Love the burrata and wine options. Main reason I come back.I’ve ordered the steak every time. I would recommend ordering a different dish. Just is what it is. I come for the burrata, wine and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Daniel Okerlund
A breath of fresh air for our community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Superior Whitefish, Bison Short Rib
PatrickK
My husband and I both ordered the chicken marsala, and it was very good as were the duck wings. The service was prompt and polite, It was a Thursday so there was a live musician which was a treat. It is a bit noisy because the ceilings are so high, but we liked the more urban atmosphere with the lights and brick wall. The menu is not extensive, but we will try it again sometime.
It was fine, food was fine, nothing outstanding. Waitstaff was a bit over attentive- the woman filled my glass every time I took a sip. We also had a bit of a challenge for a vegetarian guest as many items had cheese already in them, grits, pesto, even having messaged them a week before our reservation. Lights could've been a little lower for a wine bar, they have about 10 giant globe lights that were at full blast. They did offer nice N/A drink options.
Billy McCoy
Perfect place for our anniversary dinner! Food was unbelievable and customer service excellent! Good menu specials and a good variety of entrees and appetizers to choose from. Excellent wine and beer list! I have not found better Lake Superior whitefish served south of M28 as of yet!Parking: Plenty of safe and secure parking in back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Fish Chowder, Lake Superior Whitefish, Pesto Pasta w Shrimp
Holly Charlevoix
My boyfriend and I went here for the first time on Valentine’s Day for dinner. The food was pretty good, but the server was rather pushy to order, always popping up at the most inopportune times while we tried to enjoy conversation and cocktails prior to ordering. Found out the next day that we had been charged twice for our dinner. We called to inquire and the manager told us she would check into it and she got our info and said she would get back to us. We waited three more days with no call back so we called again. She told us that it was a problem with the company who handles their credit card payments and that 6-7 others patrons had also been overcharged. She became very irritated and said “I don’t have time to explain this to you right now; I am really busy,” and that they had been open a year and this never happened before. Lastly, she had no idea when we would be refunded and did not offer any kind of compensation or idea of what to do next. Very rude, too busy to tell us anything and very poor customer service. We will not be back for the price as the hassle far outweighs the dinner we had here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Kay Shoemaker
Excellent food- nothing in the area compares. Great cocktails, beer, and wine. Service also top notch. Brittany at the bar will make it a perfect experience. I live 300 miles away, but I’ll return for that Bourbon cream root beer float!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Brussels Sprouts, Lake Superior Whitefish, Chocolate Cremeux
Grace
Valentine's Day dinner at Oddfellows was special. Their housemade pasta never disappoints, cooked perfectly al dente. The fig and goat cheese puffed pastry is the perfect combination of sweet and savory. Music by One Human Band was the right volume - we appreciate his music. We enjoyed a featured cocktail and wine. Finally, with the red velvet molten lava cake - decadent - served with housemade vanilla bean ice cream! All of this is why we love Oddfellows.
LauraS
Great place for a glass of wine and flatbread appetizers. We had 2 hour reservations for Valentine's and didn't get our dinner until just about then. All other tables that came later had eaten and gone. Don't order swordfish. It was served in a pasta dish in chunks. It should have been chargrilled like a steak. It had the texture and taste of dried tuna. I enjoyed the atmosphere, but not the service. I'd go back for wine and flatbread.
Medra Pattillo
Great food, nice atmosphere and even live entertainment! I had the superior whitefish and it was delicious. I also had the Brussel sprouts side and my husband had rhe carrots both delicious. We could not eat it all so leftovers, yay! The sides are large enough to share. There is a full bar so you can have a cocktail. Overall a most enjoyable dining experience. I highly recommend this place and it is nice enough for special occasions.Vegetarian options: Plenty of options.Dietary restrictions: They offer many options that are clearly labeled on the menu.Parking: There is a nice lot in back and an entry door from parking.Wheelchair accessibility: The front entrance is definitely accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Brussels Sprouts, Lake Superior Whitefish, Chocolate Cremeux
Great little place in the heart of downtown. Unique vibe, excellent wine & cocktails, and a carefully curated menu. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
KRodman
This was our first time at Oddfellows and we will be back. Our server was super kind and always made sure we were taken care of whether it was food wise or drinks. It was our anniversary and they gave us a dessert on them which I thought was wonderful customer service. Everyone was friendly and the atmosphere was calming.
Codell Story
I have had almost every dish from this restaurant , and every dish has been amazing well flavored and fresh. tonight, I tried the steak Burger with the truffle fries, and I will say it is one of the best burgers I have ever had in my life. Truffle fries were par none , it was amazing. Thank you for your wonderful hospitality and service. I definitely will be back!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You will find no restaurant like this north of Green Bay. Everything from the setting and ambience, down to the drinks and food is unique and superb!!!. Definetly, one of the best restaurants in the U..P.
javo3
whitefish was plentiful and delicious even if oddly presented. served in three pieces on a bed of corn mixed with a green salsa. my problem was THAT was all there was. no potato choice - no salad choice- no soup choice- no bread choice- asked about buying a bread option and was told they didn't have any. while 22 dollars seemed quite reasonable for a whitefish dinner--we didn't really get a "dinner"
Love the burrata and wine options. Main reason I come back.I’ve ordered the steak every time. I would recommend ordering a different dish. Just is what it is. I come for the burrata, wine and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
A breath of fresh air for our community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Superior Whitefish, Bison Short Rib
My husband and I both ordered the chicken marsala, and it was very good as were the duck wings. The service was prompt and polite, It was a Thursday so there was a live musician which was a treat. It is a bit noisy because the ceilings are so high, but we liked the more urban atmosphere with the lights and brick wall. The menu is not extensive, but we will try it again sometime.
It was fine, food was fine, nothing outstanding. Waitstaff was a bit over attentive- the woman filled my glass every time I took a sip. We also had a bit of a challenge for a vegetarian guest as many items had cheese already in them, grits, pesto, even having messaged them a week before our reservation. Lights could've been a little lower for a wine bar, they have about 10 giant globe lights that were at full blast. They did offer nice N/A drink options.
Perfect place for our anniversary dinner! Food was unbelievable and customer service excellent! Good menu specials and a good variety of entrees and appetizers to choose from. Excellent wine and beer list! I have not found better Lake Superior whitefish served south of M28 as of yet!Parking: Plenty of safe and secure parking in back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Fish Chowder, Lake Superior Whitefish, Pesto Pasta w Shrimp
My boyfriend and I went here for the first time on Valentine’s Day for dinner. The food was pretty good, but the server was rather pushy to order, always popping up at the most inopportune times while we tried to enjoy conversation and cocktails prior to ordering. Found out the next day that we had been charged twice for our dinner. We called to inquire and the manager told us she would check into it and she got our info and said she would get back to us. We waited three more days with no call back so we called again. She told us that it was a problem with the company who handles their credit card payments and that 6-7 others patrons had also been overcharged. She became very irritated and said “I don’t have time to explain this to you right now; I am really busy,” and that they had been open a year and this never happened before. Lastly, she had no idea when we would be refunded and did not offer any kind of compensation or idea of what to do next. Very rude, too busy to tell us anything and very poor customer service. We will not be back for the price as the hassle far outweighs the dinner we had here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Excellent food- nothing in the area compares. Great cocktails, beer, and wine. Service also top notch. Brittany at the bar will make it a perfect experience. I live 300 miles away, but I’ll return for that Bourbon cream root beer float!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Brussels Sprouts, Lake Superior Whitefish, Chocolate Cremeux
Valentine's Day dinner at Oddfellows was special. Their housemade pasta never disappoints, cooked perfectly al dente. The fig and goat cheese puffed pastry is the perfect combination of sweet and savory. Music by One Human Band was the right volume - we appreciate his music. We enjoyed a featured cocktail and wine. Finally, with the red velvet molten lava cake - decadent - served with housemade vanilla bean ice cream! All of this is why we love Oddfellows.
Great place for a glass of wine and flatbread appetizers. We had 2 hour reservations for Valentine's and didn't get our dinner until just about then. All other tables that came later had eaten and gone. Don't order swordfish. It was served in a pasta dish in chunks. It should have been chargrilled like a steak. It had the texture and taste of dried tuna. I enjoyed the atmosphere, but not the service. I'd go back for wine and flatbread.
Great food, nice atmosphere and even live entertainment! I had the superior whitefish and it was delicious. I also had the Brussel sprouts side and my husband had rhe carrots both delicious. We could not eat it all so leftovers, yay! The sides are large enough to share. There is a full bar so you can have a cocktail. Overall a most enjoyable dining experience. I highly recommend this place and it is nice enough for special occasions.Vegetarian options: Plenty of options.Dietary restrictions: They offer many options that are clearly labeled on the menu.Parking: There is a nice lot in back and an entry door from parking.Wheelchair accessibility: The front entrance is definitely accessible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Brussels Sprouts, Lake Superior Whitefish, Chocolate Cremeux
Restaurantji Recommends
Great little place in the heart of downtown. Unique vibe, excellent wine & cocktails, and a carefully curated menu. 5 stars!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first time at Oddfellows and we will be back. Our server was super kind and always made sure we were taken care of whether it was food wise or drinks. It was our anniversary and they gave us a dessert on them which I thought was wonderful customer service. Everyone was friendly and the atmosphere was calming.
I have had almost every dish from this restaurant , and every dish has been amazing well flavored and fresh. tonight, I tried the steak Burger with the truffle fries, and I will say it is one of the best burgers I have ever had in my life. Truffle fries were par none , it was amazing. Thank you for your wonderful hospitality and service. I definitely will be back!!!!!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You will find no restaurant like this north of Green Bay. Everything from the setting and ambience, down to the drinks and food is unique and superb!!!. Definetly, one of the best restaurants in the U..P.
whitefish was plentiful and delicious even if oddly presented. served in three pieces on a bed of corn mixed with a green salsa. my problem was THAT was all there was. no potato choice - no salad choice- no soup choice- no bread choice- asked about buying a bread option and was told they didn't have any. while 22 dollars seemed quite reasonable for a whitefish dinner--we didn't really get a "dinner"