Food and service were excellent. There were a couple of specific instructions at our table which were dealt with correctly.
Stephanie
Canceled a reservation at a different restaurant to dine here for my birthday. Did not realize it was a “show” night. When I asked the hostess if it would be a problem that we had 5 in our group instead of 4, I was a little shocked when she said actually yes it was. She checked in with who I assume was her manager who was facing me, so when the hostess told her we wanted to add one more, the look on her face said it all. You would have thought I asked to accommodate 20 people instead of four. They were able to seat us, and the dining room was packed because it was a show night. Every time someone came to our table they made sure to mention that we had 5 instead of 4. It was getting comical! Within a half hour the show was starting and the dining room cleared out. I'm certain that we were the only group left in the entire restaurant. We had already received appetizers but realized our waitress completely disappeared. The entire dining room was turned over- cleaned, reset with clean tablecloths, plates, napkins, cutlery and glasses. Meanwhile, our water glasses were bone dry and we all started to think our waitress went home for the night! We finally asked for her and she showed back up- bringing our soups and salads finally. When she brought the dinner plates she AGAIN mentioned our group of “5 instead of 4.” Like ok we get it!! Usually they have a nice ambiance of music, but because it was “ Bob Seger” tribute night, they had his top 5 songs playing on repeat for the whole night. We were right under a speaker so that was a little annoying, but understandable I guess. I think they could have turned the music volume down since the room had cleared out but that's just my personal preference. One last time when she brought the bill, she mentioned our larger group but thankfully she did point out that gratuity had already been added to the check because it was show night. Had she not pointed it out way may not have noticed. All in all great food but wow! The attitude!
Karen Noel
We went to the Bee Gees. Had dinner in the theater. Nowhere to put your food. It's served on plastic plates. Dessert plastic plates. Way too dark in the sitting area. It was very expensive for a mediocre experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Treasure Black
I enjoyed an evening out a great murder mystery with an excellent three course meal everything was excellent I most definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lil Mre
This is a well known landmark in the community. We have always received stellar service and amazing Old School Italian food. In happenstance we realized today that it is possible we had found ourselves dining on evenings that coordinated with scheduled live shows, that they were full to capacity and making a reservation early on the as recommended. This Saturday there were no shows scheduled and they were slow. I do not know why unless folks , even myself due to past experience, think Andiamo’s is always so busy that we could not get a last minute reservation? The food is always amazing in the restaurant. Not only the traditional Italian dishes but the quality of their steaks are Prime! The New York Steak cuts and eats as tender as a Fillet at other restaurants,seriously! Their Fillet is delicious too. Their soups are a must. The White Onion Soup is our fav. If you enjoy French Onion Soup you will enjoy this. Think French Onion Soup that just became a little easier to eat. LOL I have yet to order something we did not thoroughly enjoy. The table side Spaghetti Carbonara is a must. Great selection of deserts. The Carrot Cake, Tiramisu and the best Spumoni ice cream are shareable! Service here has remained intact as you would expect at a fine dining establishment. They have maintained their standards in an era where so much seems to be going to the wayside when it comes to dining out. Prices appear on point if not better than most. Portions remain better than most. Very nice bar area. Clean and classy interior. Thank you Andiamo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ravioli Di Stagione Meat Ravioli, Bread Basket, Tiramisu
Marko Johnson
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Amazing Service from Amanda!
We had such a great time at Andiamo’s, and Amanda made the whole experience even better! She was super friendly, attentive, and just fun to talk to. You can tell she really cares about her guests — our drinks were always full, food came out perfectly, and she gave awesome menu suggestions.
It’s not often you get service this good. Amanda made us feel welcome from start to finish, and we’ll definitely be back to see her again. Thanks for making our night, Amanda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carretta Cooke
I enjoy the nightclub like atmosphere of Andiamo. The concerts held here are fun and staged well. Hoping they establish a jazz series there as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Cheryl Roseman
Attended a Masquerade Murder Mystery dinner event. The atmosphere, service and dinner was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kenneth Byrd
This a wonderful venue The staff was super nice My family went for a murder mystery dinner, we had a great time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yasuyuki
The best part of this dinner was a server! She was extremely nice and gave us a very pleasant moment! Since she was super nice, I don't remember how good food was....😅
Service was slow and our waitress was very forgetful not really friendly, Food was good not fantastic. Overall it was ok a little pricey.
Brenda
The food was fantastic & the show was outstanding. I would recommend Andiamo Warren for a great night out.
Scott
Excellent food, proper amount of attention from the staff, allowing us, as a first date, time to talk.
Kathleen
The usual impeccable service was a bit off. Seemed like they weren't expecting the amount of diners they had and could have used another server.
Anthony
Not the Andiamo it was created to be and mediocre at best now days. Service is poor and have came back several times to the original location only to be disappointed again and again. Food is no where near the quality it used to be and better options around. “Basic” service expectations don't exist period. This is my 5th try in a year and it's clear Andiamos shelf life is over
Food and service were excellent. There were a couple of specific instructions at our table which were dealt with correctly.
Canceled a reservation at a different restaurant to dine here for my birthday. Did not realize it was a “show” night. When I asked the hostess if it would be a problem that we had 5 in our group instead of 4, I was a little shocked when she said actually yes it was. She checked in with who I assume was her manager who was facing me, so when the hostess told her we wanted to add one more, the look on her face said it all. You would have thought I asked to accommodate 20 people instead of four. They were able to seat us, and the dining room was packed because it was a show night. Every time someone came to our table they made sure to mention that we had 5 instead of 4. It was getting comical! Within a half hour the show was starting and the dining room cleared out. I'm certain that we were the only group left in the entire restaurant. We had already received appetizers but realized our waitress completely disappeared. The entire dining room was turned over- cleaned, reset with clean tablecloths, plates, napkins, cutlery and glasses. Meanwhile, our water glasses were bone dry and we all started to think our waitress went home for the night! We finally asked for her and she showed back up- bringing our soups and salads finally. When she brought the dinner plates she AGAIN mentioned our group of “5 instead of 4.” Like ok we get it!! Usually they have a nice ambiance of music, but because it was “ Bob Seger” tribute night, they had his top 5 songs playing on repeat for the whole night. We were right under a speaker so that was a little annoying, but understandable I guess. I think they could have turned the music volume down since the room had cleared out but that's just my personal preference. One last time when she brought the bill, she mentioned our larger group but thankfully she did point out that gratuity had already been added to the check because it was show night. Had she not pointed it out way may not have noticed. All in all great food but wow! The attitude!
We went to the Bee Gees. Had dinner in the theater. Nowhere to put your food. It's served on plastic plates. Dessert plastic plates. Way too dark in the sitting area. It was very expensive for a mediocre experience.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
I enjoyed an evening out a great murder mystery with an excellent three course meal everything was excellent I most definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a well known landmark in the community. We have always received stellar service and amazing Old School Italian food. In happenstance we realized today that it is possible we had found ourselves dining on evenings that coordinated with scheduled live shows, that they were full to capacity and making a reservation early on the as recommended. This Saturday there were no shows scheduled and they were slow. I do not know why unless folks , even myself due to past experience, think Andiamo’s is always so busy that we could not get a last minute reservation? The food is always amazing in the restaurant. Not only the traditional Italian dishes but the quality of their steaks are Prime! The New York Steak cuts and eats as tender as a Fillet at other restaurants,seriously! Their Fillet is delicious too. Their soups are a must. The White Onion Soup is our fav. If you enjoy French Onion Soup you will enjoy this. Think French Onion Soup that just became a little easier to eat. LOL I have yet to order something we did not thoroughly enjoy. The table side Spaghetti Carbonara is a must. Great selection of deserts. The Carrot Cake, Tiramisu and the best Spumoni ice cream are shareable! Service here has remained intact as you would expect at a fine dining establishment. They have maintained their standards in an era where so much seems to be going to the wayside when it comes to dining out. Prices appear on point if not better than most. Portions remain better than most. Very nice bar area. Clean and classy interior. Thank you Andiamo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ravioli Di Stagione Meat Ravioli, Bread Basket, Tiramisu
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Amazing Service from Amanda!
We had such a great time at Andiamo’s, and Amanda made the whole experience even better! She was super friendly, attentive, and just fun to talk to. You can tell she really cares about her guests — our drinks were always full, food came out perfectly, and she gave awesome menu suggestions.
It’s not often you get service this good. Amanda made us feel welcome from start to finish, and we’ll definitely be back to see her again. Thanks for making our night, Amanda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I enjoy the nightclub like atmosphere of Andiamo. The concerts held here are fun and staged well. Hoping they establish a jazz series there as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Attended a Masquerade Murder Mystery dinner event. The atmosphere, service and dinner was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This a wonderful venue
The staff was super nice
My family went for a murder mystery dinner, we had a great time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best part of this dinner was a server! She was extremely nice and gave us a very pleasant moment! Since she was super nice, I don't remember how good food was....😅
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was slow and our waitress was very forgetful not really friendly, Food was good not fantastic. Overall it was ok a little pricey.
The food was fantastic & the show was outstanding. I would recommend Andiamo Warren for a great night out.
Excellent food, proper amount of attention from the staff, allowing us, as a first date, time to talk.
The usual impeccable service was a bit off. Seemed like they weren't expecting the amount of diners they had and could have used another server.
Not the Andiamo it was created to be and mediocre at best now days. Service is poor and have came back several times to the original location only to be disappointed again and again. Food is no where near the quality it used to be and better options around. “Basic” service expectations don't exist period. This is my 5th try in a year and it's clear Andiamos shelf life is over
Loading...