't bad pizza tho
Food: 3
Literally the most overpriced place in Caseville, asked for cheese on the breadsticks, nope!! No ranch and $45 for a small pizza and bread do not recommend
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
I hadn’t been to Caseville in about 8 years and I remembered loving this pizza. When I search to find the phone number and saw the low stars and bad reviews I was kinda bummed but I decided to order anyway! So glad I did. Yes the pizza was pricey but you do get what you pay for and this isn’t Little Caesar’s. Also saw reviews that pizza was watery. I got the special with everything and it was perfect! I did order ahead of time so there was basically no wait. On a Friday night also. There was a huge line for carry out which means they must be doing something right! My picky autistic daughter and I LOVED our food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Giuseppe Pizza
This place was amazing. The food is expensive but you get what you pay for. Owner even gave us a whole background for how the restaurant came to be and why it’s priced that way. Ran only by mother and son and the pizza, pickle spears, and mushrooms were amazing. Definitely recommend getting if you are in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Bread Sticks
1 star. Enough said.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
While leaving Caseville after camping, we wanted to grab a pizza and breadsticks for dinner. Foolishly, I didn't read the reviews first. Also foolishly, I didn't read the menu/price list first. I placed a carry out order for a large pepperoni pizza and breadsticks. My order was $42 and was absolutely awful. When I questioned the price, I received a snarky attitude. The pizza was an undercooked, super greasy, sloppy mess. One third of the pizza wasn't cut while the other 2/3rds were super uneven, some large, some super tiny. The breadsticks were very clearly at least one day old, reheated. Please don't waste your money. We wanted to support local but I would never return here. I'm really hoping we don't get food poisoning; I regret the purchase immensely.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
EXPENSIVE!!!!Ordered a medium pizza three toppings and bread sticks (4 breadsticks) total price $42.66. Thought wow this must be a great pizza? NOT! Caseville has great food and good clean restaurants. Just not this one!No prices listed on line. Hummmm
Loading...