Brewster's New Buffalo
$$ • Italian, Pizza, Gluten-Free
Hours:
11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
(269) 469-3005
About Brewster's New Buffalo
Customers' Favorites
Brewster's New Buffalo Reviews
Share your opinion about Brewster's New Buffalo
First time dining at Brewster’s and definitely will be back. Amazing food, drinks, service, and ambiance!
Well worth the 70 minute drive! Yummm!
My step mom and I went to dinner last night, we had the option of the bar for immediate seating which we gladly took. Bartender Melissa was great, despite being busy making delicious drinks she tended to us quickly. I had the blueberry lemon drop which was amazing. We really enjoyed the garlic dip appetizer; step mom had the steak salad and I had the chicken Alfredo and we thoroughly enjoyed our selections. We took tiramisu and a piece of cake (can’t recall the name)home which...read full review
My step mom and I went to dinner last night, we had the option of the bar for immediate seating which we gladly took. Bartender Melissa was great, despite being busy making delicious drinks she tended to us quickly. I had the blueberry lemon drop which was amazing. We really enjoyed the garlic dip appetizer; step mom gas the steak salad and I had the chicken Alfredo and we thoroughly enjoyed our selections. We took tiramisu and a piece of cake (can’t recall the name)home which...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 9PM |
People in New Buffalo Also Viewed
Brewster's New Buffalo provides a delightful dining experience with a wide selection of gluten-free choices. The restaurant features a cozy and bright atmosphere, especially in their beautiful patio dining area, which is perfect for warm days, offering a cool and shaded spot to relax. The menu includes imaginative dishes like beef ribs with hummus and summer cioppino with gnocchi, both served in generous portions with amazing taste and flavors. Guests often enjoy their visits thanks to excellent dinners and attentive service from friendly staff. The outdoor seating is particularly popular, equipped with heaters if needed, and creates a lovely atmosphere with good background music despite being busy at times. Visitors frequently recommend trying the handmade sangria and fresh-baked cookies or sharing a house salad and spaghetti and meatballs. The dinner for two is considered a great deal, often providing enough for leftovers, including options like soup, pizza, and shrimp Alfredo. Many guests mention that service is consistently praised and the food remains high quality, making Brewster's a favorite spot in New Buffalo for a tasty meal.