Penny's Five Star Pizza
$ • PizzaAbout Penny's Five Star Pizza
Customers' Favorites
14'' 1 Topping Pizza Special
Individual Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella Breadsticks
Meat Lovers Pizza
Ham & Cheese Sub
Beef Taco Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Regular Sub
Italian Sub
Salad Bar
Penny's Five Star Pizza Reviews
175 ratings
Share your opinion about Penny's Five Star Pizza
The homemade soup has elevated the menu so much, not that it wasn’t already amazing for a small town pizza shop. Not even to mention the soup and salad bar, which is so affordable and my favorite lunch spot.
Anyways what triggered this review was the ham and potato soup that saved my soul tonight after fighting a stomach bug with all the kiddos this week, it quite literally warmed us up and truly tastes so good. Truly the homemade soup hug. Lucky to have this small gem in...read full review
Anyways what triggered this review was the ham and potato soup that saved my soul tonight after fighting a stomach bug with all the kiddos this week, it quite literally warmed us up and truly tastes so good. Truly the homemade soup hug. Lucky to have this small gem in...read full review
thanks for delivering. food was great. roads were getting bad and it was appreciated.
I went for the 1st time on Saturday with my mother-in-law and the food was great. We were the only diners at 4:00pm. We ordered the LG breadsticks and peanut butter cookies as a appetizer, they were fast perfectly cooked, large and full of cheese, looked & tasted great. I ordered the turkey bacon sub and she had lasagna, that we had to take home as we were extremely full & satisfied! Those homemade cookies tho are absolutely delicious 😋.
Hours
| Monday | 3 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
Penny's Five Star Pizza provides a welcoming dining experience with its great pizzas, bread sticks, and subs served in a clean and inviting atmosphere. The friendly staff ensures timely orders and attentive customer service, making customers feel welcomed. The garlic butter crust remains a highlight, and the restaurant offers a sweet treat for kids. Customers often return for the excellent food and service. The menu features the famous signature sauce, and the cheese sticks are highly praised as some of the best ever. There are also tasty subs, calzones, and a weekday pizza and salad lunch buffet, offering good value. The family-owned restaurant has been a cherished part of the community, with a strong commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Many customers appreciate the fresh ingredients and generous portions, noting that the pizza is often delivered hot and delicious. The decor is a charming mix of sparkly vinyl and Formica, adding to its cozy, small-town feel. Overall, Penny's Five Star Pizza remains a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.