Pi Sci was very disappointing for all the hype it receives.Cheese Pizza - Good flavored square pie. $3 for beef pepperoni and you only get two one each slice (~19¢/slice) which is sad.Bread Sticks - Terrible. Extremely thin and hard as a rock. Most of them were inedible. The garlic cream cheese was pretty good but nothing special.Cinnamon (Evil) Bread - Looked about 50x better than it tasted. At times it felt like I was doing the 2012 cinnamon challenge. This was also way too much bread, could’ve used some of it on the normal breadsticks.Dietary restrictions: vegan and halal options
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jamie Meyers
After reading about them in metro times in the newspaper, we thought we’d give them a try tonight. This is the worst pizza I’ve had in the Oak Park area in a long time the cheese pizza it was empty and lifeless and didn’t have enough sauce. Papa Romano’s down. The street is a lot better than this..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Lily Coker
I get pizza a lot. I’m very happy this place opened up right next down the block from me because this is my new spot. So
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy P.
For some reason, I found the online ordering a little difficult. So with my first added frustration, I just called. When I did get there, I waited, and the gentleman at the front looked a little confused with all the people there forgot I was there for a few minutes and said your pizzas ready. But unfortunately, they forgot to put the salsa Verde on my pizza so the pizza was a little bland and for calling it, El Pastor, they needed to put some of that on the pizza. If there was one little bite on each slice of pork, that was a a lot. I'm sure they'll get the wrinkles out of the business. I hope they do it soon.
Melissa M.
Having been a previous patron of the Detroit location, I was psyched to try this place! I know they recently opened and wanted to wait a bit before coming, but tonight was the night. I ordered online and I found the add on descriptions slightly confusing. I had to call to ask about what VAL honey is (it's "hot" honey, more on that in a minute) and instead of the normal "light, normal, extra" options, it's small or large drizzle with zero clarification about what that even looks like. They also don't specify how many slices are in each pizza size. The other issue I had is that they offer option to get text updates but I got none. Obviously, I was hungry and it estimated at least an hour which seemed like a long time considering how late it was. But, I figured it's Friday so that's probably why. I got there and it was ready, but for who knows how long? I eventually got a text long after I was home saying it was ready. Might be worth reworking this system. I got the square pizza, and it's actually cooked perfectly. Expensive to add each item but that's about the standard now. Their "hot honey" isn't super great but it's definitely spicy! I was hoping it would actually taste like honey but it really is just sriracha. Breadsticks were hard and tasted like pita chips more than anything and they don't automatically offer pizza sauce as a dipping sauce (why?) so I elected to get the garlic cream cheese. However, it was almost frozen even with the 10 min drive home. Disappointing. Overall, I don't think that I'll be back for awhile. I'm sure they have some kinks to work out and hopefully they'll do that.
Joseph Basila
Soaked in oil and undercooked. Will try again but not happy with what we
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ashley Castle
Great! Our order was made quickly and everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex R.
Was very excited to try Pie Sci last week, but left overall not impressed. Everything was fine, not great, just fine. Nothing about the two pizza's we tried were unique or mind blowing (square pepperoni & square Baby Got BBQ). I can understand the hype if you have dietary restrictions, but for the average person the higher price of everything isn't justified. Also they're side of ranch price is robbery for $2 you get a tiny little nothing and then for a smaller than normal pizza place their "large size" of ranch was $4!!! It's not even amazing ranch at that. For their price gouging on the ranch alone I will not be going back. There are so many other pizza carryout options so close by where it doesn't feel like a rip off.
Cory Truesdell
REALLY good pizza. The ingredients on the BLT tasted very fresh. Cherry tomatoes put it over the top. Highly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Marcus D'Onofrio
It’s such a great addition to the neighborhood, reasonable on price. Best ranch in town, they finish the round pies on a screen & it really makes a difference. My favorite way to fill a pizza craving cheers y’
Vegan Hawaii 5-0 was SO good. I had to keep myself from eating the whole pizza. Service was quick and super friendly. The pizza looked great and was dee-lish. I'll order again for sureVegetarian options: So easy to swap out for vegetarian and vegan optionsDietary restrictions: They handle vegan options so well. It's nice to be able to go to a place that understands the vegan diet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, Vegan Hawaii
Robin Lillibridge
Dietary restrictions: Great options for dietary restrictions, including vegan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Herb Mayo, Margherita, Large Icebox Bar
Emily Cullinan
So happy to have a Pie Sci in the neighborhood !! Even though it’s only been open short while my friends and I have been getting it on the weekends. I love the Cajun crust option! Staff very friendly too. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mo Marie
First time trying out this location and it was great. Got the Baby Got BBQ pizza with vegetarian protein and it was delicious. I love that they don't charge extra to sub out for veggie protein too. So happy to have this location in the neighborhood! It did not disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Zielinski
Got a couple of pies and a salad. The pizzas were super creative, and tasty. One of the most interesting pies I have had. Strangely, the salad was what blew away expectations. Best salad I have gotten from a pizza place.Really excited to have this great spot in Oak Park.
Pi Sci was very disappointing for all the hype it receives.Cheese Pizza - Good flavored square pie. $3 for beef pepperoni and you only get two one each slice (~19¢/slice) which is sad.Bread Sticks - Terrible. Extremely thin and hard as a rock. Most of them were inedible. The garlic cream cheese was pretty good but nothing special.Cinnamon (Evil) Bread - Looked about 50x better than it tasted. At times it felt like I was doing the 2012 cinnamon challenge. This was also way too much bread, could’ve used some of it on the normal breadsticks.Dietary restrictions: vegan and halal options
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
After reading about them in metro times in the newspaper, we thought we’d give them a try tonight. This is the worst pizza I’ve had in the Oak Park area in a long time the cheese pizza it was empty and lifeless and didn’t have enough sauce. Papa Romano’s down. The street is a lot better than this..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
I get pizza a lot. I’m very happy this place opened up right next down the block from me because this is my new spot. So
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For some reason, I found the online ordering a little difficult. So with my first added frustration, I just called. When I did get there, I waited, and the gentleman at the front looked a little confused with all the people there forgot I was there for a few minutes and said your pizzas ready. But unfortunately, they forgot to put the salsa Verde on my pizza so the pizza was a little bland and for calling it, El Pastor, they needed to put some of that on the pizza. If there was one little bite on each slice of pork, that was a a lot. I'm sure they'll get the wrinkles out of the business. I hope they do it soon.
Having been a previous patron of the Detroit location, I was psyched to try this place! I know they recently opened and wanted to wait a bit before coming, but tonight was the night. I ordered online and I found the add on descriptions slightly confusing. I had to call to ask about what VAL honey is (it's "hot" honey, more on that in a minute) and instead of the normal "light, normal, extra" options, it's small or large drizzle with zero clarification about what that even looks like. They also don't specify how many slices are in each pizza size. The other issue I had is that they offer option to get text updates but I got none. Obviously, I was hungry and it estimated at least an hour which seemed like a long time considering how late it was. But, I figured it's Friday so that's probably why. I got there and it was ready, but for who knows how long? I eventually got a text long after I was home saying it was ready. Might be worth reworking this system. I got the square pizza, and it's actually cooked perfectly. Expensive to add each item but that's about the standard now. Their "hot honey" isn't super great but it's definitely spicy! I was hoping it would actually taste like honey but it really is just sriracha. Breadsticks were hard and tasted like pita chips more than anything and they don't automatically offer pizza sauce as a dipping sauce (why?) so I elected to get the garlic cream cheese. However, it was almost frozen even with the 10 min drive home. Disappointing. Overall, I don't think that I'll be back for awhile. I'm sure they have some kinks to work out and hopefully they'll do that.
Soaked in oil and undercooked. Will try again but not happy with what we
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Great! Our order was made quickly and everything was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was very excited to try Pie Sci last week, but left overall not impressed. Everything was fine, not great, just fine. Nothing about the two pizza's we tried were unique or mind blowing (square pepperoni & square Baby Got BBQ). I can understand the hype if you have dietary restrictions, but for the average person the higher price of everything isn't justified. Also they're side of ranch price is robbery for $2 you get a tiny little nothing and then for a smaller than normal pizza place their "large size" of ranch was $4!!! It's not even amazing ranch at that. For their price gouging on the ranch alone I will not be going back. There are so many other pizza carryout options so close by where it doesn't feel like a rip off.
REALLY good pizza. The ingredients on the BLT tasted very fresh. Cherry tomatoes put it over the top. Highly
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
It’s such a great addition to the neighborhood, reasonable on price. Best ranch in town, they finish the round pies on a screen & it really makes a difference. My favorite way to fill a pizza craving cheers y’
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Vegan Hawaii 5-0 was SO good. I had to keep myself from eating the whole pizza. Service was quick and super friendly. The pizza looked great and was dee-lish. I'll order again for sureVegetarian options: So easy to swap out for vegetarian and vegan optionsDietary restrictions: They handle vegan options so well. It's nice to be able to go to a place that understands the vegan diet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, Vegan Hawaii
Dietary restrictions: Great options for dietary restrictions, including vegan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Herb Mayo, Margherita, Large Icebox Bar
So happy to have a Pie Sci in the neighborhood !! Even though it’s only been open short while my friends and I have been getting it on the weekends. I love the Cajun crust option! Staff very friendly too. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying out this location and it was great. Got the Baby Got BBQ pizza with vegetarian protein and it was delicious. I love that they don't charge extra to sub out for veggie protein too. So happy to have this location in the neighborhood! It did not disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a couple of pies and a salad. The pizzas were super creative, and tasty. One of the most interesting pies I have had. Strangely, the salad was what blew away expectations. Best salad I have gotten from a pizza place.Really excited to have this great spot in Oak Park.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5