NYC Pizza Co.

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! They are not open any more but they are still taking online orders! Now I’m going thru the process of trying to dispute the charge with my bank. Not fun at all, and very irresponsible of ownership to still be taking orders at this time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered 2 pizzas for pickup. When we arrived we went into the bar and was told that the pizza restaurant was not open and hasn’t been for about a week. Even though they were closed they were still accepting orders online.

Service: 1

Awesome food, amazing chef driven treats. Crushed it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Everything Chris makes is amazing! The strawberry shortcake is one of my favorites!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just had the cheesy bacon fries and they were amazing

The pizza was delicious and it was nice to get drinks at Hard Times while waiting

This pizza was delicious! Great service!

Parking: Street parking not the greatest

Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair accessible. Snow not scooped.

Best thin crust pizza I've had in a very long time.. great sauce made there daily good fresh ingredients and the customer service is fantastic have been ordering every weekend and will continue to do so

This pizza is simply amazing and the pricing is competitive with other local pizza options in town. The style of pizza is different from anything else we currently have in Bemidji and it's truly excellent. The crust is perfect and the sauce and toppings are also very high quality. Their house-made ranch is also excellent. Service is friendly and fast. If you haven't tried them yet, I highly recommend it! Wishing for success and longevity for these new business owners. They have definitely made a strong start!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers

These folks have just about the best meatball sub I've ever had. You know it'll be good when it comes with a stack of napkins! Also, the Upper East side Stromboli was spot on. Had a test run for work lunch before ordering for the whole family...but I think that'll happen in the near future! Great job

Have had the pasta, and the pizza at least 10 times.. so delicious! I watch them toss the crust in the air like a pro! Watched them hand chop all the ingredients! Even the basil fresh off a stem! I highly recommend the food! Remember it's NY crust! Fold it or roll it! YUM!

Vegetarian options: They have a lot of options.. they make so many fun combos!

Bought a couple of pizzas for supper. The whole family enjoyed them. Like the thin crust and lots of flavor. Nice to have another pizzeria in the neighborhood. Highly recommend!

Best pizza in town there is no one better! Try it you'll like it!

I love the pizza here it really slays. I recommend the cheese pizza love it and the workers are so nice.

Great pizza! Friendly and nice place to eat at.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5