The pizza is fantastic, never had a bad pie. The "wings" are mini bite sized wings. They are pretty good but very small and I got shorted on what I ordered. Stick to the pizza 🤙
Thomas Mcauley
Raise your prices. Good luck
Omar Alhertaky
Called and ordered a large halal pepperoni after I was told by the lady that answered the phone that they offered it. When I got my pizza the pepperoni was not halal and eating pork is against my religion. Never eating from there again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Perfectlyunperfect Blah blah blah
they put bacon bits instead of real bacon the bread isn’t toasted it’s cold this is my first time ordering from here🤦🏻♀️
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jennifer Scram
With it being Halloween yesterday everyone should of known how busy they would be, but not one worker stopped working everyone was helping each other out. I hope you don't get a bunch of negative reviews because people want to be Karen's and not cook when they don't even go out trick or treating. Keep up the good work guys everyone loves you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Subs, Italian Sub, Pizza
Frances Thompson
I ordered waited the 45 minutes to pick it up, then when I got there waited another 30. Went back to counter and they told me 10 minutes waited those 10 minutes then was told another 10 minutes. There were 10 people also waiting. During the 50 minutes I waited in the building only one of those 10 people got their pizza. Tickets everywhere zero organization.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Malika Chapman
Very nice people ...The owner so sweet ......They have the Best cheese bread and Subs I've ever tasted ??...the only thing the wings be so tiny for a big price lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greg Rexin
Mr. Pizza has quickly become my go to for pizza night. As a household of ten, everyone loves and agrees (which is rear) to Mr Pizza on Cherry Hill. Food is always amazing, while the service is always top notch!
Got a LG pizza and ordered half pint of chicken wings...I noticed after they never asked if inwanted any flavor on my crust but whatever. Shoulda checked the chicken wings cus they gave me like 7 n half boneless chicken bites for 8.99 lol n they tasted like they were 3 days old fresh out the microwave . Spent 26.50 there . Pizza was bland and mediocre.
I love the food here, and everyone is always so kind. I eat here at least three times a month. Good quality food and ingredients are rare nowadays.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Amanda Hall
Pizza was delicious & the cheese bread was also great! The price was actually not bad either. It was our first time ordering from here & we'll definitely be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesebread, Pizza
Amanda Smith
Got a LG pizza and ordered half pint of chicken wings...I noticed after they never asked if inwanted any flavor on my crust but whatever. Shoulda checked the chicken wings cus they gave me like 7 n half boneless chicken bites for 8.99 lol n they tasted like they were 3 days old fresh out the microwave . Spent 26.50 there . Pizza was bland and mediocre.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Moonlit Mystic
As the Moonlit Mystic, I journey through realms both seen and unseen, seeking out the extraordinary in the ordinary. And lo, I found magic in the most unexpected of places: Mr. Pizza in Garden City.
While the pizza was undoubtedly delicious, with a crust that was a symphony of crispy and chewy, it was the energy of the place that truly enchanted. The heart of this pizzeria is a man named Chris, whose spirit is as warm and inviting as a freshly baked pie. His laughter, a melody that dances on the air, fills the space with a joy that is contagious.
Under Chris's spell, Mr. Pizza becomes more than just a place to grab a bite. It's a gathering spot where the mundane transforms into the magical. His ability to connect with customers is nothing short of sorcery, creating an atmosphere where everyone feels welcomed and appreciated.
So, if you seek a culinary adventure infused with enchantment, venture to Mr. Pizza in Garden City. But be warned: you may just find yourself falling under the spell of its magical manager, Chris.
Namaste and Bon Appetite, The Moonlit Mystic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Run Had
Update from 4 to 5 stars 8/4/24 best pizza and cheesebread was amazing too ? We did large and I enjoy my half with pineapple, sausage and Jalapeño while my better half enjoys his with mushroom, pepperoni and green peppers. Truly the best pizza around ?
Their bbq wings are amazing and their pizza is tasty too!! They're just not surprisingly always busy ?
Good pizza
The pizza is fantastic, never had a bad pie. The "wings" are mini bite sized wings. They are pretty good but very small and I got shorted on what I ordered. Stick to the pizza 🤙
Raise your prices. Good luck
Called and ordered a large halal pepperoni after I was told by the lady that answered the phone that they offered it. When I got my pizza the pepperoni was not halal and eating pork is against my religion. Never eating from there again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
they put bacon bits instead of real bacon the bread isn’t toasted it’s cold this is my first time ordering from here🤦🏻♀️
Food: 1
Service: 1
With it being Halloween yesterday everyone should of known how busy they would be, but not one worker stopped working everyone was helping each other out. I hope you don't get a bunch of negative reviews because people want to be Karen's and not cook when they don't even go out trick or treating. Keep up the good work guys everyone loves you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Subs, Italian Sub, Pizza
I ordered waited the 45 minutes to pick it up, then when I got there waited another 30. Went back to counter and they told me 10 minutes waited those 10 minutes then was told another 10 minutes. There were 10 people also waiting. During the 50 minutes I waited in the building only one of those 10 people got their pizza. Tickets everywhere zero organization.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Very nice people ...The owner so sweet ......They have the Best cheese bread and Subs I've ever tasted ??...the only thing the wings be so tiny for a big price lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr. Pizza has quickly become my go to for pizza night. As a household of ten, everyone loves and agrees (which is rear) to Mr Pizza on Cherry Hill. Food is always amazing, while the service is always top notch!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesebread, Subs, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza
Got a LG pizza and ordered half pint of chicken wings...I noticed after they never asked if inwanted any flavor on my crust but whatever. Shoulda checked the chicken wings cus they gave me like 7 n half boneless chicken bites for 8.99 lol n they tasted like they were 3 days old fresh out the microwave . Spent 26.50 there . Pizza was bland and mediocre.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
I love the food here, and everyone is always so kind. I eat here at least three times a month. Good quality food and ingredients are rare nowadays.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Pizza was delicious & the cheese bread was also great! The price was actually not bad either. It was our first time ordering from here & we'll definitely be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesebread, Pizza
Got a LG pizza and ordered half pint of chicken wings...I noticed after they never asked if inwanted any flavor on my crust but whatever. Shoulda checked the chicken wings cus they gave me like 7 n half boneless chicken bites for 8.99 lol n they tasted like they were 3 days old fresh out the microwave . Spent 26.50 there . Pizza was bland and mediocre.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
As the Moonlit Mystic, I journey through realms both seen and unseen, seeking out the extraordinary in the ordinary. And lo, I found magic in the most unexpected of places: Mr. Pizza in Garden City.
While the pizza was undoubtedly delicious, with a crust that was a symphony of crispy and chewy, it was the energy of the place that truly enchanted. The heart of this pizzeria is a man named Chris, whose spirit is as warm and inviting as a freshly baked pie. His laughter, a melody that dances on the air, fills the space with a joy that is contagious.
Under Chris's spell, Mr. Pizza becomes more than just a place to grab a bite. It's a gathering spot where the mundane transforms into the magical. His ability to connect with customers is nothing short of sorcery, creating an atmosphere where everyone feels welcomed and appreciated.
So, if you seek a culinary adventure infused with enchantment, venture to Mr. Pizza in Garden City. But be warned: you may just find yourself falling under the spell of its magical manager, Chris.
Namaste and Bon Appetite,
The Moonlit Mystic
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Update from 4 to 5 stars 8/4/24 best pizza and cheesebread was amazing too ?
We did large and I enjoy my half with pineapple, sausage and Jalapeño while my better half enjoys his with mushroom, pepperoni and green peppers. Truly the best pizza around ?
Their bbq wings are amazing and their pizza is tasty too!! They're just not surprisingly always busy ?
Food: 5
Loading...