Mackinac Island Pizza Company

Great Detroit Deep Dish Pizza. Super crispy crust on the bottom but light fluffy thick on the inside and quality toppings too. Will return!

Pretty pricey for what we got

Maybe a little pricey but great deep dish pizza. Friendly staff.

Ordered the pizza salad which was $15. It was served in a plastic container with a plastic lid. Very few ingredients besides iceberg lettuce. No gluten free pizza crust option.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had!!!

Reason for the 4 star review- we ordered 2 half pizzas for lunch ($17) each. The Greek and mushroom pizzas were great AFTER we requested to remove the lemon zest and subbed it with the truffle honey drizzle (which elevated the pizzas to 4.5 stars). Please remove the lemon zest permanently - doesn’t belong on a pizza. The person at the counter was friendly but she tried to charge me $10 surcharge for the substitution. I was annoyed because the only other pizza that they sold with the honey was only $2 extra. But I didn’t even order meat on my pizza and thought the surcharge was excessive. Finally she agreed. Additionally, I stood in line and it took me 10-15 minutes just to order because the 2 groups ahead of me were requesting some sort of discount which they had to find a manager for and also had questions about the wine. There should have been another person to assist because there was a lunch rush and it was taking so long for everything.
Finally, the Caesar Salad was in a small prepackaged container and it was $12 dollars. Wasn’t worth it. Place seemed pretty small for the amount of people that were there and the utensils and pizza pans were overpiled in the self cleanup area with no one going around to wipe the tables down.

Such great value for island food! Yummy food, huge and fresh salad, pretty decor and lovely bathrooms! I'd come back again and again

We ordered the meats pizza and breadstix. It was very delicious but small pizza size for the cost. However, for the island, it was priced on par with everything else. I would return.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Garlic Bread Sticks with Marinara Sauce

Pizza was alright, but not really worth the price. I wish they would offer a half-size pizza. You get 8 thick slices, my husband and I could only finish half and couldn't really bring the rest back to our hotel. Also, I'm a huge mushroom fan, but I feel that the mushrooms they use don't go well on a pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

This was good food and good service considering this is counter service so to speak. The food was on the pricier side but conside you are on the island.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza, Garlic Bread Sticks with Marinara Sauce

By far the best pizza we've ever had! If you're ever in the area, you have to try it!

pizza was ok but overpriced

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Wouldn't recommend poor service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

This is better than Buddy’s or any other chain Detroit pizza place…and it’s on an island

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nice people there helped us order a pepperoni pizza. When it came out it after 25 minutes it was burnt and the employee agreed and said they would make us another. After twenty minutes I asked about the new pie and they had forgotten to put the pizza in. Manager gave refund as we said we would leave. She was not surprised or very apologetic. Maybe it happens often.
Table was dirty and we had to ask them to clean it. Breadsticks and salad not the best. Expect much more from a Grand Hotel property.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2