My only complaint is that you have to do some digging to order their square (Detroit style deep dish). All of their options have been good, but I find their Detroit style to be fantastic.
We ordered on 3/30/24 for $63.61. Tiffany's Pizza charged our credit card 7 times for $63.61. Called them to tell them what happened they said it will be off by the end of the day. Guess what it's still there. Not happy at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
OurStore11 Business Account
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizzas are definitely gluten free. Almost veganKid-friendliness: Kids are always welcome
Literally the worst experience. I picked up a pizza 2 weeks ago, came back to work to discover it was raw. Called them and told them. They asked me to bring the pizza back. I told them I was working until later than night and was unable to leave again. By time I left work that night they were closed. They said it was no problem and they’d email me a gift card. They sent me a $5 gift card which does not cover the cost of the pizza I bought. The pizza was not edible that I went back to work with that day. I called them and told them I don’t think it’s fair that they only gave me $5 rather than a remade pizza. I’ve worked in a pizza place before, and it doesn’t cost that much money to make another one. That’s all they had to do. If It was my business personally, I would’ve refunded the whole pizza and gave them a coupon for another in the future. The lady that answered the phone was extremely rude. You could just hear it in her voice she was frustrated. After a few complaints, they finally decided to send me an email with the code for a free two topping and a small, tasty bread which I was happy about. I called them and placed the order and they told me that it would be ready in about 25 minutes so I went to go pick it up and I got there and they told me that the coupon was not valid. I don’t recommend this place. They’re absolutely terrible. Their customer service sucks and they don’t care about their customers like they should. They think everything is a just and they must be hurting for money since it’s too big of a deal to remake a pizza.
Haven't been in years but made a very large order on Christmas Eve '23 and it was delicious! They did a great job and I'll have to come back more often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza with One Topping
B S
Always friendly and food is always great, no issues whatsoever. Couldn't be a better experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Bread, Specialty Pizzas, Deluxe Pizza, Italian Grinder, Cheese Pizza with One Topping
Erin Lopez
We came in an hr before close and they were extremely nice :) food was great and the family and I had a great time. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terry Shelley
"Summer" of pizza... same style pizza at every place rated. I was excited for Tiffany's solely based on Xmas decorations of the Monroe store last year! But their pizza is generic. Little flavor in the crust.. it was just doughy. It was the CHEAPEST pizza this summer but I would have liked DOUBLE the cheese that it had. Had i known they had light cheese, I would have paid for extra cheese to make it in line, price wise, as other places. Even reheated, just blah.Parking: There is no parking lot, only "downtown" parking. Not being too familiar with the town, i hoped there would be a "pickup " spot out front....NOPE. I had to go around the block (not square btw), only to find an alley to jump in and get my pizza with hopes I didn't get a ticket!!
Ordered delivery. No estimate time was given. When I called, I was told that no estimate could be given because of short staffing. One hr later I received a text saying my order was canceled. Than I received a text that my food was delivered 25 min ago. I opened my front door and there was my food. It had been sitting on the front porch for over 25 min in 30 degree weather. Delivery driver did not knock, ring bell, nothing. My pizza was cold and so was the grinder. In my opinion, Costco pizza is better and the grinder is a warmed sub. When I called to complain, I was told they are short staffed and have contactless delivery. I guess they can’t ring a doorbell either. I find this food sub par and over priced. I think the staff is rude. I will go to hungry howies from now on.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Sandra D.
food is subpar and over priced. Delivery driver never rang doorbell or called. Just left my food outside my door. I wAs never alerted to its arrival. Not only is the food bad it's worse when cold. Staff was rude to my concerns. Go somewhere else!!!!
Bob Forgacs
I've eaten pizza here twice now and everyone always loves the pizza. Fast friendly service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Shane
This place was pretty cool. Good price and pizza was good
Nate The Great
Nice 50's theme. Pizza was amazing. Kevin was a cool dude.
My only complaint is that you have to do some digging to order their square (Detroit style deep dish). All of their options have been good, but I find their Detroit style to be fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tasty Bread, Specialty Pizzas, Pepperoni Pizza
We ordered on 3/30/24 for $63.61. Tiffany's Pizza charged our credit card 7 times for $63.61. Called them to tell them what happened they said it will be off by the end of the day. Guess what it's still there. Not happy at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizzas are definitely gluten free. Almost veganKid-friendliness: Kids are always welcome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tasty Bread, Dessert Pizza, Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Deluxe Pizza, blt Pizza, Salad
Literally the worst experience. I picked up a pizza 2 weeks ago, came back to work to discover it was raw. Called them and told them. They asked me to bring the pizza back. I told them I was working until later than night and was unable to leave again. By time I left work that night they were closed. They said it was no problem and they’d email me a gift card. They sent me a $5 gift card which does not cover the cost of the pizza I bought. The pizza was not edible that I went back to work with that day. I called them and told them I don’t think it’s fair that they only gave me $5 rather than a remade pizza. I’ve worked in a pizza place before, and it doesn’t cost that much money to make another one. That’s all they had to do. If It was my business personally, I would’ve refunded the whole pizza and gave them a coupon for another in the future. The lady that answered the phone was extremely rude. You could just hear it in her voice she was frustrated. After a few complaints, they finally decided to send me an email with the code for a free two topping and a small, tasty bread which I was happy about. I called them and placed the order and they told me that it would be ready in about 25 minutes so I went to go pick it up and I got there and they told me that the coupon was not valid. I don’t recommend this place. They’re absolutely terrible. Their customer service sucks and they don’t care about their customers like they should. They think everything is a just and they must be hurting for money since it’s too big of a deal to remake a pizza.
Easy in, easy out. Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet
Our favorite local pizza joint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Bread, Specialty Pizzas
Haven't been in years but made a very large order on Christmas Eve '23 and it was delicious! They did a great job and I'll have to come back more often!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza with One Topping
Always friendly and food is always great, no issues whatsoever. Couldn't be a better experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Bread, Specialty Pizzas, Deluxe Pizza, Italian Grinder, Cheese Pizza with One Topping
We came in an hr before close and they were extremely nice :) food was great and the family and I had a great time. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
"Summer" of pizza... same style pizza at every place rated. I was excited for Tiffany's solely based on Xmas decorations of the Monroe store last year! But their pizza is generic. Little flavor in the crust.. it was just doughy. It was the CHEAPEST pizza this summer but I would have liked DOUBLE the cheese that it had. Had i known they had light cheese, I would have paid for extra cheese to make it in line, price wise, as other places. Even reheated, just blah.Parking: There is no parking lot, only "downtown" parking. Not being too familiar with the town, i hoped there would be a "pickup " spot out front....NOPE. I had to go around the block (not square btw), only to find an alley to jump in and get my pizza with hopes I didn't get a ticket!!
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered delivery. No estimate time was given. When I called, I was told that no estimate could be given because of short staffing. One hr later I received a text saying my order was canceled. Than I received a text that my food was delivered 25 min ago. I opened my front door and there was my food. It had been sitting on the front porch for over 25 min in 30 degree weather. Delivery driver did not knock, ring bell, nothing. My pizza was cold and so was the grinder. In my opinion, Costco pizza is better and the grinder is a warmed sub. When I called to complain, I was told they are short staffed and have contactless delivery. I guess they can’t ring a doorbell either. I find this food sub par and over priced. I think the staff is rude. I will go to hungry howies from now on.
Food: 2
Service: 1
food is subpar and over priced. Delivery driver never rang doorbell or called. Just left my food outside my door. I wAs never alerted to its arrival. Not only is the food bad it's worse when cold. Staff was rude to my concerns. Go somewhere else!!!!
I've eaten pizza here twice now and everyone always loves the pizza. Fast friendly service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place was pretty cool. Good price and pizza was good
Nice 50's theme. Pizza was amazing. Kevin was a cool dude.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5