Decided to try goodfellas bagel for first time, sadly the only time. Customer service was friendly which is the reason for 2 stars. But the food alone... never again. I ordered breakfast burritos and various sandwiches( the don, lucky, bada bing) and some hash browns for my family to try. The hash were not fully cooked and falling apart, I put them in our airfryer to cook a Lil longer and honestly even after that they didn't really taste good( greasy taste). The burritos contain chorizo, potatoes, eggs and some peppers and onion... never thought you can screw up a breakfast burrito. The potatoes were burnt black but still hard( not cooked properly).. peppers and onions were cut too big and also still hard from not being cooked properly. The sandwiches were edible ( okay, no wow factor like i would have like) but not worth the price at all. Hate to say this but mcdonald's steak and bagel meal is way better and worth the money. Sad because the service and the atmosphere( inside meijer city market) is nice and enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
Joni
2021;this place is the bomb! one of the best breakfest sandwiches you can get in Lansing!update 2024;so, ordered via ubereats and it was a bit laggy but service overall was prompt. person on phone @ deli answered my questions promptly and kindly. I ordered the capo and new burrito. the capo was on point and hasn't changed a bit. the capo was an excellent choice with alot of flavor. the newer burritos however are rather bland and cafeteria style food totally diveragent from their life changing bagels. I would not recomend the burritos. I ordered fingerling potatoes and received soggy hashbrowns at $6. I wanted the ol' school awesome fingerling potatoes with bacon and that swizzy sauce! *ugh* typical I.M.E. with goodfellas service that they will send something substantial close to original if they run out of that product. overall better service from new shop. mixed feelings about some of the new product and service. the hand cut potatoes and prepack drinks are a welcomed addition!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
Mr Krud
Good a$$
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob Williams
This place is horrible. Got a lox bagel and it was burned to a crisp. Stopped in on a Sunday when they opened and no one was there, so the guy that I could tell hated his job did it on purpose. Will never ever go back jere again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mrgf Drttr
Capital city environment is nice but the restaurant was out of quite a few of their "iconic" options and the bagel sandwich I did get was burnt on the top. Egg tasted good but that was the only redeeming part. Big apple was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Bryan Likes to eat out
Good food and I love bagels, but cannot recommend eating at this location because it is overrun with
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 4
Abigail
I have never had a bag bagel from here - we get it delivered to my place of employment and have never had any errors with our order. They always arrive hot, and they definitely are not shy about the ingredients (LOVE THAT!). Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dimo Kallis
i was very unprepared for how good this food was going to be. i am so happy i stumbled upon it.
Kim Winston
You absolutely MUST make this a stop. The Goodfellow on cheese is my favorite. I live in California and my son lives an hour away, but when I come to Michigan this is the absolute one place I make sure, no matter what, to come get. And then I dream about it until I come back!Not only is the food amazing but the people are super cool. You will NOT regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brad
Badly prepared $10 bagel sandwich. Burnt to black bacon!, barely cream cheese, and burnt top of the everything bagel, which was very dry and hard. By far, it is the worst bagel sandwiches we have ever purchased. This is our 5th experience, and after having it great the first time, we are done trying to find a decent experience again. I don't recommend eating here.My wife was pretty sure the only person working at the time was the owner... that was a clear sign that we should go elsewhere for a bagel sandwich.They need some chef Ramsey help or something because it seems by the reviews that this place was good a couple of years ago. Even if the prices were half as much, I would go somewhere else...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, The Goodfella, The Don, Sausage Egg Cheese Sandwich, The Hitman, Bada Bing
They never keep any of their online stuff up to date—they’re listed as open but then no one will be staffing the store and orders may be placed and charged without ever being made or anyone being in the store.
Ryan M.
Ever since they relocated into the grocery store, they're seemingly inept. They don't toast the bagels, they say 20 mins on a simple order and take an hour, they don't man their cash register..... just all together worse than at their previous location
DeVon
I arrived to pick up a door dash order and the guy has his back turned. I said excuse me sir 3 times. He turns around I tell him I’m there to pick up order, he points at end of counter and turns back around. I go look at the end of the counter to see if my order is there and it wasn’t. I patiently wait for him to finish his prep. I said sir it’s no order down here, he looks at me and says i don’t know. Wow, I said you work here can you get someone to help me. He calls the guy out the back to help me, he asked the name and gets the order bagged up for me. Terrible customer service, would not recommend
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Matt Nara
Shows open on google and they have an open sign on the register. Yet no one is there at all. Correct your info on google and don’t leave an open sign in your stall.Wasting people’s time.
Service: 1
Brian Doyle
It’s nearly impossible to get in and out of here in a timely manner. They need to stop DoorDash orders or get more staff.Not worth the wait time.
Decided to try goodfellas bagel for first time, sadly the only time. Customer service was friendly which is the reason for 2 stars. But the food alone... never again. I ordered breakfast burritos and various sandwiches( the don, lucky, bada bing) and some hash browns for my family to try. The hash were not fully cooked and falling apart, I put them in our airfryer to cook a Lil longer and honestly even after that they didn't really taste good( greasy taste). The burritos contain chorizo, potatoes, eggs and some peppers and onion... never thought you can screw up a breakfast burrito. The potatoes were burnt black but still hard( not cooked properly).. peppers and onions were cut too big and also still hard from not being cooked properly. The sandwiches were edible ( okay, no wow factor like i would have like) but not worth the price at all. Hate to say this but mcdonald's steak and bagel meal is way better and worth the money. Sad because the service and the atmosphere( inside meijer city market) is nice and enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2
2021;this place is the bomb! one of the best breakfest sandwiches you can get in Lansing!update 2024;so, ordered via ubereats and it was a bit laggy but service overall was prompt. person on phone @ deli answered my questions promptly and kindly. I ordered the capo and new burrito. the capo was on point and hasn't changed a bit. the capo was an excellent choice with alot of flavor. the newer burritos however are rather bland and cafeteria style food totally diveragent from their life changing bagels. I would not recomend the burritos. I ordered fingerling potatoes and received soggy hashbrowns at $6. I wanted the ol' school awesome fingerling potatoes with bacon and that swizzy sauce! *ugh* typical I.M.E. with goodfellas service that they will send something substantial close to original if they run out of that product. overall better service from new shop. mixed feelings about some of the new product and service. the hand cut potatoes and prepack drinks are a welcomed addition!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
Good a$$
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is horrible. Got a lox bagel and it was burned to a crisp. Stopped in on a Sunday when they opened and no one was there, so the guy that I could tell hated his job did it on purpose. Will never ever go back jere again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Capital city environment is nice but the restaurant was out of quite a few of their "iconic" options and the bagel sandwich I did get was burnt on the top. Egg tasted good but that was the only redeeming part. Big apple was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Good food and I love bagels, but cannot recommend eating at this location because it is overrun with
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 4
I have never had a bag bagel from here - we get it delivered to my place of employment and have never had any errors with our order. They always arrive hot, and they definitely are not shy about the ingredients (LOVE THAT!). Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
i was very unprepared for how good this food was going to be. i am so happy i stumbled upon it.
You absolutely MUST make this a stop. The Goodfellow on cheese is my favorite. I live in California and my son lives an hour away, but when I come to Michigan this is the absolute one place I make sure, no matter what, to come get. And then I dream about it until I come back!Not only is the food amazing but the people are super cool. You will NOT regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Badly prepared $10 bagel sandwich. Burnt to black bacon!, barely cream cheese, and burnt top of the everything bagel, which was very dry and hard. By far, it is the worst bagel sandwiches we have ever purchased. This is our 5th experience, and after having it great the first time, we are done trying to find a decent experience again. I don't recommend eating here.My wife was pretty sure the only person working at the time was the owner... that was a clear sign that we should go elsewhere for a bagel sandwich.They need some chef Ramsey help or something because it seems by the reviews that this place was good a couple of years ago. Even if the prices were half as much, I would go somewhere else...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, The Goodfella, The Don, Sausage Egg Cheese Sandwich, The Hitman, Bada Bing
Restaurantji Recommends
They never keep any of their online stuff up to date—they’re listed as open but then no one will be staffing the store and orders may be placed and charged without ever being made or anyone being in the store.
Ever since they relocated into the grocery store, they're seemingly inept. They don't toast the bagels, they say 20 mins on a simple order and take an hour, they don't man their cash register..... just all together worse than at their previous location
I arrived to pick up a door dash order and the guy has his back turned. I said excuse me sir 3 times. He turns around I tell him I’m there to pick up order, he points at end of counter and turns back around. I go look at the end of the counter to see if my order is there and it wasn’t. I patiently wait for him to finish his prep. I said sir it’s no order down here, he looks at me and says i don’t know. Wow, I said you work here can you get someone to help me. He calls the guy out the back to help me, he asked the name and gets the order bagged up for me. Terrible customer service, would not recommend
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Shows open on google and they have an open sign on the register. Yet no one is there at all. Correct your info on google and don’t leave an open sign in your stall.Wasting people’s time.
Service: 1
It’s nearly impossible to get in and out of here in a timely manner. They need to stop DoorDash orders or get more staff.Not worth the wait time.
Atmosphere: 5