McColley's Pie Company is now Great Lakes Pie Company, LLC
Lewis McColley, 8392 Elk Lake Rd, Williamsburg
(231) 267-2225
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Sad we drove pretty far and wasted an hour of our vacation coming to buy a cherry pie. Based on google reviews and store hours listed. 🫤
Great selection of fresh fruits. I walked away with plums, peaches & pears and you can’t leave without the goodies!!! The BEST dried cherries I’ve ever had (perfect balance of tart with sweet), and 2 mini fresh baked pies. 1 apple and 1 cherry that were freshly baked that Saturday morning. Mmmm mmmm delish!!!
Lady working the stand was kinda quiet, not very talkative, but she seemed nice :-) I’ll be coming back here soon to stock up on more fresh fruit to make gift baskets before leaving for my hunting trip out west. I can’t wait to try the jam and salsa!
Thanks for making great, local yummy treats. I live down south, so the drive is definitely worth it.
Parking: U shaped driveway with parking and what looks like additional parking near the barn.
Kid-friendliness: Safe distance away from the road.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Apple
Quality fruits and vegetables. Try the pickled asparagus! Pies are great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything we got was super delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Random stop, excellent stop! Picked up some fresh cherries and a delicious American pie! Wish we were closer! Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought one of their pies at farmers market and the crust tasted like bacon. It was inedible, and we were left disappointed. The fruit filling was good though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Cute little roadside market with lots of goodies from fresh apples, pies, and jams
Bought a cherry pie today and had a piece with a little vanilla ice cream for dessert. So good! Home-made goodness at a reasonable price! Definitely worth the trip!
Best products! Best fruit stand!
Great pies. Bought an apple and a peach pie. Both were awesome.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent pies, worth the price!!
If Grandma was a good cook and really knew how to bake these pies are just like that.
Best homemade fresh-fruit pies. Lattice, crumb, and crisp topping. Traditional and seasonal flavors.
Nice stand offering fresh fruit and home made pies. My favorites pies are lattice apple and cherry.
Loading...