This place is great! The food is delicious and customer service is extraordinary! 10/10
Richelle Durian
Awesome experience! Pizza was amazing! Owner was suuper informative walked in 20 minutes to close & he was happy to have us (which is not a common theme with most restaurants)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig Kulikowski
Crust is top level. If you don't like Gorgonzola don't get that pizza. But the crust is the best, sauce is good, I would recommend
Sarah Wertz
Pizza is excellent. 12” and 16” crust are prepared differently so pay attention to that. Pepperoni is the little cupped type. You order at the counter and the pizza is brought to the table if dining in. Friendly staff. Very safe neighborhood. Parking available in back, front and side of building.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Leroy Wertz
9/28/25 little skimpy with the toppings but, overall a good pizza 7.5 out of 10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Theresa Zywicki
OK. I was really excited about this place pizza place in Fennville as we are moving here in April year round. We are from Kalamazoo and this pizza is comparable in price to Martini’s (which is absolutely phenomenal). Let me break this down. The crust was very good. But, unfortunately it was burnt and just touching the pizza made my hands black. It was not good. The sauce was not generous enough and Was lacking flavor. The cheese was a bit greasy. We ordered mushroom pepperoni and onion. The mushrooms and onion were thin and not detectable. The pepperoni was good, but overcooked. Overall, we were all disappointed.
Peter Colvin
$17 grilled cheese. Had to throw it in the trash. Burnt and chewable. C’mon Iggy’s. Geez.
Food: 1
Mark Edly
The pizza here is great, and the inside has a lot of great character. They’re a great edition to making downtown Fennville a fun stop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heidi Kapovich
Excellent pizza, love the crust and the cheese and sauce is not overwhelming. Such great texture and flavor. Definitely order early because they are popular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Holman
The food was a delicious surprise find while on vacation. So yummy!!! All of it! The Caesar salad was absolutely fantastic! Pizza too.. I wish I lived closer so I could enjoy more.
Holy wow! You know it’s going to be GOOD when the owner is on the floor taking orders ;) the cream cheese dip sent my heart into a twister. Must order! The cheesy garlic bread was beyond - so unique and the crust is flavorful. The pizza - 12/10. I’m a Chicago girl and they did it right. I’m talkin’ DELISH. What a fun spot full of charm. The branding is a cute touch. Can’t go wrong!!!!! Can’t wait to go back!!!!!!!
Patrick Nehls
We’re happy to have this place by us after we lost Pizza Quest. The pizzas are really good, reasonably priced, and creative. The Iggy Pep and the Pesto pizza were outstanding, the Journeyman (potato) one wasn’t for us, but all the ingredients on everything were quality and the pizzas were really well cooked.
The chopped salad was a hit too, with interesting things like pepperoncini in it. Iggys is a welcome addition to the area, an area that desperately needed another great pizza place like Pizza Quest.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Jansen
My husband and I agree — this is really good pizza. Like, it could stand its ground against some top pizza places we go to in Chicago (and no, it’s not deep dish).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Garlic Bread, Thai Caesar Whole
Erin Hurley
Perfection in pie form! Fresh made & quality ingredients, combined with a fun atmosphere means this is totally worth a day trip. They fresh grate the cheese, make their own sauce from fresh veggies and use in-house sausage recipe from the Journeyman days (iykyk). We tried a fan favorite with brussel sprouts - and that's a yes from me! The crust though 🤌🏼 chefs kiss 🤌🏼. They do carry-out, which I saw a lot of people use online ordering from the music in the park and taking it down to enjoy the perfect summers eve in small-town Michigan ✋🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Grande 12
Lexi Baumgartner
Cute little pizza joint! Pizza was good and was a good price for what we got!
This place is great! The food is delicious and customer service is extraordinary! 10/10
Awesome experience! Pizza was amazing! Owner was suuper informative walked in 20 minutes to close & he was happy to have us (which is not a common theme with most restaurants)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crust is top level. If you don't like Gorgonzola don't get that pizza. But the crust is the best, sauce is good, I would recommend
Pizza is excellent. 12” and 16” crust are prepared differently so pay attention to that. Pepperoni is the little cupped type. You order at the counter and the pizza is brought to the table if dining in. Friendly staff. Very safe neighborhood. Parking available in back, front and side of building.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
9/28/25 little skimpy with the toppings but, overall a good pizza
7.5 out of 10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
OK. I was really excited about this place pizza place in Fennville as we are moving here in April year round. We are from Kalamazoo and this pizza is comparable in price to Martini’s (which is absolutely phenomenal). Let me break this down.
The crust was very good. But, unfortunately it was burnt and just touching the pizza made my hands black. It was not good.
The sauce was not generous enough and Was lacking flavor.
The cheese was a bit greasy.
We ordered mushroom pepperoni and onion. The mushrooms and onion were thin and not detectable. The pepperoni was good, but overcooked.
Overall, we were all disappointed.
$17 grilled cheese. Had to throw it in the trash. Burnt and chewable. C’mon Iggy’s. Geez.
Food: 1
The pizza here is great, and the inside has a lot of great character. They’re a great edition to making downtown Fennville a fun stop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza, love the crust and the cheese and sauce is not overwhelming. Such great texture and flavor. Definitely order early because they are popular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was a delicious surprise find while on vacation. So yummy!!! All of it! The Caesar salad was absolutely fantastic! Pizza too.. I wish I lived closer so I could enjoy more.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Holy wow! You know it’s going to be GOOD when the owner is on the floor taking orders ;) the cream cheese dip sent my heart into a twister. Must order! The cheesy garlic bread was beyond - so unique and the crust is flavorful. The pizza - 12/10. I’m a Chicago girl and they did it right. I’m talkin’ DELISH. What a fun spot full of charm. The branding is a cute touch. Can’t go wrong!!!!! Can’t wait to go back!!!!!!!
We’re happy to have this place by us after we lost Pizza Quest. The pizzas are really good, reasonably priced, and creative. The Iggy Pep and the Pesto pizza were outstanding, the Journeyman (potato) one wasn’t for us, but all the ingredients on everything were quality and the pizzas were really well cooked.
The chopped salad was a hit too, with interesting things like pepperoncini in it. Iggys is a welcome addition to the area, an area that desperately needed another great pizza place like Pizza Quest.
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I agree — this is really good pizza. Like, it could stand its ground against some top pizza places we go to in Chicago (and no, it’s not deep dish).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Garlic Bread, Thai Caesar Whole
Perfection in pie form! Fresh made & quality ingredients, combined with a fun atmosphere means this is totally worth a day trip. They fresh grate the cheese, make their own sauce from fresh veggies and use in-house sausage recipe from the Journeyman days (iykyk). We tried a fan favorite with brussel sprouts - and that's a yes from me! The crust though 🤌🏼 chefs kiss 🤌🏼. They do carry-out, which I saw a lot of people use online ordering from the music in the park and taking it down to enjoy the perfect summers eve in small-town Michigan ✋🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Grande 12
Cute little pizza joint! Pizza was good and was a good price for what we got!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...