We rented the space above this bakery and it was delicious. Cookies were so good and fresh, the brownie was good as well. Very welcoming and decently priced. Definitely will go back the next time we are in town!
Pam McKelvey
We ordered a French vanilla 6 inch cake with butter cream icing and fresh strawberries for a small family party. It was so beautiful and so delicious! We can’t thank you enough! We will most certainly order again and tell all of our friends!
Randy Combs
Visited Cookies on Call twice this past weekend. Really, that's all that needs to be said, yes?
Amy E. Fullerton, MA
Absolutely delicious and very fairly priced. The sugar cookies were my favorite 🍪
Millard Fillmore
Great 🍪 cookies! Good selection of fresh cookies at a fair price. Perhaps the best food value in the whole town. Very friendly woman working the counter while also doing various things while not hesitating for a friendly chat with strangers.
Moriah S.
Abby made a BEAUTIFUL and delicious custom cake for my friend’s Shrek themed bachelorette party. She was super responsive and helpful with answering questions. The ordering and pickup process were smooth and she even helped me get the cake to my car. I can’t thank her and her team enough!!
Sarah Rose
Swung in for a sweet treat after dinner and was pleasantly surprised! They had a good assortment of cookies and other desserts. The carrot cake cake ball was SO GOOD! All 4 cookies I got were soft and delicious but my favorite was between the chocolate salted caramel and snickerdoodle. Will definitely be back for more!
Chantal Breedlove
Went in while the young ladies were handling a total Karen very professionally during a weekend vacation. The Fall Out is a must - a perfect menois a trois of snickerdoodle, gingersnap, and sugar cookie. My only regret is not getting a dozen. No photos unless we do an ultrasound.
Michi L
Great customer service. The strawberry turnover was incredible.
Janet Bidwell
Variety of freshly made cookies you just don't want to miss out on. The cookies were so big and delicious! Final Score: Cookies on Call (5-Star) My Cookies (3-Star) 😁
Great cookies and almond biscotti!! Must try Butler’s Pantry cookie - DELICIOUS! A perfect combo of sweet and salty.
Alexandra Hazen
Cute shops in downtown South Haven! They have lots of cookies to choose from. I had the chocolate coconut, which was a chocolate chip cookie with toasted coconut in top. It had big chocolate chunks. I also had the double chocolate cookie, which was a chocolate cookie with big chocolate chunks. Both cookies were good! They were crunchy along the edges and gooey in the center. Yum! The ladies running the store were super nice.
Mario Bledsoe
(Wow!) (Kind service!) (extremely nice!)
There’s truly nothing quite like indulging in homemade treats crafted with love! My experience at Cookies on Call in South Haven, Michigan, was absolutely delightful! This charming little gem is the perfect spot to satisfy your cookie cravings. Whether you're feeling happy, sad, or even a bit angry, these cookies are like a hug in dessert form, ready to lift your spirits!
The food was incredible! With so many mouth-watering pastries to choose from, I couldn’t help but fall in love with the Chunk cookie—it’s my absolute favorite! I can't wait to dive into their brownies next; I just know they’ll be outstanding, too!
And let me tell you about the service! Abby was simply fantastic, guiding me through the menu with so much enthusiasm and passion for the cookies. Her warm spirit made the experience even more enjoyable, and I truly appreciate her help!
The atmosphere? Just stunning! The delightful aromas, the beautiful scenery, and charming decor all came together to create a cozy haven. What a beautiful bakery! I can’t recommend it enough!
I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Cookies on Call. Give this bakery a try!
Vegetarian options: Not sure about vegetarian options.
Parking: It was easy finding parking during the fall and winter, but probably difficult during the summer as this is downtown.
Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly!
Wheelchair accessibility: It appears wheelchair accessible, but it is a smaller space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Susan Arner
Cookies and scones are delicious! I need to come back for some cheesecake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Bentley Thomas
Yummmmy! I was walking downtown and happened to pass by here. I love a good cookie, so I went inside. I’m so glad I did! I bought 2 cookies and a brownie. I ate the chocolate chip once I left the store. It was so good, I turned right back around for a second one! One of the best and I’m a baker! So good.
We rented the space above this bakery and it was delicious. Cookies were so good and fresh, the brownie was good as well. Very welcoming and decently priced. Definitely will go back the next time we are in town!
We ordered a French vanilla 6 inch cake with butter cream icing and fresh strawberries for a small family party. It was so beautiful and so delicious! We can’t thank you enough! We will most certainly order again and tell all of our friends!
Visited Cookies on Call twice this past weekend. Really, that's all that needs to be said, yes?
Absolutely delicious and very fairly priced. The sugar cookies were my favorite 🍪
Great 🍪 cookies! Good selection of fresh cookies at a fair price. Perhaps the best food value in the whole town. Very friendly woman working the counter while also doing various things while not hesitating for a friendly chat with strangers.
Abby made a BEAUTIFUL and delicious custom cake for my friend’s Shrek themed bachelorette party. She was super responsive and helpful with answering questions. The ordering and pickup process were smooth and she even helped me get the cake to my car. I can’t thank her and her team enough!!
Swung in for a sweet treat after dinner and was pleasantly surprised! They had a good assortment of cookies and other desserts. The carrot cake cake ball was SO GOOD! All 4 cookies I got were soft and delicious but my favorite was between the chocolate salted caramel and snickerdoodle. Will definitely be back for more!
Went in while the young ladies were handling a total Karen very professionally during a weekend vacation. The Fall Out is a must - a perfect menois a trois of snickerdoodle, gingersnap, and sugar cookie. My only regret is not getting a dozen. No photos unless we do an ultrasound.
Great customer service. The strawberry turnover was incredible.
Variety of freshly made cookies you just don't want to miss out on. The cookies were so big and delicious! Final Score:
Cookies on Call (5-Star)
My Cookies (3-Star) 😁
Restaurantji Recommends
Great cookies and almond biscotti!! Must try Butler’s Pantry cookie - DELICIOUS! A perfect combo of sweet and salty.
Cute shops in downtown South Haven! They have lots of cookies to choose from. I had the chocolate coconut, which was a chocolate chip cookie with toasted coconut in top. It had big chocolate chunks. I also had the double chocolate cookie, which was a chocolate cookie with big chocolate chunks. Both cookies were good! They were crunchy along the edges and gooey in the center. Yum! The ladies running the store were super nice.
(Wow!)
(Kind service!)
(extremely nice!)
There’s truly nothing quite like indulging in homemade treats crafted with love! My experience at Cookies on Call in South Haven, Michigan, was absolutely delightful! This charming little gem is the perfect spot to satisfy your cookie cravings. Whether you're feeling happy, sad, or even a bit angry, these cookies are like a hug in dessert form, ready to lift your spirits!
The food was incredible! With so many mouth-watering pastries to choose from, I couldn’t help but fall in love with the Chunk cookie—it’s my absolute favorite! I can't wait to dive into their brownies next; I just know they’ll be outstanding, too!
And let me tell you about the service! Abby was simply fantastic, guiding me through the menu with so much enthusiasm and passion for the cookies. Her warm spirit made the experience even more enjoyable, and I truly appreciate her help!
The atmosphere? Just stunning! The delightful aromas, the beautiful scenery, and charming decor all came together to create a cozy haven. What a beautiful bakery! I can’t recommend it enough!
I thoroughly enjoyed my experience at Cookies on Call. Give this bakery a try!
Vegetarian options: Not sure about vegetarian options.
Parking: It was easy finding parking during the fall and winter, but probably difficult during the summer as this is downtown.
Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly!
Wheelchair accessibility: It appears wheelchair accessible, but it is a smaller space.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Cookies and scones are delicious! I need to come back for some cheesecake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Yummmmy! I was walking downtown and happened to pass by here. I love a good cookie, so I went inside. I’m so glad I did! I bought 2 cookies and a brownie. I ate the chocolate chip once I left the store. It was so good, I turned right back around for a second one! One of the best and I’m a baker! So good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Loading...