Amy J's Pasty
1000 N Lincoln Dr, Hancock
(906) 482-2253
Customers' Favorites
Veggie Pasty
Steak Pasty
Beef Pasty
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I can’t say enough good things about Amy J’s. Hands down the best most authentic and delicious pasty you can have in the UP. I’m sorry because there are a lot of good ones but NOTHING beats Amy J’s. 5/5 you have to try! Obviously eat it the correct way with ketchup. And I like to add some butter. If you’re from out of town you have to stop in. I order extras when I leave town too to share with friends out of state. THE BEST PASTY in the UP.
Pasty was served warm and delicious. We got drinks and ate at the cafe table inside. Other patrons were getting take out. There were cookies and cinnamon rolls available too. Staff was very friendly. We were happy to find this place on the way back from Quincy Mine.
My husband and I have been wanting to try a pasty since we made it into the U.P. two weeks ago, but have been holding out because of mixed reviews. We made it to this side of the peninsula and saw Amy J's and all the great reviews, so we decided to pop in! Great prices and absolutely delicious pasties! Wish they weren't sold out of the veggie one so we could try one of each, but maybe we can try and get one before we have to leave ? The woman, I'm assuming owner,...
You May Also Like
Griffin Family Cafe & Catering - 200 Michigan St #313
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, American
Gino’s Restaurant & Cocktail Lounge - 800 Quincy St
![]()
Italian, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian
The Forge Food Smith - 787 Market Street UNIT 3
![]()
Barbeque, Food Trucks