Theo & Stacy's Downtown

234 W Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo
(269) 388-5025

Recent Reviews

shawn dockery

Friendly staff, great food and reasonably priced, plus newly adde Taco (gyro) Tuesday!!

Samantha-Brian Wittenberg

I have been eating here for a long time and love it. The food is always great and you will never walk away still hungry. Stacy is one of the kindest, most honest and genuine people I have met. I highly recommend this place.

Delanie M.

A M A Z I N G! Theo & Stacy's serves greek cuisine and even do a vegan night the first friday or every month. I don't eat dairy and my best friend is a vegan so we HAD to try it out. We had the olympic sampler, the lentil soup, mousaka, soutzoukakia, and baklava. All of the food was amazing and so was the service. The olympic sampler had a delicious dairy free tzatziki sauce that tasted like the real thing. Stacy herself came and checked up on us multiple times and we learned about how she made the sauce herself. The soutzoukakia (meatballs) and grape leaves tasted like real ground beef and were seasoned so well. Every thing we had was delicious even the warm pita bread served with the meal. I wish vegan night was every night! They were very busy but our service didn't suffer at all and stacy boxed up our food to help out our server.

Brooklynn Paddock

Good food,nice people!:))

Treshel Hoeft

Excellent, fluffy, pancakes....the best I have ever had!! And they are big, my ol man could only eat two.

John Crissman

Food was fantastic and came out in record time. Our waitress Jessina was a delight with the kids. Return trip ensured!!

Lori halverson-wente

Outstanding authentic Greek food with large portions at a great value! Plus the owner came by all the tables to see if we enjoyed our food and to thank us!!! She was so sweet and sealed the deal of my amazing night out! Th is is the best Greek food I have had in the US!

Jared Foster

For a Greek joint the gyro was only half good. Should be a hot a fresh signature item. Service was great though and the place was clean.

Dawn Niemisto

We stopped into Theo and Stacy's today for a late lunch almost early dinner. Which I am so so thankful we did. We immediately were seated. Then upon being seated our wonderful  waitress Jessina took our order when we were ready. I could not wait to try the items we selected off there nice Winter menu. Especially  when I saw the table near us get what I thought might be what I ordered. When my Greek Cobb Power Bowl Came out I was so so excited.  Darcy the hostess brought it out. I found out as we talked about how amazing it looked she put it together. I added Gyro meat to it. The veggies are so fresh and tasty. The Gyro Meat is so tender. My boyfriend ordered a French Dip Sandwich which the meat was tender and delicious. They also were great about his allergies. Which not all restaurants are. Then to top off an already perfect time Stacy herself came out of the kitchen to see us. Which was wonderful. She chatted with us for awhile answered questions and then gave us some complimentary Baklava which was to die for... so if your looking for amazing food Stop in to Theo and Stacy's.  You will not regret it.❤

Sarah Bickel

I spent the weekend with my sisters in Kalamazoo. We are all from out of town. Theo and Stacys was a clean and friendly restaurant with attentive staff. Our food was prepared fresh and arrived quickly. The place was full of people and small, but it wasn’t crowded and seemed to run like a well oiled machine. We felt like family and would definitely come back next time we are in town! The pita bread and Rye bread were so fresh and delicious, one of us dropped our gluten-free guidelines for the afternoon. The Greek dressing was so good I asked to purchase some to take home and they were cheerfully accommodating to my imposing requests. The facility was so well taken care of, you could feel pride and love in this restaurant. We felt like we were invited into our friends home to have lunch.

Jeff Panaka

I came here for lunch and I was in a rush so they expedited my order despite the restaurant being at nearly full capacity. This was greatly appreciated. The food is well priced, well presented, and most importantly good. 5/5 one of my Kalamazoo standbys.

Emalee B.

This place is a nice ma and pa diner. It's quaint on the inside and not too many people inside, which is what I look for. My s/o and I ordered the Gyro omelet but we were served two Greek omelets, they were still tasty though! I enjoyed my visit here, it wasn't anything grandiose but I think we'll stop back in! We only got refilled on coffee twice, we would've appreciated a couple more however, there was only one waitress and quite a few tables got sat so it was busy for one waitress.

Justin Miner

Absolutely love this location. Took my daughter is and the service was top notch. Definitely going back soon.

Brenda Hughes

Always good quality comfort food, breakfast all day, and specials.

Rebecca Hanley Leitow

Thank you so much for the great lunch at the cancer center! I asked for vegan options as I have been to your Friday dinners. It was so good. Usually there is nothing for me to eat at these types of things. I am still full from the amazing lunch.

Load More