Mackinac Island Pizza Company

Name: Mackinac Island Pizza Company
Address: 1547 Cadotte Ave, Mackinac Island, Michigan, 49757, US
Telephone: (906) 847-2313
Price range: $
Rating: 4

$ • Pizza

Hours:
1547 Cadotte Ave, Mackinac Island
(906) 847-2313

About Mackinac Island Pizza Company

Mackinac Island Pizza Company offers high-quality Detroit-style pizzas with crispy crust and fresh toppings. The restaurant features a cute, retro diner decor and provides relatively affordable meals, such as the half mushroom and half tomato basil pizza. Customers can enjoy a variety of options, including the meats pizza and breadstix, which are delicious despite their small size for the cost—though prices are comparable to other places on the island. Some guests wish the restaurant offered half-size pizzas, as the full pizzas provide only eight slices, making it difficult to take leftovers back to the hotel. The restaurant can be busy, leading to long wait times for ordering, especially during lunch rushes, and the self-cleanup area tends to be crowded with overpiled utensils and pizza pans. The Caesar Salad, served in a small prepackaged container for $12, was considered not worth the price. The staff are friendly, but sometimes extra charges or delays can occur, such as a surcharge for substitutions. Guests have enjoyed the pizza lunch special for two, which includes 4 slices, a salad, and two drinks for $25, offering good value considering the location. The pizza with pepperoni and sausage has been praised for its toppings, cheese, and crispy crust, with fast service often delivering pizzas in about 15 minutes. Many visitors consider it the best pizza on the island, especially praising the crust for its crispy, cheesy crunch and the friendly, welcoming staff. The space is spacious enough to accommodate larger groups, making it a nice spot to grab a bite on Mackinac Island. Overall, despite some minor issues, the good service, cleanliness, and tasty pizzas make it a popular choice.