Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

Picked up a couple of sandwiches while traveling. Good food though one of the sandwiches was a bit sloppy. Prices seemed a bit high.

Very pricy for what you get. Long wait for your food. Staff was friendly.

Waiting time is a bit but the food is worth it! We always take food to go because it feels empty inside and kinda unwelcoming but may just be me!

I had a little Mancino's Pizza shop in my hometown when growing up, so I kinda knew what to expect. However, this location that I've gone to since I came to the Oshtemo/Kalamazoo area in late '80s is amazing! You want a sub from the menu? Custom items? Soft or crunchy? How about a pizza? Custom and light sauce? Just cheese? Special diet? Buffet dining? NOBODY has been as accommodating as my Mattawan Mancino's Italian Eatery! NOBODY. Picky husband? Finicky wife? Kids that seem to never want anything or they pick at it until it's cold? BRING THEM HERE!! Friends coming from out of town, and you can only make last-minute plans? Mancino's will take care of you! They're definitely not like the bland national chain, and still not like the pretentious little 4-table eatery. Mattawan Mancino's has become my ONLY choice for about 30 years. Sauce isn't too spicy like they're trying to impress you, toppings aren't sad and lonely like they were dished onto the pizza with rusty spoons. To be completely honest, their quality and flavor outweigh their prices - I feel that I MORE than get my money's worth, even if I order delivery - and come on, I know that's rare. If you haven't yet, just try them. And if you HAVE had Mancino's Pizza, then I'm sorry if I steer more people their way and our wait is 10 minutes longer!

But please know, I'm actually a nobody who simply likes quality pizza and subs. I'm not getting paid by them, nor am I an employee or family member. But when I was asked by Google to review them? Oh heck yeah, there's just nothing like them around, and luckily there are a few locations near me.

I order a large taco salad for takeout. It was fresh. But for the pice I paid is was a very poorly made salad there was a lot of lettuce and chips but there was hardly any meat in it. It was not worth the money I paid for it.

The food was good, my sides were lacking and under-cooked, definitely not worth what they charged.

The food has gone way down hill in recent years. Very disappointed. I used to love the steak delicious!
Sub par ingredients.

Great food, especially there pizza

I was in there today and i just don't understand why most of the young people that work there are so disrespectful, (don't care) don't say thank you or you are welcome for your order. the owners need to to get more involved with the store out here in Mattawan instead of just getting the profits because its going down hill fast.
The grinders are the same size of bread but the filling are getting smaller and smaller and that a shame.
The pizzas are doing the thing so smaller and more expansive with less toppings and smaller size, it's just sad that the mattawan community has supported owners of samuel mancino's for good food and good times for a long time.
I feel now that the owners have swept us under the rug with the poor quality of food and some of the young employees that treat their customers like it's a bother for us to come in.
Signed longtime customer sad of the outcome.

I wasn't feeling perky yesterday and I decided I wanted a sandwich/easy meal today. After reviewing the menu, I told my husband what I wanted and he placed an order for pickup. When he brought it home, we were both immediately unimpressed.

I ordered a club sandwich. It had what appeared to be bacon bits on it, not strips of bacon. The quality of ingredients seem subpar especially as compared to the description and / or pictures online.

He got the steak sandwich that he used to get frequently and he noticed a huge decrease in quality of ingredients. The flavor has also changed. I ordered a salad and it had white onion all over it. You don't put white onion on a salad and even the pictures show red. The chicken was just cold deli chicken vs grilled chicken. All in all in all, I think we will just take our service elsewhere.

In theory these are small issues, and I know that costs of everything are going up but we are willing to pay for quality and we did not get it here.

Great good, service is always friendly and quick. Best Italian grinder in West Michigan IMO!

I door dashed a sub, paid for extra veggies, came cold, tons of lettuce, I mean - enough to feed an army - barley any other veg, no mayo to be found- cheese was iffy and somewhere it had traces of what could have been. Store could not help me, manager was sincere and apologetic about my ongoing hunger since the trash bin had dinner instead of me.

Ordered one kids pizza and a small sub on a relatively slow Friday night been waiting for a solid forty minutes while there’s four kids just moving as slow as can be and goofing off. No responsible person in sight this place is a joke.

Overall a good place to get food from. Does get busy, but worth the wait.

Went with my Mother because she likes their baked spaghetti.