Original Murdick's Fudge
7363 Main St, Mackinac Island
(906) 847-3530
Customers' Favorites
Fudge
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The absolute BEST fudge. We flew into Mackinac island twice this year and both times left with a bag of fudge from this amazing shop. The last time we visited was Wednesday 10/25. We don’t know that everything would be closed. We had the pleasure of meeting Bob. He saved the day. Thank you again!!
Worker was annoyed and short with us when we ordered. We asked if they sold 1/2 bars and she said “Nope.”. The whole process she couldn’t have been less enthused. Should have left but bought some bars anyway. The flavor was nice for each one - so my only complaint is the service.
Absolutely love their fudge and flavors but 2nd time buying the taffy ..wont make that mistake 3 times. Its melty and doesn't harden,sticks to paper really bad and all the taffy tastes the same regardless of the color. Even refrigerating doesn't make it taffy consistency. Taffy is a 1 star with me but fudge is definitely always 5 stars.