Some of the best pizza I've had from around the entire US. And I've had pizza from over 35 states. A local shop that treats their customers right, makes great pizzas at a very reasonable price and their pizzas are very big. They make other food as well though I can only speak to their pizza. Not a place to sit down and eat though. Order your food, pick it up and go enjoy it!
Sarah Cat
Great pizza, bread sticks, and service.
Seileen O'Marcaigh
Never had a bad experience here. The pizza, bread sticks and sauce are fantastic. Best pizza around and it heats up good the next day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza, Antipasto Salad
Judah Weber
Haven't had the Chicago style in forever!! Did not disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Triple Cheese Pizza
Domenic Ferrara
Came in to get a quick drink and was looking about getting a bite the owner of the manager wearing a red t shirt was super rude and being disrespectful as soon as I came in and as I was leaving.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Dennis F
If your not ordering your pizza from Carlos Pizza, you are missing out. Best pizza around, hands down ! All the staff are awesome. Try everything they offer for the best experience. Thank you to the crew at Carlos.
Parking: Plenty of parking, easy in, easy out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza, Chicken Dinner, Boneless Chicken Bites, Chicago Style Super Special Pizza, Chicken Club Sub, Everything Bread, Antipasto Salad
Constantine Silva
I’m giving Carlos 5 stars, despite the recent issues I’ve encountered, because I’ve been coming here regularly for years and I know they can do better. I’m not looking for a freebie and I’m not here to punish them with a bad review. I just want to offer positive feedback. Whoever was making your pizzas Sunday afternoon put maybe 5 slices of pepperoni on my large pizza. (I know this because I give my dog all the pepperoni and he was sad and disappointed.) Overall it tasted great, but typically you guys don’t skimp on toppings. We thought the bone-in wings had gone down in quality since we last ordered them. We couldn’t even finish them. We will not order again. And we ordered a sub. We were given a pizza sub. We did not order a pizza sub. We’re going to take a break from Carlos and hopefully return in 30 days to the service and quality we’re used to. We prefer to support local businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Danny D
I'm giving an update to a review I did years ago. Upgraded from 3 to 5 stars. I've been coming here for 12 years. When I feel like a high quality but expensive pizza I come here. $19 for a pizza is pretty steep, but I understand this business's costs too. Labor & materials have gone up since 2019 and so has the price. The square pizzas have a nice outer crunch to them, and they don't cheap out on the cheese. They've always had the pizza ready when they said it would. I like the online ordering even though I don't use it. I look at it to make sure my printed menus are up to date and to verify the products are available. They have lunchtime specials which take a bit out of the expense.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carrie Mayo
Customer service was great and very friendly. We ordered 40 pizzas and had them delivered. Everything was right and tasted great! Highly recommend
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Nowosielski
Pizza, bread, salads, dessert....All delicious! Prices are terrific. Food is prepared quickly. Also, the first time we ordered a Medium pizza and they accidentally made a Large. They gave us the large upgrade for no additional charge. Great customer service. Highly recommend!
Ordered 3 pizzas and each one was better than the last!! Can't wait to order again, great, old school pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza
David Wakeford
Carlos on southriver really bangs out some good food quick and cheap. Not sure on delivery as I pick it up, but if something is wrong or delayed they usually make it up to you by giving you a free pizza and salad/dessert. The management really knows how to appeal to customers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon
Horrible experience I've been coming here for over 20 years and this will be my last time I explained my order to the person over the phone three times and he confirmed but not after I was given an attitude the entire time I had a similar experience with the same gentleman before so I knew something was up after I placed the order
An hour and a half goes by and my order is not delivered yet I called back to check the status more attitude from the same guy delivery driver finally shows up with the wrong order very nice guy says I will have them comp you I said hold on I still need my order he says he will tell them to get the order out for me The only problem with that is it's going to take another hour and a half to get the order so I offer to go up there and pick up my order Manager doesn't seem to really care much about anything I get there place the order and now it's another hour later on top of a horrible day that I was already having this made things worse
I had people at my house I was entertaining I had to leave and deal with this debacle I was still charged for the pizza they gave me a discount but no one seemed sincere about anything going on besides the two delivery drivers The one delivery driver is basically the only reason that I keep going to this place because he is so pleasant not the young one this one is probably mid-age or younger My apologies if he is younger
Anyways after this experience it's a shame to have to find another place but I feel if though the person taking my order and making my pizza doesn't really care in that says a lot about the other people around as well this will be my last order and once again I do want to reiterate that the delivery driver that delivers my stuff all the time is a very awesome person.
I know that will probably be a response to this saying call us and talk to us but that is The typical response You should be preventative train your employees and customer relations especially in a time like now we're businesses are going under.
Kim Riccobono
Ordered from here yesterday. It was a fairly large order. Among the order I requested an XL BLT pizza. I was having a party. I opened the box and found a bacon pizza. No lettuce, no tomato, no mayo. I was soooo looking forward to that BLT. Disappointed. Also, the 4 cheese bread sticks were over cooked and dry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Super Special Pizza
Some of the best pizza I've had from around the entire US. And I've had pizza from over 35 states. A local shop that treats their customers right, makes great pizzas at a very reasonable price and their pizzas are very big. They make other food as well though I can only speak to their pizza.
Not a place to sit down and eat though. Order your food, pick it up and go enjoy it!
Great pizza, bread sticks, and service.
Never had a bad experience here. The pizza, bread sticks and sauce are fantastic. Best pizza around and it heats up good the next day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza, Antipasto Salad
Haven't had the Chicago style in forever!! Did not disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Triple Cheese Pizza
Came in to get a quick drink and was looking about getting a bite the owner of the manager wearing a red t shirt was super rude and being disrespectful as soon as I came in and as I was leaving.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
If your not ordering your pizza from Carlos Pizza, you are missing out. Best pizza around, hands down ! All the staff are awesome. Try everything they offer for the best experience. Thank you to the crew at Carlos.
Parking: Plenty of parking, easy in, easy out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza, Chicken Dinner, Boneless Chicken Bites, Chicago Style Super Special Pizza, Chicken Club Sub, Everything Bread, Antipasto Salad
I’m giving Carlos 5 stars, despite the recent issues I’ve encountered, because I’ve been coming here regularly for years and I know they can do better. I’m not looking for a freebie and I’m not here to punish them with a bad review. I just want to offer positive feedback. Whoever was making your pizzas Sunday afternoon put maybe 5 slices of pepperoni on my large pizza. (I know this because I give my dog all the pepperoni and he was sad and disappointed.) Overall it tasted great, but typically you guys don’t skimp on toppings. We thought the bone-in wings had gone down in quality since we last ordered them. We couldn’t even finish them. We will not order again. And we ordered a sub. We were given a pizza sub. We did not order a pizza sub. We’re going to take a break from Carlos and hopefully return in 30 days to the service and quality we’re used to. We prefer to support local businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I'm giving an update to a review I did years ago. Upgraded from 3 to 5 stars. I've been coming here for 12 years. When I feel like a high quality but expensive pizza I come here. $19 for a pizza is pretty steep, but I understand this business's costs too. Labor & materials have gone up since 2019 and so has the price. The square pizzas have a nice outer crunch to them, and they don't cheap out on the cheese. They've always had the pizza ready when they said it would. I like the online ordering even though I don't use it. I look at it to make sure my printed menus are up to date and to verify the products are available. They have lunchtime specials which take a bit out of the expense.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Customer service was great and very friendly. We ordered 40 pizzas and had them delivered. Everything was right and tasted great! Highly recommend
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza, bread, salads, dessert....All delicious! Prices are terrific. Food is prepared quickly. Also, the first time we ordered a Medium pizza and they accidentally made a Large. They gave us the large upgrade for no additional charge. Great customer service. Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Not a big fan !!
Ordered 3 pizzas and each one was better than the last!! Can't wait to order again, great, old school pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Round Pizza
Carlos on southriver really bangs out some good food quick and cheap. Not sure on delivery as I pick it up, but if something is wrong or delayed they usually make it up to you by giving you a free pizza and salad/dessert. The management really knows how to appeal to customers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible experience I've been coming here for over 20 years and this will be my last time I explained my order to the person over the phone three times and he confirmed but not after I was given an attitude the entire time I had a similar experience with the same gentleman before so I knew something was up after I placed the order
An hour and a half goes by and my order is not delivered yet I called back to check the status more attitude from the same guy delivery driver finally shows up with the wrong order very nice guy says I will have them comp you I said hold on I still need my order he says he will tell them to get the order out for me The only problem with that is it's going to take another hour and a half to get the order so I offer to go up there and pick up my order Manager doesn't seem to really care much about anything I get there place the order and now it's another hour later on top of a horrible day that I was already having this made things worse
I had people at my house I was entertaining I had to leave and deal with this debacle I was still charged for the pizza they gave me a discount but no one seemed sincere about anything going on besides the two delivery drivers The one delivery driver is basically the only reason that I keep going to this place because he is so pleasant not the young one this one is probably mid-age or younger My apologies if he is younger
Anyways after this experience it's a shame to have to find another place but I feel if though the person taking my order and making my pizza doesn't really care in that says a lot about the other people around as well this will be my last order and once again I do want to reiterate that the delivery driver that delivers my stuff all the time is a very awesome person.
I know that will probably be a response to this saying call us and talk to us but that is The typical response You should be preventative train your employees and customer relations especially in a time like now we're businesses are going under.
Ordered from here yesterday. It was a fairly large order. Among the order I requested an XL BLT pizza. I was having a party. I opened the box and found a bacon pizza. No lettuce, no tomato, no mayo. I was soooo looking forward to that BLT. Disappointed. Also, the 4 cheese bread sticks were over cooked and dry.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicago Style Super Special Pizza
Loading...