Restaurants near Otter Lake

“The burgers are fantastic. Karaoke on Friday night with DJ Paul is always a blast and of course the best bartender in the area works there as well. Kaili is the best bartender.”

“Noone in my entire life has ever impressed me with coffee. I drink it daily, but to me, coffee is just coffee.... until I had Tony's Banana Foster Coffee. It is amazing, as is the cozy store with breakfast and treats, ambiance and charm and the staff is the best! It is definately worth the drive and always great to support local businesses!”

“Best pizza around! I talked my wife into a milkshake from the Corner Cone and we decided to grab a pizza for lunch. The Kitchen Sink pizza was amazing, and we had dinner for two days!”

“Stopped on the way home from north. Breakfast was very good, no complaints. Took a cinnamon roll home, they had them in bags on the counter-didnt know they were day old-would have never bought them! Wasn't told they were day old. They should have been cheaper too! When we had it that night with our coffee, it was hard and dried out. We couldn't eat it. Not that we expected from all the reviews. Just beware if you're going to buy...ask how old they are and how stale and hard. We learned the hard way. Will stop for breakfast if out that way, but not buying any baked goods, I'll stick to a good bakery!!!”

“Def recommend the corner cone! They have a great selection and friendly staff. My son dropped his ice cream right after getting it and they remade it for him ☺️”

“Years ago the Benny's location was a dive bar under a different name. It was bought and the place has been gutted and rebuilt. It's all tastefully new inside. Cozy place to have a cocktail of your liking with good conversation.”

“J U S T got pizza , 1st time ever crossed their threshold . Great friendly service..... and pizza was R E A L L Y GOOD !!! We'll be back?”

“Love this place! They have the best nachos and a huge variety of ice cream and always great service 😊”

“The bread bowl with pasta is freaking amazing! Mario is by far the best pizza/pasta man around! Thank you Mario and team for always making our food with love and care. We so greatly appreciate you!”

“Thank you for a great lunch today! Highly recommend the Van Wagoner sub with fries! It was delicious!”

“Best pizza in the world for the past at least 35 years 😭🙏🏻”

“awesome service great tasting pizza and more at a fair price”

“Love the place great food and service until tonight bartender was a stuck up didn’t want to serve anyone didn’t lke us playing music not going back for a while fat chick with glasses think it was owners daughter ran 5 customers bout right away”

“Definitely my favorite hangout”

“I just wanted to thank the Otisville Hotel for hosting our Celebration of Life for my brother-in-law Jim Jaissle's memorial service. The upstairs is newly updated and was very nice to host our family and friends. The owners are wonderful people and they made our celebration very special. Otisville Hotel - definitely recommend ✅️”

“great atmosphere, good people and amazing food.”

“first time ordering X-large pizza and salad for family dinner. I highly recommend”

“Excellent food that is made fresh daily! Everything is very reasonably priced, with large portions. Great service!! We came across Judy's food truck while on vacation and we loved it so much we came back two times!! Highly recommended!!”

“Always great service and great food”

“Mo gooder atmosphere friendly service cold beer”

“Best place around for bowling and entertainment! Lane & Meredith are the absolute best! Check it out today; & again next week!”

“The perch and cod fish dinners are delicious!!”

“I love this subway! I have gone here almost weekly for over a year. The staff is so friendly and recognizes me when I come in and remembers most of my order. It is just such a friendly atmosphere! It is a highlight of my workday to go in to get my lunch.”

“go there most Thursdays just to see Heather working the bar. She's the best .I have made some cool friends there, awesome!”

“Great food and great atmosphere! We were visiting from Ohio and it was close to where we were staying. So glad we stopped, the food is great! Be sure to stop by if your in the area, we will be back!”

“Superb food great atmosphere”

“Always amazing in store, ordered delivery today. Had some issues with my order. They resolved as quick as possible with a perfect response oriented on customer service. That's rare in today's world. Give them your business. You won't regret it.”

“This location made the best quesadilla I've had since the early 2000s. It was fresh, hot, and yummy. My crunchy taco tasted amazing, the shell was fresh.

Got my food pretty quickly. I used the kiosk to order. Lobby was clean. Plenty of parking.

Keep in mind fellow patrons, it's one way in the parking area, you don't leave through the entrance!”

“Not a fan of McDonald's but...
This McDonald's in Otisville is the best one in the county. 10 out of 10 times my food has been fresh and hot when going there. No other McDonald's I know of can match this.”