Murdick's Fudge and Ice Cream

Absolutely love their carmel corn with pecans! Staff is very friendly!

I think I was his first retail customer for Dec 2025. It appeared the store was closed for the season. I was skeptical about the ice cream and popcorn being fresh. I was surprised. Both were excellent. Worth going back or ordering online. Service was outstanding.

Service wasn't very friendly or welcoming. Quality of ice cream wasn't very high. The milkshakes tasted like milk. Not somewhere I will be checking out again next time I'm in town

This place was outstanding. This was my first time in Petoskey, and I’m glad this was one of my first stops. Good quality treats, and friendly customer service.

Went by for an afternoon ice cream. The waffle cone was great and the two flavors I got were delicious! The pumpkin cheesecake ice cream was my favorite! Super creamy with large chunks of cheese cake. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a great ice cream experience.

Best fudge in the city, best selection I believe too! Also...was thr best priced that we found!

A charming little ice cream shop with delicious flavors. We stopped in today with our family and talked to Paul (the owner) about some family Affholter ties and he was very friendly as were his daughters working. Definitely recommend stopping here while in downtown Petoskey!

We got ice cream here. They had lots of good flavors as well as popcorn. The pricing was reasonable as well.

The ice cream was delicious, but what really stood out was Eli, one of the staff members. He was super friendly with a great personality, which made the visit even better!

Fudge was extremely hard. This establishment should use plastic bags and not wax paper inside the boxes.

We went in at almost 9 pm and they had quite the line, but they moved them through efficiently. The two young people working the counters were super nice and patient. It cost us $30 for two waffle cones, a small cake cone and a small cup, which seemed pricey. Other than that, it was good.

Delicious. Many cool flavors

Great ice cream! Everyone was very satisfied with their choices. The waffle cone is one of the best I've had and stayed crispy. Black cherry ice cream is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Got some ice cream here at the recommendation of another store near by and it was delicious! Nice variety of flavors and even offer real dog ice creams instead of just giving them vanilla or whipped cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We enjoyed our visit as a family during our vacation to Petoskey …

Great ice cream , great employees , great business…

Highly recommend and thank you again ?