My favorite pizza, but lately far too much oregano.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
terry pernsteiner
Fabulous pizza. The best in Biwabik. I ask for well done and the crust is perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron V.
Great pizza, fast service and always friendly. Sometimes you do have to call a few times when they are busy.
Ashley Moreland
Best subs around. Poor Gary's special is my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gina B.
BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!!!! OMG! No idea what Jacob H. was talking about, he was probably the idiot who got in a fight & punched an old dude on Sunday when we were there. There were 12 of us, 8 ordered pizza, the rest ordered apps & everything was amazing! Came out fast & hot, workers were super busy but did an amazing job! It is connected to a pub where the fight was but that was also handled right away & I swear they called him Jacob before kicking him out.....Jacob needs to grow up & get a life, Poor Gary's is definitely someplace I'm coming back to!
Jacob H.
Poor Gary's lives up to its name. These guys don't know their ass from a tea kettle. We ordered takeout and the order was completely wrong. That's one thing and probably can be attributed to a immature and inexperienced staff, but the pizza quality is also lacking. A premade pizza dough that resembled cardboard is all you have to look forward to with these guys. Pretty disappointing and there's plenty of other options in the area.
Nicolas Powell
Got a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and there was barely any mushrooms. Couldn't even taste them.
We ordered a house special pizza to be delivered. The pizza was excellent- thin, crispy crust, great sauce, toppings were really good.Delivery was right on time, very friendly and polite.Highly recommend!
Lisa Seliskar
Had fond memories of Poor Gary's 10 - 20 years ago, so decided to drive from Eveleth to Biwabik for a change from our go-to Snickers, and order carryout pizza. Got it home (10 minutes) and while the toppings were fine, the crust was flavorless and not crisp at all. Then we went to the Vermillion Club for dinner, because my mom loved Poor Gary's and they serve it there, and we got fresh food (dine-in) and 3 different pizzas, and they were the same as the Biwabik location. Floppy, bland crust. So, I don't know what changed over the years, but it is not what is used to be. Sad, because there's not a lot of GOOD pizza options around here, and they used to be one of three. Sorry Poor Gary's, but I think you need to go back to your old/original recipe crust, or cook them longer?
Boot Loops
Service was ok the honky-tonk and hangover where playing their buttons off will be chasing them around for sure.
Tim Jacobsen
Pizza was really good. Will definitely go here again when I am in town.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Ratzlaff
Not HAPPY, guy who answered the phone was rude, also person who delivered was rude, gave a $10.00 tip along with delivery charge, he didn't even say have a good night. SO SAD. I'm a Christian, what happened to go good manners, we are paying their wages, if they didn't have people like me they wouldn't have a business.
My favorite pizza, but lately far too much oregano.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Fabulous pizza. The best in Biwabik. I ask for well done and the crust is perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, fast service and always friendly. Sometimes you do have to call a few times when they are busy.
Best subs around. Poor Gary's special is my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!!!! OMG! No idea what Jacob H. was talking about, he was probably the idiot who got in a fight & punched an old dude on Sunday when we were there. There were 12 of us, 8 ordered pizza, the rest ordered apps & everything was amazing! Came out fast & hot, workers were super busy but did an amazing job! It is connected to a pub where the fight was but that was also handled right away & I swear they called him Jacob before kicking him out.....Jacob needs to grow up & get a life, Poor Gary's is definitely someplace I'm coming back to!
Poor Gary's lives up to its name. These guys don't know their ass from a tea kettle. We ordered takeout and the order was completely wrong. That's one thing and probably can be attributed to a immature and inexperienced staff, but the pizza quality is also lacking. A premade pizza dough that resembled cardboard is all you have to look forward to with these guys. Pretty disappointing and there's plenty of other options in the area.
Got a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and there was barely any mushrooms. Couldn't even taste them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great pizza that's always on
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good pizza when we order.
First time ordering excellent pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered a house special pizza to be delivered. The pizza was excellent- thin, crispy crust, great sauce, toppings were really good.Delivery was right on time, very friendly and polite.Highly recommend!
Had fond memories of Poor Gary's 10 - 20 years ago, so decided to drive from Eveleth to Biwabik for a change from our go-to Snickers, and order carryout pizza. Got it home (10 minutes) and while the toppings were fine, the crust was flavorless and not crisp at all. Then we went to the Vermillion Club for dinner, because my mom loved Poor Gary's and they serve it there, and we got fresh food (dine-in) and 3 different pizzas, and they were the same as the Biwabik location. Floppy, bland crust. So, I don't know what changed over the years, but it is not what is used to be. Sad, because there's not a lot of GOOD pizza options around here, and they used to be one of three. Sorry Poor Gary's, but I think you need to go back to your old/original recipe crust, or cook them longer?
Service was ok the honky-tonk and hangover where playing their buttons off will be chasing them around for sure.
Pizza was really good. Will definitely go here again when I am in town.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not HAPPY, guy who answered the phone was rude, also person who delivered was rude, gave a $10.00 tip along with delivery charge, he didn't even say have a good night. SO SAD. I'm a Christian, what happened to go good manners, we are paying their wages, if they didn't have people like me they wouldn't have a business.