Coney Island

266 E Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo
(269) 382-0377

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rowan Palmer

Awesome, haven't been here since I was a kid and it was even better than I remembered. Staff is so nice too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natalie King

Fantastic!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

CN Tortellini

Classic dog house open for well over a century. The classic interior reminds me of visiting when I was a kid. The Coneys taste great like always but with inflation and all, it’s gotten expensive. I don’t blame the place but it’s gotten so I’ll only visit on rare occasions when it’s pushing a twenty spot for a couple dogs, fries and a drink.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anita Johnson

They have the best coney in this area. I come from Battle Creek to enjoy this coney dog.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe Grgurich

1) Music was a good high energy!
2) I was next in line.
3) Food is all a high quality goal here!
For the Coney experience, this is it: )

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paula

OMG!! Talk about nostalgia, the best Coney Dog made to perfection and a great meal….I visited 50 years ago and it was a simple menu (still the same😊). The Coney Dog is made with a high end brand wiener that has a one of a kind flavor. One bite and you notice that it is quality. I’m not an onion or mustard fan but since this place is famous for their Coney Dog, I tried it. It has mustard and chopped onions on top of the famous “chili”. The chili is hard to describe…it’s their specialty and no other Coney Dog compares. It’s been their “secret” for generations. It has mustard that has a just right flavor and add the onions….mmm, mmm, mmm!!! The combination is PERFECTION 💕Wow! My picky husband and I went back and ordered two more😂. Onion rings were batter dipped and great. And not to mention the chili cheese fries were another great side. Even the fountain drink Pepsi tasted great. I can’t say enough how happy that we ate there. We are from out of town but we’re going to find excuses to come back often. We visited the downtown diner, the original one that’s been there for generations. They kept the original walk in feel….like a time in history. I’m rambling on, but I want to emphasize how special this place is and how they’ve kept the same menu and quality of food that you’ll rarely experience. A+++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coney Meal with an Extra Coney Dog, Onion Rings, Chili Fries

Becky D

Thank you so much the food was amazing (:💯👌👍👍👍🫶 -Jon

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hamburger, Coney Dogs Chicago Dog French Fries

Sister Pat

Fries were great

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Seth Roush

This place has the best hot dogs ever I've had a lot of hot dogs in my life and this place is the only place that makes them right staff was wonderful I think everyone should go here at least once but once you've had one you'll keep going back for more thank you for making it such a pleasant experience and for letting me leave with a full stomach I really can't give this place enough credit if there was the option to leave 1,000 Stars I would do it

Linda Cole

For never been there before I was a bit disappointed. Honestly I can make better chili dogs at home. It was soggy, fell apart, VERY MESSY. Didn't taste like chili. Was just ground beef. fries were ok. Bathroom smelt old and musty. For being the oldest restaurant in town... Y'all need to step it up.

Georgianne Dykstra

I love Coney!! The owners and staff are very friendly. Their Chicago dog is spot on, the Coney is delicious and the fries are perfect.

Kory Short

Terrible is all I can say.
Waited 15 minutes for 2 hotdogs and I will not be back.

Pat Dorey

Love everything about them food service awesome

Casey Geimer

This place serves hot dogs, hamburgers and gyros.
We had the hamburger, coney dogs, and onion rings. Everything made to perfection

It's a simple place with good food. Highly recommend.

Lyn Jones

My husband has been going to Coney Island for over 80 years. When we go to Kalamazoo we must go to Coney Island.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chili Dog

Loading...