4 Best Pizza Restaurants near Caseville

“OMG amazing hand tossed pizza, made just the way I love! Hot fresh and on time! Had pepperoni and sausage and a quarter of it had green olives ♥️“

“new owners..loved the old owners, but the new owners came through with ultimate service! thank you 🙏“

“My first pizza from Main St.! I ordered a Margharita pizza because I want to taste the crust, sauce, and cheese on my first try. Crust was good, very little sauce so no comment on that, lots of very good mozzarella cheese. It was more like a cheesebread. Hardly any fresh tomatoes and vitually no fresh basil. But I'll give him a break since it's winter in Caseville and no fresh produce to speak of! I'll try again with a different type of pizza. Also want to try the ribs! I support local eateries!!“

“Came here for dinner last night and it was such a great experience. We ordered the three cheese artichoke dip, shrimp scampi pasta, and BBQ Brisket sandwich. My husband got a beer… one of the IPAs, I’m unsure of the name! It was all delicious! Highly recommend the dip with the fresh baguette! 👌👍 If you’re going for dinner, I suggest getting there early as it got very packed even a little before 6pm on a Friday night! There was live music playing and the musician was good to boot! Huge shout to Lauren for her accommodations (we had a baby and stroller in a small and busy space) as she quickly shifted tables and other things around for us to be comfortable. She even had the musician give us an anniversary shout on the mic. It made us feel very special. It looks like there is a lot of outdoor seating and I’m sure it would be a different but equally wonderful experience in the warmer months also. If we’re ever in the thumb again (love their brewery name, too haha) we will have to make this a stop! Thank you, Thumb Brewery staff, for everything!“