4 Best Mexican Restaurants near Mackinac Island

“I had a taste-test date night with my wife. We bought PB fudge from every store on the island and in Mac City. We can say with certainty that Murray Hotel Fudge Company has the best Peanut Butter fudge in the straights. We also agreed that theirs is the creamiest fudge on the island. There are so many flavors, but my favorite is the Cinnamon Bun! Although there was an error in our rather large online order, they proved that their service is excellent by correcting it right away. Latoya was wonderful and helpful. Thanks!!“

“We really enjoy this restaurant. The food is always delicious & the employees are amazing.“

“We ate here last weekend for probably the 6th time, we look forward to it every time we’re in St. Ignace! Great staff who deal with the busy northern Michigan weekend rush of entitled down staters and out of staters with class, and the food is always excellent. They have live acoustic music on the weekends, and the artists are usually really impressive. Ignore the poor reviews, this is one of the best spots in town!“

“I haven't been to St. Ignace in a few years, but after leaving the ER with my kid, I was SO fricken excited to see it while taking him to McD. I didn't even know it was there. I saw 2 guys working who were both extremely kind & polite & probably didn't judge me at all for all the food I ordered.

And all that food was on point too!! My quesadilla had the perfect cheese/chicken-chipotle sauce ratio & the tortilla strips on my grilled cheese steak burrito were ACTUALLY crispy. It is entirely possible that I was just starving, but it was amazing & possibly one of the best fast food experiences I have had in a while.“