Original Murdick's Fudge

Great Mother's Day present, ordered online. Fast delivery on 3rd day from ordered.

Fudge was hard and dried out. Sugary, not creamy.

The absolute best fudge you will ever eat!

Will always and forever cherish this place! My family is from the UP and we always visited and we still get some shipped from our UP family every year!

A very special gift for my mother recently diagnosed with terminal cancer. she had been on a strict, sugar free diet to help slow the progression but to no avail. I finally received permission to order her favorite treat in the world from a place that holds some of her best memories. When ordered a week prior to Christmas, tracking showed a post Christmas delivery. I called CS and the kindest representive stepped in to expedite the order! It arrived on time and she was elated. Her favorite fudge, beautifully presented just in time for her last Christmas. Thank you, Murdicks!

The fudge and brittle is so absolutely fantastic!! I bought some for my dad in AZ, he loved it. He loved it so much he had me order more for him and my family! And the delivery was so fast, I really can't recommend them enough!!

They were making fudge when we came in, and it was fun to watch while we waited in line. I was thankful for a chance to try samples - it helped me choose what to walk away with!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fudge

Everyone raves about this place. I don’t know if the man that was there was the owner or a sales rep but everyone in the place was so consumed a “corn syrup“ delivery instead of focusing on customers. The young girl behind the counter couldn’t be bothered with a friendly disposition and courteous nature. Go to other fudge shops where they are lovely and look forward to customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Friendly staff, great fudge!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fudge

The people making the fudge were happy and cheerful. The two women at the counter were not. No smiles, no recommendations, no thank you for your purchase. The fudge was great. The peanut brittle tasted stale, not good at all. An overall disappointment for the touted oldest fudge shop on the island.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fudge

Ordered fudge online. The German chocolate is absolutely amazing and I wish I would haven't gotten more. Had a small mix up with my order and they fixed it right away. Very thankful for the great costumer service!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Every other store here is a fudge shop so I figured I’d try the first. Fudge is good, popcorn was awful (stale).

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Fudge

When I was a child we vacationed in the u p and I remember this fudge to this day (it is Devine) 50 years later ,,,I keep seeing ads for you and thank God!!! I ordered some just came today and it is just how I remember! I ordered the 5 slices box for my boyfriend for his birthday, I had to sneech a sliver,,,I'll be raving about you to friends and family,such great memories will be passed on.!

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fudge

Best fudge

I had no idea dogs were not allowed, understandable with food. My fault on my part to assume because we've gone to restaurants with my senior dog. So my dog is in a stroller, as I enter, before I was even a foot in, someone said no dogs allowed do I backed out and left. As I leave, I heard her yell "buh bye" then heard chuckles. I respect businesses who does not allow dogs so I left right away but be respectful and professional.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1